New jug is too tall for my fridge shelf, and is harder to tell how much milk is left just by looking at it. I’m sure they save an eighth of a cent with the new design but I will pay more for milk elsewhere to stick with normal.

Milk spoiled at least 5 days before date on jug. The seal is also sometimes difficult to open and sometimes just falls apart without completely opening.

Sometimes the cap is so hard to hard to open to break the seal. I think it is from being stacked on a pallet and it gets smashed down. I thought it was just me but my sister and neighbors have the same issue. Very frustrating.

From the first day this milk was gross. My husband and children complained from day 1. It did not outdate, but I threw it out after 5 days. No one would drink it. I won't buy it again. No matter the price.

Why does Sam's Club charge $3.25 whole, $2.88 2%, and $2.67 for 1% milk when Walmart chargers $2.67 for all 3 versions? Jug is sturdy and nice but price variation makes no sense. 4⭐ since it costs 8% more for a membership club

I got this milk over the weekend and the use by date was aug 11. We opened today and both jugs that I got where bad already. Tasted sour and had white stuff floating in it.

I purchased the milk on April 6. We began using it on April 7 and by the 9th it was sour (expiration date is the 16th). Very disappointing especially since the price is higher at Sam’s Club!

This has been our favorite for years. We live an hour away so I buy 4-5 gallons at a time and freeze them. The containers used by sams allow for easy freezing. I have never had any problems freezing this milk and thawing. The last 4 I purchased, when thawed, the milk completely separated, clabbered and nothing would reconstitute it. I have never experienced ANY milk doing this to this extent. ESPECIALLY sams brand!! Cheap brands have differing degrees of separation during thaw that is remedied by shaking the container a few times during the thaw process and once thawed. Sadly, I guess we are back to buying Bordens. I will say that I will try again with 1 gallon to see if it was just this batch. 🤞

We always buy this milk I have no idea who brain storm idea this was with this new milk container I see people complaining about the seal what the big deal my problem the milk container it to HIGH it's hard to fit on the fridge door I have to lay the milk container down & some x I even put it into the other milk container I feel Sam's need to go back to the old milk container some older people will have trouble taking that seal off but if that is the only problem you have in life don't complain ok but the QUALITY of the milk is great

Sam's milk is usually good but the one I purchased at Sam's in Panama City yesterday has something wrong with it. It has a weird taste and is foamy on the sides of a glass. First noticed it with a bowl of cereal and thought it was the cereal until I drank it out of a glass. Anybody else run into this?