Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
All Departments
All Services
Customer reviews for Member's Mark Honey Vanilla Whole Milk Greek Style Yogurt, 48oz for
Member's Mark Honey Vanilla Whole Milk Greek Style Yogurt, 48oz
4.2 out of 5 stars
stars
439 ratings145 reviews
  1. 5 stars69% (303)
  2. 4 stars8% (37)
  3. 3 stars5% (22)
  4. 2 stars5% (24)
  5. 1 star12% (53)

Member photos

Sort by |
Showing 91-100 of 145 reviews
May 24, 2026
Lucy
5 out of 5 stars review

This is the best yogurt I have ever had. I used to buy two at a time. I am so disappointed that my Sam's Club in Jacksonville Florida informed me they discontinued it.

Helpful?60IBGE61P2G117422502323
Jun 5, 2026
anonymous
2 out of 5 stars review

Soapey honey flavor

It would taste much better if they changed the honey flavoring. I would also like to know which 'live and active cultures' are in the yogurt. They are currently not listed on any MM yogurt labels.

Helpful?60IBGE61P2G117422502323
Dec 18, 2025
Taffie
1 out of 5 stars review

New Lid, New Lies

When the Lid Changed, So Did the Trust — Ingredient Downgrade Disguised as Rebranding :( They change this and the ingredients the original one had a black lid on it. Once they made the cheaper ingredients and more of a chemical taste, they put the cream/white lid on it. Disappointing cheaper cheaper ingredients yet still the same price. I don't know why companies do stuff like this. They lose so many customers.

Helpful?60IBGE61P2G117422502323
Feb 20, 2026
SamsandCostcoMember
2 out of 5 stars review

RIP Black Lid Yogurt

As other reviews have stated, the recipe has been reformulated. This used to have a black lid. It now has a Higher water and syrup content. The yogurt is sticky and almost cloyingly sweet. You're having to pour off the whey syrup every time it's opened and you didn't have to before. This is not the same product as a year ago.

Helpful?60IBGE61P2G117422502323
Dec 2, 2025
GreekYogurtFan
1 out of 5 stars review

Not real Greek style yogurt

This isn't traditional strained Greek yogurt. They add pectin to it to mimic the texture of Greek yogurt. It has a weird texture more like yoplait custard yogurt than what it's supposed to be. Plus because of the way they make it, it only has about half of the protein per serving as traditional Greek yogurt.

Helpful?60IBGE61P2G117422502323
Jan 13, 2026
DANIELLE
1 out of 5 stars review

No longer up to par

Used to be delicious. Warning- if you enjoyed this product when it had the black lid, it is no longer the same. Very runny and the honey flavor overpowers the vanilla now. I thought I bought a bad batch where too much honey was mixed in, after reading the reviews, it seems that the recipe was changed at the same time the lid was changed to white. Bring back the old recipe so we can enjoy our yogurt again!

Helpful?60IBGE61P2G117422502323
Dec 10, 2025
Heather
1 out of 5 stars review

TERRIBLE change it back pls

The new change is terrible. It's so thin and runny. Does not taste good either. It used to be thick and sweet/rich but now it's just bad bad. I was buying the previous one, with the black lid for my kids and now it's so thin it makes a huge mess when they eat it. It also it always sticky/messy on the outside of the container at the store

Helpful?60IBGE61P2G117422502323
Dec 29, 2025
Lmc
1 out of 5 stars review

Favorite before they changed it - now I don't buy

This was a staple breakfast for me every single day. It was also a snack for later in the afternoon. I always put blackberries in there, both of which I got from Sam's. The recipe used to be delicious, at first I thought it was just a bad batch and then I realized that it has just changed. All of the same comments that others have concerns about, less flavor, runny and the sticky containers, which I don't understand is what I experience. If they ever change it back, I will gladly purchase one for Home and one for work again every single week.

Helpful?60IBGE61P2G117422502323
Dec 15, 2025
THOMAS
1 out of 5 stars review

Thumbs down

This used to be our tried and true breakfast yogurt and the last few months the quality has been horrible. From sticky dirty containers and lids, curdled or slimy yogurt, and the most recent time… BOTH of our containers have had broken seals, I'm assuming because of manufacturing error. Overall this used to be a 5 star product and like many other things, has dramatically dropped to 1.

Helpful?60IBGE61P2G117422502323
Feb 12, 2026
anonymous
2 out of 5 stars review

Expected better

Was looking for a tub of honey Greek yogurt to make my own parfaits instead of the chobani flips. I decided to try this instead since you get more bang for your buck. Members mark brands are typically good but this was too watery, has an unpleasant aftertaste and an artificial chemical taste. I will be going back to the Chobani, Better goods and the Greek Gods yogurt brands.

Helpful?60IBGE61P2G117422502323