Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Customer reviews for Member's Mark Iced Cinnamon Rolls, 8 ct. for
Member's Mark Iced Cinnamon Rolls, 8 ct.
3.9 out of 5 stars
stars589 ratings237 reviews
  1. 5 stars59% (350)
  2. 4 stars9% (52)
  3. 3 stars11% (63)
  4. 2 stars8% (47)
  5. 1 star13% (77)

Member photos

Sort by |
Showing 181-190 of 237 reviews
Nov 21, 2025
Joey
1 out of 5 stars review

A real disappoinment

These are subpar, heavy with little flavor. I really loved the way they used to be made-they were so delicious! They were the perfect start to my day...but the new cinnamon cupcake things are a big disappoinment. Please bring back the real cinnamon rolls!

Helpful?1OJN3PZ21V1S17815773723
Nov 21, 2025
BRITTANY
2 out of 5 stars review

Not the same as the old ones

These LOOK like the original cinnamon rolls. They're better than the gross metal sheet kind, but not even close to the original. They're about HALF the size (thickness) of the original. They've also cut back a ton on the amount of “rolls” or layers that are in the roll. This is super thick where the old ones were thin and just melted in your mouth. These are tougher, harder, and just a disappointment in general if you thought they brought back the OG amazing ones they sold around a year ago. While it's an improvement over the metal pan type, we probably won't buy them again.

Helpful?1OJN3PZ21V1S17815773723
Nov 24, 2025
Angie
5 out of 5 stars review

They're back!!!

So happy these were brought back! The previous ones they tried to replace them were not it and something you could find at the gas station that's prepackaged! Thank you Sam's for listening to your customers, I rather pay the extra dollar to keep the quality in the product.

Helpful?1OJN3PZ21V1S17815773723
Nov 21, 2025
Anonymous
2 out of 5 stars review

Not the same as before

So disappointed!!! I was so excited to see these back in store. These are not the same taste or quality as they were before. The texture is rubbery and tastes overall chemically. Not sure why the recipe has changed but please bring the old recipe back. Quality over quantity Sam's Club!

Helpful?1OJN3PZ21V1S17815773723
Nov 21, 2025
SUZANNE
4 out of 5 stars review

Not Quite the Same as the Original

I was excited when these came back to replace the hockey pucks in the single tray. Unfortunately, they're not quite like the originals. These are noticeably smaller — the old ones stood more than an inch above the muffin liner — and the texture has changed too. The original was flakier, almost croissant-like, while this version is denser and a bit tougher. I'd rate it somewhere between the original and the tray version. The price has also gone up by $1. I'll still buy them occasionally, but if they were the original version, I'd purchase them every week. Really disappointed.

Helpful?1OJN3PZ21V1S17815773723
Nov 21, 2025
Shell
4 out of 5 stars review

Newer version Cinnamon Rolls

Sooo glad you brought back the old style of cinnamon rolls! However, they are closer to the original version, but not quite the same. These are smaller, the roll is not quite as croissant like and the icing is a little thinner. But, I definitely like these way better than the ones you had changed to before.

Helpful?1OJN3PZ21V1S17815773723
Dec 8, 2025
YUMI
5 out of 5 stars review

Sweet and not to sweet

I love these cinnamon rolls. It is sweet and soft. I love most of sweet treats at Sam's club. I will buy it again. Sam's club has the best bakery items. I love pecan pie and cheesecake as well. Their calories are such as six seven. I reduce calories to remove some of icings.

Helpful?1OJN3PZ21V1S17815773723
Nov 28, 2025
Carissa
5 out of 5 stars review

Yee yeeeee!!!

Listen, God heard my prayers on this lol I would buy these and share them with co-workers and we would always rave about how amazing they are. And then one day, Sam's club made an unwise choice and took them away and replaced it with garbage rolls. You heard me right, garbage. But, as they say, the trash will eventually take itself out and that's what happened because those replacements were awful. I'm so glad these are back. Sam's, please continue to make wise choices and never get rid of these delicious gooey and tender amazingly good cinnamon rolls ever again, please and thank you.

Helpful?1OJN3PZ21V1S17815773723
Nov 21, 2025
Amelinda
5 out of 5 stars review

They're back!

These are the amazing, flaky, gooey cinnamon buns from last year. The cinnamon filling isn't quite as good as before, but the cream cheese frosting and everything else is just as awesome as I remembered. These are my favorite store bought cinnamon rolls, hands down. Treat yourself and your friends/ family today!

Helpful?1OJN3PZ21V1S17815773723
Nov 21, 2025
Tom
5 out of 5 stars review

THE BEST EVER CINNAMON ROLLS ARE BACK!!!

We would like to thank the Sam's Club personnel that ACTUALLY LISTENED to all the customers that were/have been clamoring for the return of these 8 ct Members Mark cinnamon rolls. There literally IS NO COMPARISON to the deluxe quality of these rolls (especially when lightly warmed in a microwave). The ONLY close comparison would be the Cinnabon Bakery Restaurant which would be several times the price of what Sam's Club would charge. As to the "replacement" cinnamon rolls that Sam's offered up when they canceled the originals.. the ones that are in a square tinfoil tray all clumped together.. WHY WOULD ANYONE want THOSE OTHER CINNAMON ROLLS IN A TINFOIL TRAY that you can buy/get from ANY GROCERY STORE?!?? These MEMBER'S MARK 8 CT CINNAMON ROLLS ARE THE DREAMIEST AND MOST SCRUMPTIOUS CINNAMON ROLLS FOR THE MONEY. I'm 73 years old I've tasted LOTS OF CINNAMON ROLLS AND THESE ARE THE BEST. Also they freeze well. Put them in the fridge until the frosting isn't gooey and then you can individually wrap one at a time lightly with saran wrap or easier yet, pop them into a sandwich bag, seal it up and put them in the freezer for an individual one at a time treat. Seriously... I don't leave many product reviews about anything, and if I do it's usually to complain about some really unthinking thing/decision that someone in "Corporate America" made to adversely affect the quality and /or value of a particular product... Almost all of the few complaints I have made have fallen on deaf ears...EXCEPT SOMEONE AT SAM'S CLUB ACTUALLY LISTENED!!! WHICH IS ACTUALLY A TESTAMENT TO THE COMPANY ITSELF, THAT SOMEONE TOOK ACTION AND PASSED THE COMMENTS UP THE CORPORATE LADDER, AND SOMEONE IN THE HIGHER LEVELS FIGURED IT OUT, AND RE-STARTED THE PRODUCT LINE. My hope now is that Sam's give it a chance to catch up as I am sure that there are some customers that are unaware that the cinnamon rolls are back on the shelf and have given up and quit looking for them. So thank you Sam's. At a time when all the companies across America are trying to cut corners and trying to offer less product for a higher price to the consumer, GUESS WHO CAME THROUGH FOR THE CONSUMER... GOOD OL' SAM'S!!! THANK YOU!!!

Helpful?1OJN3PZ21V1S17815773723