Prefer the 2% compared to the 1%, little watered down. Never had an issue with Sam's milk. Expiration and price are always reasonable.

Very satisfied with this milk. I buy it every time I’m at Sam’s. It has a great taste and the dates are far enough out that it doesn’t spoil for me.

Weird taste - I bought because I didn't have time to go to the grocery store but I don't think I'll do that again. It tasted strange.

I buy milk almost every week. I had to return 1 gallon in the last 6 months because it spoiled before the “us by date”

Can someone enlighten me as to how to open these things? I couldn't pull the seal off by hand, so I used a pair of pliers and ripped the tab off in the process. The only way to open these bottles is to pry them open with a knife risking cutting yourself and having fragments of the tab fall into the milk.Why do they make these so hard to get into? Don't tell me for safety, because gagging on pieces of the "safety tab" is just as bad.

First time we ordered milk for delivery from Sams advice if you are not able to drink it quickly purchase somewhere else. Delivered on 2/14 best used by 2/16. Not had this problem with any other grocery stores. Lessen learned. Aside from this one time problem we are long time well satisfied members

Never in a million years could I imagine wasting time to write an online review for milk. Now that I'm reading other reviews, I'm not surprised at the dozens of other reviews complaining about the new milk jug design. For the last few months, I've tolerated the hard to open caps and drips/spills when pouring. But this morning, I was simply unable to open the cap on a new carton. Could not get fingers around cap to get a good grip. So, I head out to garage to grab the channel lock pliers, which allowed me to get cap off. No, I'm not a feeble senior citizen. But I would certainly feel sorry for those who are, especially if they don't have the required tool to open the carton. I assume Sam's/MembersMark did some savvy consumer research/testing before launching this brilliant design. Undoubtedly, there were advantages, most probably related to easier/more efficient packing/shipping of a carton that's a bit more square. However, amazingly, they seem to be ignoring the many customers complaining about frustrating design. So, while the milk is fine and at a very reasonable price, I'll simply do what smart consumers do to send a message: I'll buy my milk elsewhere. If enough consumers would do the same, our message may be heard by deaf ears.

The new jug design was a shock, but it takes up less space in the fridge. Some older reviews mention it being hard to open. It's just fine. Under the lid, I believe the designer has since added a flap with which you can easily pull off the seal. I've never had a problem. The milk tastes good and has a long expiration date. It costs less than the grocery store, too!

Just why? Why would anyone bother to redesign a milk jug? This design is horrible it spills all over and I don't like anything about it. There was nothing wrong with the standard milk jug that has been around for years. find something else to waste money on Sam's club and bring us back the old jug please!

Good milk, great price. Don't much care for the bottle design. We are having a harder and harder time unscrewing the caps. The cap on the last several are so low it's hard to get off... Two of us tried, finally the third got it off, but not easily... We got one the other day with no seal. I returned it... At times the seal is very difficult to remove.