Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Customer ratings & reviews for
SALTED BUTTER QTRS 1LB - 4 STICKS
4.9 out of 5 stars
stars3,946 ratings3,838 reviews
  1. 5 stars94% (3,722)
  2. 4 stars3% (112)
  3. 3 stars1% (21)
  4. 2 stars1% (24)
  5. 1 star2% (67)
Write a review

Customer photos

  • +128 images
Sort by |
Showing 81-90 of 3,838 reviews
Feb 2, 2024
Anonymous
1 out of 5 stars review

As mom says, “I'm not mad, I'm just disappointed”

I make the best chocolate chip cookies. For years, I have touted LOL salted sticks as the #1 choice for baking-and you deserved every accolade. However, shame on you for not admitting that you changed something. Jeesh, I thought my oven was broken!! I feel vindicated seeing all these other comments and wish you just put “new recipe” on the box.

Review from landolakes.com
Helpful?1978GOWKJBOW15344465100
reply from Consumer Affairs

We appreciate your long time business and review. We have sent you an email so we can learn more about your recent experience.

Jan 8, 2024
Bob
1 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

not very happy

I bought a case of soda, it wont let me write a review on it but anyways ive just about lost my patients with this store this is the 2nd complaint in the last 2 weeks the only reason ive been coming here is because of dentists appointments the case was wet and busted can inside and dented cans lookslike someone dropped right before i received it i definately want a refund

Review from walmart.com
Helpful?1978GOWKJBOW15344465100
Dec 24, 2023
Trina
1 out of 5 stars review

Ever since Covid your butter has been awful...

Prior to Covid all my cookies were perfect. Since 2020 or 2021 whatever you did to your butter has ruined my baking. My cookies are flat greasy garbage. I have changed absolutely nothing. I have thrown out more cookies and dough in the last three years. I will be trying something else, probably Kerrygold, I guess. Shame on you Land o Lakes for whatever you did to ruin your butter and my baking. My heart is so sad.i learned my lesson, finally making the switch after 2 or 3 crappy Christmas cookie seasons.

Review from landolakes.com
Helpful?1978GOWKJBOW15344465100
reply from Consumer Affairs

We are sorry to hear of your issues when baking Christmas cookies in the past 2 or 3 years. We have not intentionally made any changes to our butter. Please watch for an email coming from us soon.

Apr 16, 2020
Longtimefan
1 out of 5 stars review

BOOOOO to the changes!

I have aexclusively used your product for many years. Recently, I thought it tasted a bit different and I was glad to come across these reviews! I agree. I don't know what has changed but it wasn't for the good. Then, yesterday, I read that you are abandoning your mascot of 92 years. BOOOOOOOO. I AM Native and didn't find it even slightly offensive. Another one bites the dust. Sad.

Review from landolakes.com
Helpful?1978GOWKJBOW15344465100
reply from Consumer Affairs

Thank you for your comments. As Land O'Lakes looks toward the 100th anniversary of our cooperative in 2021, we’re seeking new ways to tell our farmer-owned story to consumers. We’re doing this by rolling out new packaging for our products, which began in 2019. The new packaging features words like “Farmer-owned” and “Since 1921” above vibrant images of land and lakes. While the packaging is new, the ingredients in the products have not changed and the same delicious products are inside. Please look for an email from us

Dec 16, 2023
Barb
2 out of 5 stars review

What has changed?

I just made and baked the same Christmas cookie I've been making for 50 years. When I creamed the butter and the sugar, it never really creams. This has never happened before. The dough was different. They didn't get as big as they usually do. They were harder. They usually melt in your mouth. Also, when i took them out to soften, never got as soft as I needed them after two hours on counter. What is going on??

Review from landolakes.com
Helpful?1978GOWKJBOW15344465100
reply from Consumer Affairs

We apologize for your experience when making your Christmas cookies this year. We have not intentionally changed our butter recipe. Please watch for an email from us.

Jul 25, 2022
Connie
1 out of 5 stars review

Flavor

The flavor you had in this product has gone or so mild I don't even taste it anymore. I'm going to try Continental butter chips hope the flavor of butter is still there. You can't get cheap on butter or you loose your flavor and that's what sold this butter.

Review from landolakes.com
Helpful?1978GOWKJBOW15344465100
reply from Consumer Affairs

We appreciate your review and apologize for your experience. Please watch for an email from us.

Mar 6, 2022
Kate
4 out of 5 stars review

What has changed?!

I will ONLY use land o lakes butter. I make cakes, and will not substitute with any other butter. It seems that it has changed recently, and the consistency is runnier when softened. My icing won't stand up like it should. It also smells a little different. I have been through multiple boxes, bought at different times from different stores, and this seems to be the case just as of 2022. I don't know what is going on, but please switch it back!

Review from landolakes.com
Helpful?1978GOWKJBOW15344465100
reply from Consumer Affairs

We are sorry for the issues you have been experiencing with your icing. Please watch for an email coming from us so we can learn more.

Dec 30, 2021
Cinnamon
1 out of 5 stars review

Land o Lakes Butter has changed

I have used Land O Lakes Butter for years, and would never buy any other brand, but here in the last several months myself and my entire family have noticed a change in the butter consistency. It is like there has been some sort of oil added, its consistency is super greasy. This is super disappointing because we use alot of butter. I have read other reviews of the same complaint. You really need to check into this. At this time I am searching for another butter, because quite honestly I can't eat the greasy mess that your butter turns into. Never did that in the past.

Review from landolakes.com
Helpful?1978GOWKJBOW15344465100
reply from Consumer Affairs

We appreciate your review and apologize that the butter was been greasy for you recently. Please look for an email from us so we can learn more.

Feb 23, 2024
LifeIsFaire
1 out of 5 stars review

Packaging deceptive

We have been buying LOL for years recently the packaging has changed and SALTED needs to be more PROMINENT on package! My husband has been eating the WRONG butter for days and is on a sodium controlled diet,under 2000 mg per day and it matters darn it! Salted in small 1 shade off green color band is not sufficient especially since he is color blind and had to view on zoom in website to even see it, totally missed it on package. Saw blue stripe which is traditionally used for only un-salted packages and bought it.

Review from landolakes.com
Helpful?1978GOWKJBOW15344465100
reply from Consumer Affairs

We appreciate your feedback on the packaging and will share with our team. Please look for an email from us. For future reference, unsalted butter sticks are in a blue box.

Apr 12, 2023
Mary
3 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

We picked up our groceries at DeSoto Mo Walmart this evening. We opened up this head of cabbage about 6” long looking like it had been plucked of old leaves and not looking fresh at all. Surprised management would allow this to be on the shelf at this point. Not worth the trip back for return. Your produce could be better quality and fresher. I will go other places for my fresh produce from now on. Too many times it has happened.

Review from walmart.com
Helpful?1978GOWKJBOW15344465100