I ordered these with a curbside pick up order on 10/23. The item I received was dated 10/25. All were very dry and crumbly and not fresh at all. This was unusual as most often the muffins are pretty fresh. Perhaps staff did not pay attention to best used date and look for a more fresh date.

I did not care for this variety pack of muffins. The butter pecan tasted OK, but it didn't hold together as well as their regular muffins. The flavor of the butter pecan muffin is the only reason these muffins got two stars because the other two varieties were not good. The red velvet was a disaster on all fronts. It was wet, greasy, tasted of nothing but chocolate chips, and had no structural integrity. It literally fell apart into soggy crumbs. The orange cranberry one was lacking in sweetness and was on the gummy side. Just skip these and get one of their regular varieties.

Don't waste your money. My wife and I both agree the muffins are not good. They taste terrible, are dry and fall apart when you try to eat them. The red velvet doesn't taste like red velvet. The orange cranberry doesn't taste like orange and the pieces of cranberry are so small and have no flavor. The pecan didn't taste good and was very dry.

Sadly nothing like Sam's muffins. A short microwave heat for 18 seconds didn't help at all. The muffins are dry, crumbly and very disappointing. The red velvet had no flavor unless you'd taste a mini mini chocolate chip. The cranberry muffin had a faint taste of orange. They also had something light colored but hard in the muffins. The butter pecan was the best of the 3. At least it was moist, had some flavor and had tiny pecan pieces in them. The first 2 we threw away and ate part of the 3rd one. We won't purchase again. stick with the everyday flavors they have.

Pretty disappointed in these. Not sure if it was a bad batch or what but the flavors were subpar and it would not hold together. Crumbled into micro muffin everywhere from simply taking the muffin paper off to eat it. Each flavor was not great, family of 5 and no one enjoyed them

I purchased this pack of muffins for a special occasion breakfast and wished now that I hadn't. They were dry, and the pecan muffins had no flavor, and the cranberry orange had little flavor. I was so embarrassed and disappointed. I have purchased the blueberry muffins many times, and they have never been disappointed.

Holiday muffins not a GO! The red velvet scent overpowers the butter pecan and orange cranberry. None of the three is to be compared to the all around year chocolate and blueberry. I almost took these to a social event, and glad I didn't. I would have been embarassed.

I was very surprised when I tasted these muffins. Each muffin flavor had an artificial taste that was overpowering, making them unedible. They went in the trash. Member's Mark products are usually good quality, I'm not sure what happened with the batch I got.

My daughter and I are both very disappointed that these have replaced the cinnamon crunch muffins . We gave them a try this past week and the only really edible ones were the red velvet, and it was nothing to write home about. The butter pecan didn't taste anything like butter pecan, and the cranberry orange honestly didn't taste like anything at all. The butter pecan and cranberry orange were both incredibly dry.

WHAT happened? Blueberry and banana nut are fantastic. This Holiday pk is horrible. Cranberry orange is so dry I tossed outside to the birds. Hope I didn't kill them. Butter pecan just ok but flavorless. Red velvet has funny chemical smell and is not red but just a chocolate muffin. I am SO disappointed. Plus what's up with filling muffins 1/2 full vs their normal huuuuge size. Just stop messing with a good thing on the NON holiday, everyday ones.