Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
Customer reviews for Member's Mark 4" Assorted Mini Pies, 6 ct. for
Member's Mark 4" Assorted Mini Pies, 6 ct.
4.4 out of 5 stars
stars350 ratings116 reviews
  1. 5 stars74% (258)
  2. 4 stars8% (27)
  3. 3 stars11% (37)
  4. 2 stars4% (13)
  5. 1 star4% (15)

Member photos

Sort by |
Showing 71-80 of 116 reviews
Jan 3, 2026
Predmore
4 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Yum

Perfect size

Helpful?3TVZ25ETSGEX17751500205
Dec 20, 2025
TEVIN
4 out of 5 stars review

Cheaper than crumbl and worth a try.

Overall: Good for the price. A "rocket fuel" list of ingredients. But its much cheaper than crumbl who has gotten insane with their $11 minimum delivery fee. Favorite: Peanut butter pie- IT has a good, more subtle peanut butter flavor that blends well with the cookie crumb. Crumb isn't too soft or hard (this applies to all pies as well). The crust can be cut with a metal spoon fine but a plastic spoons might take a bit more force. Still not rock hard or anything. The frosting on top was basic but worked with the whole piece. I personally did not care for the little dots on top. I think that is excessive and added a weird crunch to each bite. 2nd favorite: French silk pie- Flavor was lacking but wasn't bad by any means. Everything about this was fine. I've had better and worse. Not mad about it at all except I think the flavors could be more pronounced. Loved the texture on this and peanut butter. They are both a bit thicker thank I expected but I really enjoyed it. Least favorite: Cherry topped vanilla bean- What a wild disappointment. Tasted like a normal jar of super sugary jelly. Scrapped it off and threw it away after the first bite. Completely unnecessary to add to this pie and made it worse, overly sweet. The vanilla bean and crust was nice but tainted by that stupid cherry jelly stuff. Really disappointed with this one. Still edible and would be better without the Jelly.

Helpful?3TVZ25ETSGEX17751500205
Nov 21, 2025
Dana
5 out of 5 stars review

Great find - delicious dessert mini pie assortment

For sweetness, I give these 3-4 stars, I prefer desserts that have a more subtle sweetness, these are very sweet, but I forgive that because they are just so delicious. We really enjoyed each flavor and one of them is PLENTY for your dessert sweet tooth after dinner,probably 1/2 would be fine, but they are hard to stop eating even when you know you already have your sugar high...

Helpful?3TVZ25ETSGEX17751500205
Feb 2, 2026
Cortnie
4 out of 5 stars review

I'm an avid baker and only treat myself every once in a while. These were very good, even though I could slightly taste some artificial flavors. My favorite was the chocolate, which had a slight hot fudge taste. My daughter's favorite was the cherry vanilla and my husband's was the peanut butter. They were sweet enough without being overly sweet and the crust was delicious.

Helpful?3TVZ25ETSGEX17751500205
Nov 21, 2025
Donna
5 out of 5 stars review

Outstanding! Offer them more than once a year!

These are wonderful and I wish Sam's would offer them year-round or at least 3 or 4 times a year! I love a little something sweet after dinner, but don't need a lot. Cutting one of the pies in half totally satisfies my sweet tooth while saving me half the calories!

Helpful?3TVZ25ETSGEX17751500205
Dec 6, 2025
KA
2 out of 5 stars review

Don't buy

These are not worth the money. First they are much smaller than the pictures shows. They look delicious but taste wise they are a major disappointment. The vanilla bean holds no distinguishing flavor, the pb has an odd taste and the chocolate mousse is good but not worth paying the price for the other flavors.

Helpful?3TVZ25ETSGEX17751500205
Dec 9, 2025
Sana
5 out of 5 stars review

Fantastic especially the cherry topped

The cherry topped are my favorites the three flavors are great but the cherry topped is the best it's fantastic I will buy more definitely and if you make a giant cherry topped pie I would buy it also. I did not attach a picture to my review because I eat them all sorry😁 Thank you

Helpful?3TVZ25ETSGEX17751500205
Nov 26, 2025
Aidanmama
5 out of 5 stars review

Nice surprise!

Tried on a whim and pleasantly surprised! Def shareable as they are very rich- 1 pie could easily be split between 2 people. All were great, but all we really need are the peanut butter ones! Please consider doing half dozens of just those! We PB/choc fans will buy them regularly!

Helpful?3TVZ25ETSGEX17751500205
Jan 14, 2026
CARRIE
5 out of 5 stars review

Seemed high quality

Definitely something I would pick up again for a dinner party. They were very good. I am a peanut butter fan, but I didn't love this one, I would still purchase, but for me the vanilla bean was just amazing flavor. I had left over and I just cut small pieces of each every day while on vacation...just a nice satisfying treat even in small doses.

Helpful?3TVZ25ETSGEX17751500205
Nov 21, 2025
ReadyForFall
5 out of 5 stars review

Delicious little pies.

They are a good size, you can share it also. They taste great. My only complaint is there is too much crust in ratio with filling. The crust tastes great on all of them, it's just really thick and they could use more filling. The peanut butter taste exactly like a homemade peanut butter pie. The vanilla creme is soooo good. I didn't think I'd like it, but it is my top favorite. The little bit of strawberry topping gives it that needed bit of fruit taste. The chocolate silk is just that...smooth and silky. They are all worthy of 5 starts if the crust were decreased and have more filling. I'd still highly recommend.

Helpful?3TVZ25ETSGEX17751500205