It does NOT taste good, cold or room temp. It's not chalky, but it tastes almost like old and bland chocolate. I wouldn't buy it again. Didnt realize I couldve returned it until it was too late.

The worst protein shake I have ever had. Picked up 2 cases cause the powder protein from them is the best. Very disappointed with the taste and texture

The brown bottle RTD is the grass fed version of the new white box RTD. I don’t believe Sam’s is carrying the brown bottle any longer at least no in my area. However, they do have the grass fed version in powder protein at my location.

Sam’s club changed from the Raw grass fed protein in a bottle, which were amazing to this c rising of Raw protein shakes, which taste awful. The flavor is awful and barely able to be drank. Save us the hassle and bring the old ones back.

This is supposed to be the new and improved version, but they taste watered down with less flavor, does not taste as good as the old ones in the bottle.

so gross! this is not the same recipe as the plastic bottles. I was very much looking forward to the same great flavor I have purchased several times. very disappointed ☹️ will be returning ASAP

The formula seems to have changed since the packaging changed. It seems to have a bit of a bitter aftertase now that the formula changed. Could it be the new packaging? not sure but it definately is different.

most likely they will lose a lot of customers unless they go back to the original taste. I can tolirate the clumsy box, but the taste is what kept me buying there product but when the lose the taste they lose me.

Improved is not the wording I would have used. The bottled version is a superior protein shake. This version is not that, a little disappointed in Raw.

Very gross taste. It's watery %26 flat. The chocolate milkshake one was the best. I will be returning this tomorrow. I hope they get the chocolate milkshake flavor back. It was the best