Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
Customer reviews for Carrington Farms Refined Coconut Oil, 128 fl. oz. for
Carrington Farms Refined Coconut Oil, 128 fl. oz.

Member photos

Sort by |
Showing 1-10 of 13 reviews
Mar 28, 2026
NICHOLAS
5 out of 5 stars review

Good Product, Great Price

All of the one star reviews for this product need to understand the difference between ounces and fluid ounces. You are buying a gallon of coconut oil not 8 pounds of coconut oil. Water works that way but coconut oil does not. This is a very good value for refined coconut oil.

Helpful?768AC3IJ8JSZ17239000531
Mar 9, 2026
CHASE
5 out of 5 stars review

Fluid ounces vs ounces of weight

If you know the difference in these two measurements, then you will see that they are real close on what they are seeking. They could have used smaller container, but you are getting what they are advertising. Coconut oil 1 fl oz = 0.92oz weighed

Helpful?768AC3IJ8JSZ17239000531
Apr 10, 2026
Nathaniel
5 out of 5 stars review

This is great for the amount. Refined means not a strong or any coconut flavor. Cook and hand cream is my main uses.

Helpful?768AC3IJ8JSZ17239000531
Dec 28, 2025
Bonnie
5 out of 5 stars review

very good product, and very fresh and soft, not hard like the other that Sam's sells.

Helpful?768AC3IJ8JSZ17239000531
Mar 23, 2026
BOZANA
5 out of 5 stars review

soap making

great for soap making

Helpful?768AC3IJ8JSZ17239000531
Apr 11, 2026
JudyShimel
2 out of 5 stars review

Leaking packaging

Poor packaging, coconut oil leaked out almost 10 oz of product. Won’t let me up load phones, there was no coconut oil in the middle! Very disappointed. I will not order from this company or brand! An I highly suggest you don’t either!

Helpful?768AC3IJ8JSZ17239000531
Jun 8, 2026
anonymous
2 out of 5 stars review

I ordered this product online. When coconut oil reaches a temperature over 75 degrees it starts to melt. There was no plastic seal to prevent this. It was not packed with bubble wrap so when it was delivered it was upside down. There are no returns for online order on the apps I would have to call which is an inconvenience. So if you decide to order consider ordering in cooler weather. There was no option for a cool pack.

Helpful?768AC3IJ8JSZ17239000531
Jan 31, 2026
Mandilee
1 out of 5 stars review

Severely underfilled container

Inaccurate weight. Another reviewer was right. They only fill the container about 70 percent full. The full weight of the bucket, (including the weight of the bucket), is only 125 oz. I would guess there's only about 115 oz of Coconut in here, at best! You can clearly see they're underfilling it, as it's only 70 percent full. If you're using this to make soap, or even if you're not, just know you are absolutely NOT getting a full gallon of coconut oil. You're better off purchasing the Sam's brand of Coconut oil, for the price per oz. They are misleading the amount by underfilling the product severely.

Helpful?768AC3IJ8JSZ17239000531
Jan 17, 2026
Sarah
1 out of 5 stars review

You're only getting 118oz MAX.

You do not receive 128 fluid ounces; you actually get 116 fluid ounces. The 128-ounce measurement includes the packaging. I purchased eight of these containers over a period of a few weeks and noticed that none of them were full, with some being filled only a little over halfway. I decided to weigh the unopened containers and was shocked to find that they weighed between 126 and 127.8 ounces. Then, I weighed the containers and the oils separately to determine exactly how much oil I was getting. The amounts varied from 116 to 118 ounces, which is 10 ounces less than what was advertised.

Helpful?768AC3IJ8JSZ17239000531
Feb 28, 2026
CC
1 out of 5 stars review

Underfilled containers!

I have to agree with the other two reviews that state how severely underfilled these buckets are. My unopened container weighs 7.8 pounds. I paid for 8 pounds of product. I chose this product for my soapmaking business because of the competitive pricing, which I now find is not competitive at all.

Helpful?768AC3IJ8JSZ17239000531