Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
Customer reviews for First Response Early Result Pregnancy Test, 4 ct., 2 pk. for
First Response Early Result Pregnancy Test, 4 ct., 2 pk.
2.1 out of 5 stars
stars38 ratings38 reviews
  1. 5 stars18% (7)
  2. 4 stars5% (2)
  3. 3 stars5% (2)
  4. 2 stars8% (3)
  5. 1 star63% (24)
Sort by |
Showing 1-10 of 38 reviews
Sep 22, 2025
Samk1
3 out of 5 stars review

Very DISAPPOINTED!!!!!!!!

I’m really hoping yall see this! IM VERY VERY VERY disappointed with tests you’ve put out recently!!! You guys have always been old reliable for me, when I was or happy I always always had to get first response ! These last few cycles I have been so… upset is an understatement!!!! IVE BEEN devastated!!!! FIVE TESTS WITH PINK INDENT LINES THAT SHOW UP IN THE TIME FRAME!!!!!! I was so excited!!!!! THEN CRUSHED WHEN IVE HAD A NEGATIVE HCG RESULTS

Review from firstresponse.com
Helpful?1NORDR9IRU9C17096557564
reply from First Response Consumer Relations

Thank you for having the courage to share your feedback with us, Samk1. We have sent you an email, because you're not alone. We are with you!

Mar 30, 2026
Mum of 6 NZ
1 out of 5 stars review

False positives

These test used to be the most reliable. Then 2-3 years ago they changes and now you get false positives all the time. I would never recommend these test to anyone but especially someone struggling with infertility. These test would give someone false hope. My oldest child is coming up 20 and my youngest is 11 months old so it's been over 20 years using these tests. The quality has dropped dramatically.

Review from firstresponse.com
Helpful?1NORDR9IRU9C17096557564
reply from First Response Consumer Relations

No matter where your journey takes you, we’re with you, Mum of 6 NZ. We are going to follow up, so keep an eye out for an email to arrive soon!

Oct 21, 2025
NikkiR365
1 out of 5 stars review

False Positive

Took two tests a few days apart. Both positive. Tried a different brand after reading these reviews, 2 days after the last positive test. That one was negative. Don't plan on using these again. The only reason I did is because the other brands were bought out. I see why now 😅

Review from firstresponse.com
Helpful?1NORDR9IRU9C17096557564
reply from First Response Consumer Relations

Thank you for sharing your feedback with us, NikkiR365. We have sent you an email, because we are here to guide you, no matter what your journey is.

Aug 19, 2025
Anniek
1 out of 5 stars review

Don’t waste your money. I’ve give it 0 stars

I’ve gotten multiple faint lines on these, my HCG was negative. We planned my youngest 4 years ago and had no issues with these tests. My faint lines I’ve been getting look exactly like they did when I got pregnant with my 4 year old. So seeing the faints you think nothing of indents but I have taken a TON of these recently and they all have idents!!!

Review from firstresponse.com
Helpful?1NORDR9IRU9C17096557564
reply from First Response Consumer Relations

We’re all about reliable, effective results, Anniek. We have sent you an email, because we are with you! You are not alone.

Dec 24, 2025
Mom0723
1 out of 5 stars review

Faulty test

I bought a test 4 hours ago and when I went home to take it. The test was faulty, no lines came up at all.

Review from firstresponse.com
Helpful?1NORDR9IRU9C17096557564
reply from First Response Consumer Relations

That moment of not knowing what’s next is among the most sensitive that you will ever go through, Mom0723. We have sent you an email, because no matter where your journey takes you, we’re with you.

Nov 20, 2025
Stephnic98
1 out of 5 stars review

Horrible

I took a first response 6 days sooner and got what I thought was a positive test….only for it to be wrong. I will never buy this brand again.

Review from firstresponse.com
Helpful?1NORDR9IRU9C17096557564
reply from First Response Consumer Relations

Thank you for having the courage to share your feedback with us, Stephnic98. We have sent you an email, because we're with you on this journey.

Oct 21, 2025
Ss122
1 out of 5 stars review

Awful false positive

I got a very clear pink line on my FRER and it ended up being a false positive. Super bummed and this used to be my most trusted brand

Review from firstresponse.com
Helpful?1NORDR9IRU9C17096557564
reply from First Response Consumer Relations

No matter where your journey takes you, Ss122, we are with you. We have sent you an email, because you're not alone.

Jun 19, 2025
Rachel28
1 out of 5 stars review

Heart Broken False positive

I had a false positive that came up within the time frame. I am heart broken and sad. I do not think i will be using these again. I’d rather wait longer for a true positive on a strip test

Review from firstresponse.com
Helpful?1NORDR9IRU9C17096557564
reply from First Response Consumer Relations

We’re all about accurate and effective results, Rachel28. We have sent you an email, because we are here for you. You are not alone!

Jul 8, 2025
Morganrae
1 out of 5 stars review

TERRIBLE

I wasted money on over 3 boxes, got faint positives and got excited. Line didn’t get darker so I looked at 2 unused tests I had left and guess what they already had the line :/

Review from firstresponse.com
Helpful?1NORDR9IRU9C17096557564
reply from First Response Consumer Relations

We're deeply sorry to hear about your disappointment, Morganrae. We have sent you an email, because we're with you. You are not alone!

Apr 14, 2024
Ollie21
1 out of 5 stars review

False positive!

Please don’t buy this brand if you’re thinking you’re pregnant! I took this test a couple days ago and got the most certain positive, I took another test with this same brand the next morning and it was negative that same day I went to my doctor got blood work and a urine test and what do I know they both came back negative. Weather you’re hoping to get pregnant or if you’re not trying to get pregnant this is the worst brand to buy from. I will never buy one of these test I wasted a large amount of money on them and a lot of stress was involved. Just please take these false positive reviews into consideration before you get excited or freak out! Always check with your doctor!!

Review from firstresponse.com
Helpful?1NORDR9IRU9C17096557564