Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
All Departments
All Services
Member ratings & reviews for
Mr. Clean® Magic Eraser Extra Power - 10 ct.
4.4 out of 5 stars
stars
818 ratings818 reviews
  1. 5 stars75% (614)
  2. 4 stars8% (64)
  3. 3 stars4% (34)
  4. 2 stars4% (34)
  5. 1 star9% (72)

Member photos

  • +63 images
Sort by |
Showing 531-540 of 818 reviews
May 17, 2015
Reviewer name: sureyawright
5 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 stars review

Soot

I have been using this for years to clean my shower. Recently I had a kitchen fire. I had to throw away almost everything in my kitchen due to smoke and soot. A cleaning crew came and tried to get my dish set clean. But the soot was just smearing and not coming off. My dish set was passed down to me by my parents 20 years ago. They aren't fine china or anything fancy. But me and my step mom have a tradition where she finds pieces to the set at thrift stores, flea markets, tag sales, online, etc. then every Christmas she gives me what she found that year. I have almost the entire set now. When I called my step mom to tell her the news.. All of them are destroyed, she suggested to try the magic eraser. Why didn't I think of that?!?! I grabbed one and tried it on one piece and it worked like magic! I was effortlessly removing all the soot! I gave them a nice hot rinse and then repeated the process in case of any missed spots. I am so grateful for this product! Without it I would have lost a gift 20 years in the making!

Review from mrclean.com
Helpful?3K6DUA36F2KW15337405557
Jan 27, 2011
Reviewer name: Sdowell
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

Magic Eraser

I bought this product because I have small children and their mess's make it to the walls sometimes, but this product would not even get color crayon off the walls. I would never but this product again. Also scuffs on shoes it didn't work at all, a toothbrush and cleaner works way better, sorry but I had a very poor experience.

Review from mrclean.com
Helpful?3K6DUA36F2KW15337405557
reply from Mr Clean Team

I'm surprised by your report. I have 4 children and use the Magic Erasers for the exact messes you mentioned. Perhaps you have a package that doesn't meet our standards. Please call us with package handy at: 1-800-867-2532.

Jul 11, 2011
Reviewer name: Caleigh
4 out of 5 stars
4 out of 5 stars review

Who needs other cleaning products when you've got this?!

I was skeptical about a little sponge that could do so much, but I decided to test these puppies out anyways. The results were PHENOMENAL! I cleaned every wipeable surface of my apartment with magic erasers when I moved out. Besides my irreversible damage to the carpet, the magic eraser made my former residence look even better than when I moved into it! I cleaned like a madwoman, removing furniture marks on walls and door frames, pen and marker spots, really old stains on the upper part of the wall from exploding carbonated beverages, fingerprints and some of the most formally stubborn stains from the dark reaches of the universe. My only complaint is how quickly those wonderful sponges start to shred. Unfortunately, there aren't enough magic erasers in the world to fix up my new place, which at the very least should be condemned and incinerated! It's amazing how gross fifty years of college kids renting out a house can be. Let's just say, black mold is the least of my roommates' and my worries, but at least we're out of our annoying, though now delightfully clean and shiny, apartments. Thanks for the magiclean, Mr. Clean!

Review from mrclean.com
Helpful?3K6DUA36F2KW15337405557
Aug 28, 2009
Reviewer name: Susie
5 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 stars review

Kitchen floor like new

I used the Magic Eraser on my linoleum kitchen floor. Hated the floor because it had stained over the years on the mostly white background. I cleaned with the eraser today, and the floor looks great! Several hours on my knees to go through the whole room, but well worth it!!! Had tried every cleaner I could think of and nothing worked like this!

Review from mrclean.com
Helpful?3K6DUA36F2KW15337405557
Jun 12, 2015
Reviewer name: MamaDawg
2 out of 5 stars
2 out of 5 stars review

We love the product but ...

We own a detail shop and use a number of different tools and tricks to get things clean. We tried the Magic Eraser and loved it, it was truly like magic, the eraser got things out we didn't think were possible. We started off using just the regular duty and then graduated to the "Extra Power" because the other just wasn't stout enough to handle us! Overall we LOVE the product, the only thing I don't like is that it tears too easily while scrubbing making it difficult because then pieces fall into the car leaving more mess. We tried a similar product of an off brand nature and it held together quite a bit better. If you make the eraser stronger we will use it only!!

Review from mrclean.com
Helpful?3K6DUA36F2KW15337405557
reply from Mr. Clean Team

Thanks for your loyalty to Mr. Clean Magic Erasers in your detail shop. They compress & break down as they're being used, and we'll share your recommendation to make them stronger with the rest of our team. Feel free to call us at 1-855-236-3353 if we can help further. We're open M-F from 9-6 ET. Thanks for taking the time to write a review!

Jun 12, 2012
Reviewer name: nburg
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

Waste of money!

VERY DISAPPOINTED with the Magic Eraser - Extra Power. I saw the commercial for using it on white shoes, so though I would try it. The eraser would just fall apart and left a flaky mess! I really could not get a good cleaning job done on the shoes because of this flaw. Tried it on some smooth surfaces also. Not impressed at all. Does not perform as advertised. Sorry I got it.

Review from mrclean.com
Helpful?3K6DUA36F2KW15337405557
Sep 6, 2011
Reviewer name: 1aliceincleanland
2 out of 5 stars
2 out of 5 stars review

Quality has diminished

Hello, I've used the magic erasers since they came on the scene, and I think the quality has diminished. I used to be able to clean items over a lengthy period of time, whereas nowadays, the magic eraser begins to tear and pieces fall off, before I've completed cleaning a couple of items. I've always loved the fact that it is definitely "magic", but am disappointed with the product quality of today. It cleans beautifully, but this eraser doesn't last very long. Sincerely, Alice in Connecticut

Review from mrclean.com
Helpful?3K6DUA36F2KW15337405557
reply from Mr Clean Team

I'm sorry to hear the Mr Clean Magic Eraser Extra Power is tearing more quickly. I'm not sure what may have gone wrong. They are designed to compress and break down as it's used - like a rubber eraser. It can leave behind small pieces of residue, much like an eraser does. The life span of the pad depends on the roughness of the surface and number of times used previously. Although I know you have used them for years here are some recommendations when using them. •Wet pad with water, then squeeze out excess, don't over saturate. •Gently rub pad on surface to remove tough dirt and grime. Hope you give it another try. If you have any other questions please give us a call at (800) 867-2532.

Aug 3, 2009
Reviewer name: grandma
5 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 stars review

Amazing product

I thought I would need to repaint the interior doors in my house. I decided to try to clean them first with the Magic Eraser Extra Power. I am amazed! It was fun and easy to remove all the scuff marks and dirt. I am so delighted that I will not have to endure the expense and work involved in painting. Thank you so much for this amazing product!!!

Review from mrclean.com
Helpful?3K6DUA36F2KW15337405557
Mar 7, 2015
Reviewer name: Tekers
5 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 stars review

magic erasers the extra strength ones

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I love this product, it is amazing for single people and especially for families. This product hasn't disappointed me yet. I use it on the walls, doors, base boards, shower, dog door, to clean make up off wood counter tops. I love that I can make my doors in the house back to being white for example from people not using door handles, with barely any effort it takes off the greasy, sticky, plan out dirty hand prints in seconds and it doesn't even use the whole eraser it lasts forever. I world recommended this product to anyone I could and do. Now that my kids are getting older they even love it, I mean that has to say something good for a teen to actually like to use something to clean is amazing.

Review from mrclean.com
Helpful?3K6DUA36F2KW15337405557
Oct 7, 2014
Reviewer name: Erin
5 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 stars review

Even removes damage left behind by other cleaners

So I was cleaning up the kitchen and found some old coffee and soda ring stains on the white Formica counter top from cups being left there. Soap and water wasn't doing the job so I decided to use some bleach. Well I guess I let it sit too long-WHOOPS! It left behind huge dark yellow stains and no amount of scrubbing with a sponge was going to get it off. After an internet search I tried silver jewelry cleaner which dulled them a bit but still left very obvious yellow stains. Finally I remembered we had some Mr. Clean Magic Eraser Extra Power sponges so I got one of those out and gave it a try. Well I'm happy to report there are no more yellow stains, the eraser completely removed them. I also discovered just how off-white the counters had become, the place where the stains had been was the whitest part of the counter! So the whole thing got a good scrubbing with the Magic Eraser and is now bright white again. It's got me searching the house for stains I thought were permanent to try the Magic Eraser on. It really is amazing, I thought I had ruined my counter with the bleach but now it looks like new!

Review from mrclean.com
Helpful?3K6DUA36F2KW15337405557