These Smucker’s Uncrustables are a freezer staple in my house. They thaw quickly, the bread stays soft, and the peanut butter and grape jelly have that classic flavor you expect. They’re perfect for lunches, snacks, or grabbing on the go when you need something easy. The portion size is just right, and every sandwich is consistent — no mess, no prep, just simple and dependable. If you like PB&J, these are an effortless win.

When I don't feel like eating a heavy lunch, I can grab a couple of Uncrustables, and they are enough.

These are the perfect grab and go between school and sports for the kids. We always keep them on hand.

I'm not sure what it is, but I think it's the jelly. There's less jelly and it tastes a little different. Bread still is nice and fresh though. I'll buy it if it's on sale.

I’m don’t think a week goes by when I don’t have one of these for a quick meal or snack. Lately some look like the jelly leaked into the bread - not a big taste difference but doesn’t look like what you expect. I really like the kind with Jan but it seems to have been discontinued- so disappointing.

Pros- convenient, great price, no prep, no dishes, good portion for kids Cons- doesn’t keep freshness. frozen or thawed. After a week or so, the bread gets stale-ish. Limited variety. I would like to see a box with mixed flavors

Doesn’t taste like it used to 15 years ago.

The new uncrustables are mostly bread, for the whole 1/2 inch around the sandwich! Very little filling in the “new” version. If you check the weight on the box, you’ll notice that they are only 2.4 oz each compared with the 3 oz they used to be in Sam’s boxes. All bread! Also, the “soft” bread gets stale as soon as I open the wrapper! I have contacted Smuckers. They sent me an apology letter and that’s it.

They’re a lot smaller than I used to be a cost a lot more

one side was soft the other side was dry and very crusty, almost like they were froze, thawed and then froze again.