Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Customer reviews for Safety 1st Everfit All-in-One Convertible Car Seat, Choose Color for
Safety 1st Everfit All-in-One Convertible Car Seat, Choose Color
4.6 out of 5 stars
stars2,202 ratings602 reviews
  1. 5 stars81% (1,784)
  2. 4 stars9% (200)
  3. 3 stars3% (75)
  4. 2 stars2% (35)
  5. 1 star5% (108)

Member photos

  • +20 images
Sort by |
Showing 151-160 of 602 reviews
Nov 21, 2025
Megan
5 out of 5 stars review

Perfect

I'm very happy with my purchase. I used to be die hard Graco but their quality has really declined over the years and I can no longer justify their price. This was on sale and met the safety standards and had other good reviews. I'm glad I gave Safety first a chance.

Helpful?74ZQR0W5JVD316609312301
Feb 23, 2023
Kat
1 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

THE WORST heed my warning or injury could occur

WORST thing you could buy ever even when installed the right way there is still so much slack and movement with the seat even if the child is IN THE ACTUAL SEAT! buckled in and everything there is still movement. I used this for one trip not even that far from my house maybe 30 minutes and that was it I had to put the seat belt over the car seat to try to stop it from moving or worse falling over with my child in the seat. I was terrified . I immediately filed for a rerun online and Sam's club so called customer service didn't help much besides annoying me every single day . I scheduled a pickup for the return so I didn't have to go back out and drop it off and I kept getting calls about the pickup that was ALREADY SCHEDULED . Every few hours. Talk about horrible service. I don't see how this is allowed to be sold and Sam's service needs to get some serious help. If you value your child's life DO NOT but this garbage! buy ANYTHING ELSE! Avoid this seat I could not beg you enough to do so

Helpful?74ZQR0W5JVD316609312301
reply from DorelJuvenileSupport

Thank you for your review. We are sorry to hear of your experience and our Consumer Care Team is happy to help! You can text us at 812-652-2525 or call at 1-800-544-1108.

Oct 23, 2023
Lori J
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Great investment in your childs safety.

Very nice car seat. Child is secure. Has extra cushions for comfort and holders on the side to hold the straps so they are not in the way as you take your child out and put them in. I like that you can adjust for growth with one hand and do not have to take the seat apart. I love this car seat! Great price also.

Helpful?74ZQR0W5JVD316609312301
Oct 20, 2023
HazelAngel
4 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Do not buy as an infant seat!

This is a great car seat for a toddler. After having trouble positioning as a rear facing seat, I researched and found that crash testing for this seat scored 2 out of 5 for rear facing. It also doesn’t take into account that a young child will inevitably fall asleep while riding. There isn’t enough recline position in this seat for an infant to sleep safely. My son is 10 months old so this seat will be used only as forward facing when he turns one.

Helpful?74ZQR0W5JVD316609312301
Nov 21, 2025
Alyssa
2 out of 5 stars review

Fine for forward facing ONLY

We could not use it for rear facing, because it was impossible to get a safe install in either vehicle. We tried with both the seatbelt and the latch system, and the belt would slide, allowing the head of the carseat to move over a foot side to side. I absolutely do NOT recommend attemping to rear face it, because it it not safe at all. We were able to get it installed safely for foward facing. It is definitely a cheaper made carseat, the sides feel more flimsy and the headrest is more flimsy. However, I expected that already with it being $90. They definitely should not be marketing these are a transition carseat, though. The rear facing install was terribly insafe.

Helpful?74ZQR0W5JVD316609312301
reply from DorelJuvenileSupport

Thank you for sharing such a detailed review. We’re truly sorry to hear about the difficulty you experienced with the rear-facing installation. Your child’s safety is our top priority. Per instructions, when testing for movement, you will test at the belt path, not the head of the seat. <br />The seat should install securely in both rear-facing and forward-facing modes using either LATCH or a seat belt—so we take your feedback very seriously. The instability you encountered could indicate an installation issue and we would really appreciate the opportunity to help troubleshoot or evaluate the seat further.<br />We’re glad you were able to achieve a safe forward-facing install, but we understand your frustration, especially if you purchased this model expecting it to work confidently as a transitional seat.<br />If you are open to it, our support team can walk through step-by-step rear-facing installation checks or arrange a replacement or return if the seat is not performing as it should. You can reach us at 1-800-544-1108.

Aug 14, 2022
MomWifeNurse
5 out of 5 stars review

Great quality for great price

We bought the previous model of the carseat for my husband’s vehicle. I like it better then the really expensive model we have in my car. This seat is more user friendly as far as loosening it and tightening it to get my son in and out of the seat. My mom and sister each wanted a carseat for my little boy so we didn’t have to swap seats out all the time. I ordered 2 of these carseats in teal color. I love this model even more than the previous model I have. I’m considering ordering another one like this for my car to replace my expensive seat.

Helpful?74ZQR0W5JVD316609312301
Oct 8, 2023
Matt
5 out of 5 stars review

5 Star Quality at a Fraction of the Price

Wanted a second carseat, and this was perfect. All the reviews about it moving are probably due to poor install. There is a QR code on the book that takes you to the various install position videos. To properly install the rear facing latch; you need to lift off the cushion off the car seat a little and pull up and back against the car seat while pushing down. After the video I saw the angle and leverage needed to install; My car seat went from moving a few inches to not a single millimeter, not even my Evenflo Safemax is as secure. I recommend watching the two minute video for your desired install position. This also has nice shoulder cushions. 5 star

Helpful?74ZQR0W5JVD316609312301
Dec 24, 2025
Brendan
1 out of 5 stars review

Don't waste your money

I purchased this car seat because we were in a pinch and it was the only one available at the moment. Figured it was cheap and it would work fine. It's the worst car seat I've seen. Impossible to get tight. Literally will fall over if you Take a turn too quickly, with it being installed as tight as possible in accordance with the owners manual. I don't know how this seat is allowed to be sold.

Helpful?74ZQR0W5JVD316609312301
reply from DorelJuvenileSupport

We’re very sorry to hear about your experience and understand your concern about the car seat’s stability. From your description, it sounds like there may be an installation issue, as the seat should remain secure when installed correctly according to the instructions. Safety is our top priority, and we take feedback like this very seriously. Please contact our Consumer Care Team at 1-800-544-1108—they can guide you step by step to ensure the car seat is installed safely, or assist with a replacement or refund if needed.

Jan 3, 2026
MrsEast
5 out of 5 stars review

Safety 1st is a Great Brand!

This car seat is holding up for our two year old son (turning three in four months). We did lose one of the seatbelt cushions unfortunately, but the functionality is still great. We used it in rear-facing and he is now front facing, along with one adjustment to the headrest. Cupholders are super easy to clean. I usually vacuum out the seat so as to prevent dropped food from spoiling in the crevices. Easy installation, sturdy, and reliable.

Helpful?74ZQR0W5JVD316609312301
Apr 21, 2022
Granny
3 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Strong arm

Why can't car seats be more user friendly. Using the instructions, I could not tighten the belt enough to secure this car seat in my back seat. I had to get daddy (who ended up adding my seat belt) in order to tighten and secure it in the back seat. Now I'm afraid if I have to remove it, I will not be able to reinstall it. No wonder they are not installed properly. Maybe this is why it was on sale!

Helpful?74ZQR0W5JVD316609312301