I don't know if I prefer the old round bottles or the new square, but they're ok. In the water dispenser we have, we didn't have an issue with the amount of water left in the bottle, but the units sold at Sam's might have that issue. Looking at the picture of the Primo Deluxe, it looks like the hose doesn't even reach the bottom of the bottle there! Anyway, at the price difference, I can live with pouring out a little room temp water. The reasons of the 1 star deduction are A) I wish these had handles for easy lifting and carrying. And B) The main reason is that I didn't find these very "no-spill". Quite the contrary, trying to puncture the top to insert the hose pushed out some water that I had to clean up. If I continue to have that issue, I guess I'll have to learn to change bottles on a towel.

I was skeptical after reading all the. Reviews having moved from NRH and the water source water store to duncanville this sams option is the best price. These work for me just fine. They fit in my bottom load dispenser and the tube goes all the way to the bottom. I took pictures but no option to add them.

I hate these square bottles. The water dispenser I use, which also came from Sam’s, doesn’t reach all the way to the bottom of the bottles. I either have to waste about half a gallon of water or use part of the next bottle then pour the last of it into the new one. Either way, it’s a pain, so I buy my water at Kroger now.

It works ok. Would prefer the 5 gallon over these.

Oh sure, they look nice—if you're into decorative water jugs that barely squeeze into your dispenser like it's a gym workout. Great for stacking, if your dream is to build a plastic tower. But if you're actually planning to drink the water? Might want to switch back to the good ol' reliable 4-gallon round ones. You know, the ones that actually fit your dispenser without a wrestling match.

Noisy don’t buy this

These gallon jugs were very helpful until Member's Mark decided to redesign the jug to be rectangular. My dispenser says we are out of water well before the jug is actually empty because the straws for the pump don't reach the bottom. Poorly executed.

Bottle too tall and dispenser hose doesn't reach bottom leaving 1/2 gallon of water in bottle.

Such a shame that they are no longer in stock. I purchased the whole set up and cant use the water station because there aren't any jugs

Loved the water, affordable I now have to pay for it to be deliveredand a bottle deposit. please bring the water jugs back!!