Bought 2 gallons on the 20th 1st gallon best by date 25th tasted sour. 2nd gallon best by date 30th tasted good. When you order online to pick up at store you cannot choose best by date.

The milk tastes great but I'm a senior citizen and the twist off too was too hard to take off. When I finally got it off, the pull tab was harder to pull off. Needless to say some pliers and a pair of scissors helped. The milk was great.

Why did they change the design? This design sucks. More times then not, I've had trouble with opening the lid and tab. And elderly mother cannot open it at all. Please make a better design.

We always purchase galleries of milk and freeze 3 quart bottles. This milk unlike other milk will clump up and separate after it's defrosted. We're purchased 1% and 2% and both have this problem.

This is the second time I have purchased this milk and the second time the milk has spoiled before the sell by date. Also the spout design is awful for pouring.

This milk spoiled in just a few days! What a waste of milk and our money! I rarely buy this milk compared to the milk at BJ's, but whenever I do, it spoils!!

The milk is just fine, but the design of the container is horrible. It's difficult to pour from, especially for kids. I have stopped buying milk at Sam's because of this design and the spills it causes, unfortunately (and inconveniently for me!).

The new jug design is great and something we've been saying needed done forever. Finally you can pour without milk dribbling down the side of the jug. The seal is a pain, that could use updating. It's really hard to peel off. But the shape of the jug is smart and much appreciated!

Gave this milk another chance recently. Still awful taste, like plastic.

Milk is fine but this is the worst container that ive encountered.