Customer reviews for Safety 1st Everfit All-in-One Convertible Car Seat, Choose Color forSafety 1st Everfit All-in-One Convertible Car Seat, Choose Color
Most helpful positive review
4 customers found this helpful
5 out of 5 stars review
Verified Purchase
Love this car seat!
Angela
Most helpful negative review
6 customers found this helpful
1 out of 5 stars review
There’s a reason why it’s so cheap
anonymous
2,237 reviews
Filter by:
Sort by:
- 4 out of 5 stars review9/22/2022Very nice car seat, down fall was there were no latches to attach to the vechile seat so it made it move a lot. For this we returned it and will look for one with the latches like our infant seat. It was very well made and lots of room.
Carseat
Ccat - 5 out of 5 stars review8/31/2024I bought this a year ago for our infant daughter. She has been using it now for four months. Today we got in an accident. It protected her from any harm. Will definitely be purchasing again!
Kept My Baby Safe
EspressoandInkDorelJuvenileSupportThank you for sharing your feedback. We would love to speak with you regarding your experience. Please reach out to our Prod... - 5 out of 5 stars review8/30/2026good product qualityDuane
- 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase11/19/2025Good quality
Great product
Dm - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase10/20/2025Nice career.
Car seat
Gma - 1 out of 5 stars review5/2/2023It arrived in a brown box, not the actual box you buy in stores. It was just tossed in there with no packaging and not even a plastic bag or wrap to protect it. The tape on the outside was barely stuck on and it was partly opened when it arrived. Looks like it was used or just dirty because it wasn't sealed or protectedTkDorelJuvenileSupportThank you for your review. All items are new, sourced and shipped directly from the manufacturer. With Dorel being the large...
- 4 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase10/20/2023This is a great car seat for a toddler. After having trouble positioning as a rear facing seat, I researched and found that crash testing for this seat scored 2 out of 5 for rear facing. It also doesn’t take into account that a young child will inevitably fall asleep while riding. There isn’t enough recline position in this seat for an infant to sleep safely. My son is 10 months old so this seat will be used only as forward facing when he turns one.
Do not buy as an infant seat!
HazelAngel - 1 out of 5 stars review4/19/2022Would not secure properly in either of our vehicles in rear facing, the cushions on the straps were unusable when straps were tightened and chest clip was in proper position, if you can afford something else please don’t buy this, we immediately returned them.
Didn’t work for us
MJSupplier ResponseHello, Thank you for your review. We are sorry to hear of your experience with your car seat. Our car seats carry a 1 year ... - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase10/23/2023Very nice car seat. Child is secure. Has extra cushions for comfort and holders on the side to hold the straps so they are not in the way as you take your child out and put them in. I like that you can adjust for growth with one hand and do not have to take the seat apart. I love this car seat! Great price also.
Great investment in your childs safety.
Lori J - 1 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase2/23/2023WORST thing you could buy ever even when installed the right way there is still so much slack and movement with the seat even if the child is IN THE ACTUAL SEAT! buckled in and everything there is still movement. I used this for one trip not even that far from my house maybe 30 minutes and that was it I had to put the seat belt over the car seat to try to stop it from moving or worse falling over with my child in the seat. I was terrified . I immediately filed for a rerun online and Sam's club so called customer service didn't help much besides annoying me every single day . I scheduled a pickup for the return so I didn't have to go back out and drop it off and I kept getting calls about the pickup that was ALREADY SCHEDULED . Every few hou...
THE WORST heed my warning or injury could occur
KatDorelJuvenileSupportThank you for your review. We are sorry to hear of your experience and our Consumer Care Team is happy to help! You can text... - 1 out of 5 stars review12/24/2024Difficult to install, hard to get tight enough. Also, easy to install incorrectly. A family member has the Spanish side facing the door, they did not see the rear facing belt path and put the belt through fwd facing belt path. I was able to correct. Note: manual states when installed rear facing it MUST touch the seat in front of it. This is the opposite of most other seats I've installed. My brother was not able to install seat securely in his vehicle. Seat was able to tip because his wife drives with the drivers seat too far forward for the seat to touch the seat in front of it. This seat has a lower weight limit for rear facing (only 40 lbs) compared to 50 lbs with many other seats.
Difficult to install correctly.
ConcernedDorelJuvenileSupportThank you for your review. We are sorry to hear of your experience and our Consumer Care Team is happy to help! You can text... - 3 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase4/21/2022Why can't car seats be more user friendly. Using the instructions, I could not tighten the belt enough to secure this car seat in my back seat. I had to get daddy (who ended up adding my seat belt) in order to tighten and secure it in the back seat. Now I'm afraid if I have to remove it, I will not be able to reinstall it. No wonder they are not installed properly. Maybe this is why it was on sale!
Strong arm
Granny - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase5/31/2022Great seat. My granddaughter is big for her age-not fat. We needed a seat that would grow with her. She likes this seat too. She is six month's old. We bought 3 so we wouldn't have to transfer aeat and child and with the great price we could. Highly recommended
Love the seat
ymv1999 - 2 out of 5 stars review10/24/2022my husband and i have tried every way it show to put this car seat in the car and it just doesn't seem to strap down tight enough. It says the top should not move more than 1-2 inches and I feel like if we pushed it, it would just fling off. I'm not sure if this is user error or what but we've tried both ways and it still just doesn't make me feel like it's very secure and safe... Please help if you have any tips...stacy72DorelJuvenileSupportHello, thank you for your feedback. Please reach out to the Consumer Care Team for assistance with the installation of your ...
- 5 out of 5 stars review4/3/2023I see a lot of negative reviews about this seat not getting tight. Sad to say that is user error and should not be held against the car seat. Yes, it is hard to tighten when installing, especially alone. I had to sit on it while my husband pulled the tightening strap. However, this is the experience we’ve had with any seat or car seat base we’ve installed. So that said, we’re happy with it. Both kids seem comfortable (twins). I follow a page on Instagram called Safe In The Seat and that’s when I realized that my forward facing stage 2 car seat wasn’t ideal. This seat will last my kids quite a while until I’m comfortable flipping them forward The cup holders twist out for easy washing and the padded shoulder strap covers are nice and also r...
Great Value!
Nicole - 5 out of 5 stars review3/26/2025Great Car Seat! My daughter has gone through all of the stages of this car seat and it has been great. It has been easy to adjust and use and she never complains about comfort. We take several long road trips and she never complains about being in it. We ended up getting a second one for our other vehicle and then buying a 3rd one for Grandma and Grandpa's car. We all have different car types and it fits great in all 3.Love ItDorelJuvenileSupportThanks for your review! We are humbled and flattered by your glowing review. It is absolutely amazing to know that your litt...
- 1 out of 5 stars review9/24/2023I've installed many carseats over the years with 5 kids. After installing (rear-facing), I tested how far it could move. It moved about 4" on the first push (it should move no more than 1"), and with subsequent jostling it almost went horizontal to the point that the child's head would hit the car seat two spots over. I'm really disappointed with this product. This is the first car seat I've bought that I'll return for the reason of moving dangerously too much after being "secured."
Moves WAY too much!
JimPDorelJuvenileSupportHello, we appreciate your feedback and apologize for this concern. The Consumer Care Team would be happy to assist you with ... - 5 out of 5 stars review4/8/2023We purchased this as a second seat for hubby's car. I was pretty hesitant to purchase because I saw negative reviews stating people could not get the seat secured tight in their vehicle but realized those were the ONLY negative reviews. All other reviews were great & people seemed to love it. I decided to purchase & give it a try for the price & just planned to return if it didn't work. I'm so glad we did!!! It's a great seat! I had to do some serious tugging and push down on the seat while pulling the seatbelt, but it is secure & not moving. I'm thinking those who couldn't get it tight enough was maybe user error & not the seat. I'm not sure if some people also realize you're supposed to test for movement at the BASE, not the head area ....
It's a very nice seat for the price!!
Britney - 2 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase8/16/2023I liked that it could grow with the baby, but...It doesn't convert to a carrier. I didn't realize this when purchasing. Secondly, it was difficult to install in the car, but we got it done. Unfortunately, the hospital staff wouldn't let the baby leave in the carseat because the straps wouldn't tighten enough on the baby's chest to deem it safe. The seat was returned.
Looked good
Disappointed - 4 out of 5 stars review12/20/2022It's built well. I did have an issue with it being delivered in an open box with no plastic protection so it got wet in the rain. So it would probably be better as a pick up item. When it's in rear facing, it tips over. (I have a 2019 Ford fiesta) and I've seen other people write the same thing. I'm going to continue to try and fiddle with it to get it to stay, but as of now it's probably just best as forward facing. It's very nice to look at and it's soft material.
Great car seat, BUT
Maddie