Good value

Excellent quality

Love this brand

Horrified to report that 3 of 8 of the gallons of milk I purchased were spoiled and they are dated for July 1st...at least a week prior to their due dates...

It's milk. White liquid with all the fat necessary to carry the sugars out of the body. Thankfully it isn't ultra-pasteurized like the fraudulent "organic milk". I prefer raw milk, but that can be hard to come by. Usually matches the best "sale" prices at the local grocer, but alwas this price at Sam's.

Used to be good product for my family especially when kids were babies. Nowadays they don't make as good milk as before. Multiple times my kids complaint that the remaining half gallon tastes weird. And they surely were right after I tried too. I'm switching to other store brands now as they offer cheaper yet better quality milk..

Used to be one of the best buys for Milk. Lasted way past the Best By date and tasted great. But it has gone from good to terrible, bypassed bad at lightning speed. They no longer have the seal under the cap and when you pour there are globs of what can only be described as Milk Jelly coming out. The inner top of the jug is lined with it. Not looking to eat my Milk so I will return to the normal grocery store brands. This has happened several times and with several jugs (6+), so no excuse that this was a one time incident.

I love the milk. Creamy enough for soups and sauces. The kids love the taste. All goes well until about a week before the “sell by” date. Then it turns sour and I have to dump it down the drain. I’ve complained to Sam’s Club and once I brought it in to return for a refund. Each time I was told that it has been an ongoing issue with their milk. Why??? I have considered buying a half gallon, but I don’t want to run to the store more than once a week. Do I just try to use as much as I can before it turns for the worse. Disappointing.

I’ve been pouring Member's Mark Vitamin D Whole Milk into my mornings lately, and it’s become a solid staple in my fridge! This milk delivers everything you’d expect from a quality whole milk—rich, creamy, and full-bodied with that classic dairy taste that makes everything better. Whether I’m sipping it straight, splashing it into my coffee, or pouring it over cereal, it’s consistently smooth and satisfying. The added Vitamin D is a nice bonus, giving me a little extra nutrition without any fuss. The 1-gallon jug is super convenient for my household, and the price is hard to beat for such a generous amount. It stays fresh for a good while, too, which I appreciate since I don’t have to run to the store as often. My only tiny gripe—and why it’s 4 stars instead of 5—is that it’s not quite as decadent as some premium brands I’ve tried; it’s great, but not mind-blowing. Still, for everyday use, it hits all the right notes. Member's Mark Vitamin D Whole Milk is a reliable, tasty choice that gets the job done with ease. If you’re looking for a no-nonsense, high-value milk that tastes good and feels good, this is a fantastic pick—four stars for keeping my fridge happy!

Always purchase our milk from Sam’s! For some reason the last few purchases was a disaster. As soon as we get home to unpack, my kids like to dig for the cookies and milk. When I grab the milk to open the cap to pour, as I open the cap there is melted residue from the seal that is supposed to protect from contaminants. At this time it is already too late to return. So we disposed of the milk. Next time we’ll just ask to open the caps before purchase.