My kids love this

My family and I used to LOVEEE this yogurt. The recipe/ingredients must’ve changed when they switched the color of the lids? We bought 3 of the new ones (at least a month in between each time) hoping we just got a bad batch. We were wrong. They were all nasty. Flavor, consistency and taste. Please get the old one back!

Like others have said recently, something has changed. It's like a viscous liquid now and the taste is different. Not a horrible taste, but not nearly as good as it used to be. The texture is just really weird. I was trying to spoon it into a bowl and any “yogurt” above the rim of the spoon would just run out and back into the container or onto the counter. I can't justify buying it again until it's back to how it was.

This yogurt was great! Purchased every trip and a favorite for our kids. The recipe has changed, ingredients were added, the texture is now runny, a d it does not taste as good. Old version was better than the brand name, this is much worse. The container with the black top is good - the white lid is the bad version (in my Michigan club at least)

Creamy and good taste

Love this yogurt

Excellent product

Love it!

Yummy!

I have never had any issues with Member's Mark versions of products and usually I actually prefer them to the name brand. this yogurt was a total let down. From quick search online apparently the recipe was changed and ingredients are now lesser quality than before. The texture of the yogurt was not thick as greek yogurt usually is as well as the container did not seem adequate for proper food keeping. I ended up transferring it to an airtight container and every day the separation was more than the last. I understand this is not high quality product and separation is normal, but the amount I was seeing was bizarre. The taste is strong of imitation vanilla extract as well. I will be reaching for Chobani or other going forward.