I am of the opinion that anyone that says this is a good coffee has never had good coffee. I had high hopes when I read the reviews. I gave it a chance based on the reviews and because it said “Medium-” in the description of the roast but it was way over roasted, to the point that the oils were roasted out of it and you can see burn marks on the beans. I know that preference for coffee is very subjective and I have already seen another review that said that the beans were not even shiny – you don’t want them shiny, shiny is ruined. I have been roasting my own coffee for years and maybe I am a little spoiled, but with the rising cost of green beans I was questioning if it is really justified to spend more on green beans than I would spend on already roasted coffee. Well this coffee (and a couple others) have shown me that continuing to roast my own coffee is not only justified, it is a necessity. Based on reading other people’s reviews the roast of these beans is extremely inconsistent and you will be rolling the dice on what you will actually get. This coffee made a weak cup of coffee but was still able to leave an ick on the tongue for way too long after drinking it, a stronger cup lead to a stronger ick. Is it better than Folgers, maybe, but I am not going to try Folgers again to let you know. Compared to the Starbuck’s Pike Place – they have about the same ick but the way over roasted Starbucks is stronger. This coffee gives about the same level of disappointment as the Cameron’s Southern Pecan. The Tim Horton’s that ordered has not arrived yet but I have to say that my hopes are dashed for preroasted coffees.

It's been my favorite bean for year I was a bit disappointed when it wasn't available for a few weeks. Now its back

Nice bold and rich flavor. Like it better than the previous members mark brand in same color packaging.

Love this coffee but prefer it ground. The grinder suggested the grind setting but it didn't work for my coffee maker.

I’ve purchased this product for the last 5 yrs and it’s quality is consistent. Worthwhile to grind these beans at the store and enjoyed at home.

Coffee is ok and taste is very bitter. This Sam’s Club location needs to have more selection of whole bean coffee. Currently there is only members mark and eight a clock coffee’s available.

This used to be my go to coffee, but it has been going downhill over the last year or so. The latest version is probably the worst version yet. The coffee has a lot of chaff after grinding and the flavor no longer has any dark chocolate notes. The flavor profile description on the package was updated too, so this is not the same Columbian Supremo I used to love. I hope Sam’s can restore the old quality and flavor this coffee once had.

Whole beans is the way to go. The member mark brand rich flavor 4c H20 to 3 tbs coffee.

Has great value and especially flavor

I've enjoyed MM Columbian Supremo for quite a while. This is a tasty medium dark roast coffee that doesn't disappoint.