Most helpful positive review
4 customers found this helpful
5 out of 5 stars review
Verified Purchase
Taste and price? Excellent!
SteHanBBQ
Most helpful negative review
1 out of 5 stars review
Verified Purchase
Did not like
Deblv
85 reviews
Filter by:
Sort by:
- 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase7/6/2019I used to drink another premium brand that in comparison costs 4X as much. A neighbor of mine had a taste comparison test between blended Scotch (had to be imported from Scotland as well regardless of price) between 8 of us 7 out of 8 chose the Members Mark brand for taste and smoothness. All had it either on the rocks or straight as with the others we tried...
Taste and price? Excellent!
SteHanBBQ - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase8/25/2022Where have you been?! This has become my favorite blended Scotch whisky. I was so disappointed when it disappeared from the shelves months ago that I quit drinking Scotch. I haven't enjoyed another, so smooth and tasteful, not even the much more expensive brands. Try it you! You'll like it.
Welcome Back
precious - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase6/20/2020First time try. Surprisingly pleased with the quality for the bucks. Tastefully robust straight-up/neat! Pleasantly palitable on the rocks! Well worth repeat purchases with honest recommendations.
I Explored, Discovered, and was Glad I Did!
Wacnificent - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase11/3/2022For my tastes, as good as Scotch costing much more
Rusty Nail or on the rocks
JLM - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase4/7/2023Smooth Scotch. Great taste with a very low cost. I wish Sams Club would keep it.
Keep it in inventory
Sammy - 5 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase4/17/2022Good for the price
Generic scotch at its' finest
Scotch fan - 5 out of 5 stars review1/14/2018I like McCallan 12, Fine Oak and Whiskey Maker's Edition. They are pricier, and I used to drink Dewars for when I didn't have company or weekend drinking (mainly because I travel a lot and that's what they serve on the plane). I bought this to try, and I was off for Christmas for two weeks. I drank this nightly, and I think it is very good especially for the price. People complain about the smokey, but since I like McCallan Oak, it might just be up my alley. If I want to have a less expensive scotch at home, this will be go to. I think it is better than Dewars , J&B, etc. Not as good as the $50-$100 bottles, but that's unfair to compare.
Oaky taste - but good for regular drinking
MotownKevin - 5 out of 5 stars review9/18/2018Don't know what the people complain about, probably just they are bourbon drinkers and have no clue about scotch. This is best Scotch for the money!!! Cheers
Best Scotch Ever!
val - 5 out of 5 stars review8/10/2018i would say this taste very similar to Johnnie Walker Red Label with a touch of double black Johnnie Walker, you really cant go wrong with the price. will be going back for this
like a johnnie walker
Charlie - 5 out of 5 stars review9/1/2021This item has a taste profile that is somewhere between Johnny Walker Red and Dewar's. At this price point I consider this item to be a very good value for the money.
Great Scotch at a Great Value!
Martha - 5 out of 5 stars review1/7/2020The taste comes though even over ice. Can also enjoy straight. I can’t afford the “good” stuff, but this blows away any of the lower shelf brands, and at the same price. Others reviewers have compared it to Johnny Walker Red. The only down-side is it’s a heavy glass bottle.
Great taste, great price
Jaxy - 5 out of 5 stars review8/17/2018Very similar to Johnny Walker red, I recommend this over the name brand. It's the same thing, bigger quantity and cheaper.The Dude
- 5 out of 5 stars review10/3/2019My wife loves Jonny as her daily drinker. A blind taste test showed she preferred the MM, and at half the price! Win-win.
Great JW Red Replacement
BW - 5 out of 5 stars review3/21/2026Very good scotch, bring it back!MICHELLE
- 4 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase4/1/2024This was honestly pretty good Scotch. I typically don’t usually buy blended but I thought I’d give it a go. I was happy with how it tasted and it did have a peaty taste to it which I love. I think this can be a great addition to the home bar not bad for a 3 year aged scotch.
Not bad for 3 year age scotch
Benny - 4 out of 5 stars review1/19/2018Scotch, like wine, has many variations and as many opinions about what is "good". I prefer blended scotches (JW Blue is my favorite). Many favor single malts. I have friends on both sides. But just for drinking at home I like the Member's Mark scotch which I have replaced Dewar's White Label with.
Very good scotch for the money
DanL - 4 out of 5 stars review1/6/2020For the money, this is really hard to beat. I paid $19 for a 1.75 of this, which is just a stellar deal. This is a lightly peated scotch, even more lightly peated than JW Black, and a lot smoother and richer than Famous Grouse or Teachers. It does have a bit of an edge from the young grain whiskies in it, but there's a fairly nice body and a honey note. I've not tried JW Red, but have tried Dewar's White. I'd take the Member's Mark over the Dewar's anytime. Very happy with this, and I wish there was more reviews online because the people reviewing it here clearly don't have much experience with scotch. It's not top shelf, but this is top value.
Exceptional value for the daily dram
DiciplesofBacon - 4 out of 5 stars review4/12/2021Let's be real. You're getting a half gallon of blended whisky for $19. If you're expecting JW you'll be disappointed, but if you want a decent blended whisky for 1/3 the cost... buy it.
You get what you pay for
Vano - 4 out of 5 stars review12/23/2021I like my whisky bland and not a lot of after taste. To me this is better than JW red but a little blander than JW black. But also lower cost than JW black. Most of my buddies that are in to flavorful character scotch’s wouldn’t like any of these options.
better than jw red
browja66 - 1 out of 5 stars reviewVerified Purchase11/1/2019Do not buy this. Really disappointed and have go agree with other's with the taste of gasoline. So many other options are better.
Did not like
Deblv