Customer reviews for Member's Mark Fat Free Milk (1 gal.) forMember's Mark Fat Free Milk (1 gal.)
Most helpful positive review
10 customers found this helpful
4 out of 5 stars review
Verified Purchase
The milk is amazing but the container is awful!
LWhite
Most helpful negative review
3 customers found this helpful
1 out of 5 stars review
Verified Purchase
Smashed
Family of six
1,633 reviews
Filter by:
Sort by:
- 1 out of 5 stars review4/4/2022The milk and price are good. The container is hard to pour from and it is impossible to get the plastic seal off the top. We have to use a pliers to pull it off or a knife to cut it out.
Hate the container!
Anne - 1 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase9/22/2020This milk was received as a pickup order with only a few days left before expiration. Within 2 days the milk was no longer good. Not my first negatives experience when buying milk at Sam’s.
Too close to expiration
Melodius - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase12/3/2020Fat free milk is something I choose for dietary reasons. The Member's Mark Fat Free Milk has a different gallon shaped container than others. I find this specific shape fits in the fridge side door easier than the other containers.
Member's Mark Fat Free Milk (1 gal. jug)
Craig - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase3/30/2023I hesitated when buying this because the last two times I bought it here ( last summer) the milk was binky. I was desperate so I took a chance and lucked out. The milk was fresh!
Fresh milk
Patmobile - 4 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase7/22/2024I picked up the milk because I was in the store and I didn't want to make another stop just for milk. My question is why being a discount store the milk is at last 30 cents more than the local wal mart?
Price of Milk
Sallie G - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase12/4/2023I grew up drinking Publix brand milk and am still a hard-core Publix brand fan, but I gave this milk a try and was pleasantly surprised that it's just as good and lives out its shelf life just like Publix brand. My only complaint is that at my local Sams, the date is usually really close, it must be a slow mover.
Great Milk, Great Price
JB - 3 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase12/3/2023Good value, would have given 5 stars, but the pick up handles are not 'punched out' at the factory -Sam's should address. Sometimes, like my last purchase, 30-50% of plastic handles are not punched out. It's a supplier issue ongoing and a pain for customers and I'm sure the stores dealing with the mess it makes.
Very good value, but could be better for customers
Midwest - 1 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase3/25/2024It tasted fine the first couple of days when I was using it in coffee. But then the next day I drank it as is and it tasted funny. I tried again the following day with a different cup and the same thing happens. It wasn't spoiled but it had an odd flavor. So I dump the rest down the drain.
Tasted funny before best before date
jj - 3 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase12/24/2023This is the one product I have problems with from Sam’s that they carry. The product taste great, prices are awesome but the expiration dates are so close to today’s date. Sometimes within a week the expiration date is. Other places it’s sometimes 3 to 4 weeks from today’s date that they expire. This is the only thing that if we are out of milk I may buy one.
Only in an emergency, otherwise I buy elsewhere
CL - 1 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase5/16/2021The height of these jugs and the shape of the handle is annoying. The height is a tough squeeze into our undercounter coffeeshop fridge. The handles often have a left over plastic oiece that didnt quite get cut out and make it hard to grab multiple jugs at once. Additionally, there is a seal under the cap that takes extra time and a knife or long fingernail to pry off. Such a pain when working in a fast paced coffeeshop. We go through 40+ gallons of milk per week and wull buy milk elsewhwere every opportunity when the price is comparable.
Jug shape, handle, and seal not practical.
stacyoMember's Mark SupportThank you for sharing your feedback. Rest assured we have made changes to the cap and are expected those to arrive in club ne... - 4 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase3/7/2024Milk is fine but I really do not like the shape of the jug - it's a little too tall for storing easily in fridge. The more "traditional" shaped jugs take up a slightly larger "footprint" but still fit more easily into shelves in the fridge - and we have a big fridge!
Do not like the height of the milk jug
MM - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase2/25/2024Simply the freshest tasting skim milk ever! I use skim Fat-free milk for protein shakes, cereal, cream of wheat, etc. This skim milk has never let me down. Every gallon I have bought lasted way beyond the expiration date, where other brand labels generally did not. Since it is only me in the family that likes Fat Free milk, I need my skim to last before it ever has a sour smell or taste. Truly excellent product. I can only imagine how long and fresh the 1 or 2% might last! highly recommend.
ALL Fat Free milk lovers
CT2eye56 - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase11/12/2025Good Milk in a well-designed & space-conscious jug.
Great Milk & Jug
KER - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase10/26/2025So glad Sams carries Skim, have been drinking it for years, 5 stars!
Love Skim milk!
Dennis S - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase12/7/2025I prefer skim, fat free, milk. Last two trips you were out though. Not the first time. Why
Please keep skim milk in stock.
Jack - 1 out of 5 stars review8/14/2022These containers are very difficult to handle! When u get to the last few ounces, you have to be a gymnast or ninja to get last few oz's out! No other carton alive creates this problem, AND THE PRICE IS $1 HIGHER than nearby competitors. If you don't drink much milk, that's no big deal, but I drink 3 gallons a week.Julio
- 1 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase5/14/2024Can someone explain why when we pay for memberships I routinely see milk alot cheaper a Walmart?
Why so much?
Brian - 1 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase9/16/2020Picked up a gallon milk via curbside pickup--the date of expiration was the next day.
Received Expired Item
- 1 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase2/7/2023I do not like the design of the container. Difficult to get into the shelves in the frig
Poor container design
Kathy - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase12/12/2020Nice sturdy plastic jug. VERY hard to pull off the inside protection seal! I’m in my 60’s and have all I can do to pull it off.
Milk Juds
Lori