Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Customer reviews for Member’s Mark 2% Reduced Fat Milk 1 gal. for
Member’s Mark 2% Reduced Fat Milk 1 gal.

Member photos

Sort by |
Showing 1,301-1,310 of 1,360 reviews
Dec 18, 2020
wheelzzz
1 out of 5 stars review

Spoils before expiration date

We've bought this milk a couple of times & always had a problem with it spoiling within 2-3 days after opening it. Also weird taste. Won't buy again. I would not recommend this brand, unless you like chunks in your milk.

Helpful?7GQGDX89EYJQ16452423770
Sep 7, 2021
Grandad_2003
1 out of 5 stars review

Separated after freezing

We always purchase galleries of milk and freeze 3 quart bottles. This milk unlike other milk will clump up and separate after it’s defrosted. We’re purchased 1% and 2% and both have this problem.

Helpful?7GQGDX89EYJQ16452423770
Aug 11, 2024
Shelly
1 out of 5 stars review

Couldn't open

The carton design is horrible. I never could get it open, even with vice grips. I ended up poking a hole in the jug with a knife to pour it out. I will never buy Sam's milk again.

Helpful?7GQGDX89EYJQ16452423770
Jan 19, 2023
sad cow
3 out of 5 stars review

doesn’t last

If your a heavy milk user or drinker it’s 5 stars but most retailers the milk has a longer shelf life than this brand of milk or my Sam’s does a bad job on rotating the milk stock

Helpful?7GQGDX89EYJQ16452423770
Oct 11, 2021
Meema
4 out of 5 stars review

Top to tight.

The milk tastes great but I’m a senior citizen and the twist off too was too hard to take off. When I finally got it off, the pull tab was harder to pull off. Needless to say some pliers and a pair of scissors helped. The milk was great.

Helpful?7GQGDX89EYJQ16452423770
Mar 9, 2025
SB
3 out of 5 stars review

Getting Bad these days

First of all no proper stock at Vernon Hills, IL location. Every other time I visit it won't be there. Also these days the milk is turning bad before expiration date. Happened multiple times now.

Helpful?7GQGDX89EYJQ16452423770
Jun 1, 2021
unhappy
1 out of 5 stars review

design flaw

Super sick of this new design! We have had so much difficulty getting this product opened. We’ve brought pliers in from the garage in order to get them open. Please bring back regular milk jugs!!

Helpful?7GQGDX89EYJQ16452423770
reply from Member's Mark Support

We are sorry! Rest assured we are working with our supplier to make corrections.

Apr 19, 2025
dm23
3 out of 5 stars review

Good milk bad pricing.

This milk tastes like milk. Its in different container than typical gallon milk. Only issue i have is its priced more expensive than another grocery store and even Walmart. $2.77 ar Walmart and $3.34 at sams. Makes no sense.

Helpful?7GQGDX89EYJQ16452423770
Jan 25, 2025
dogmom
1 out of 5 stars review

Expired too soon

Buyer beware, had order delivered to me. Won't buy this item again as it expired in 7 days from delivery. Buying in bulk is great but not when I could buy from store locally and have last as long as I need for 2 people. Very disappointed.

Helpful?7GQGDX89EYJQ16452423770
Jul 21, 2020
Joe
1 out of 5 stars review

Milk Not Good

Bought 2 gallons on the 20th 1st gallon best by date 25th tasted sour. 2nd gallon best by date 30th tasted good. When you order online to pick up at store you cannot choose best by date.

Helpful?7GQGDX89EYJQ16452423770