Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Member ratings & reviews for
PINE-SOL PINE 175 FL OZ
4.7 out of 5 stars
stars21.9K ratings21.8K reviews
  1. 5 stars82% (17.9K)
  2. 4 stars15% (3,247)
  3. 3 stars1% (322)
  4. 2 stars0% (85)
  5. 1 star2% (371)

Member photos

  • +466 images
Sort by |
Showing 331-340 of 21,857 reviews
Dec 6, 2023
Beeboop
5 out of 5 stars review

Iove pinesol

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] the smell of clean filled the entire house and would last for quite sometimes. Pine-sol became one of our family traditions that have been passed from generation to generation- three generations now. Now that you've changed from the original to the new longer lasting scent I can't pass that tradition on because it's not the original. The new scent is not a bad scent just not the scent that reminds me of home and family traditions. I realize that everything must change and everything has a season. I'm saddened to see the season of the original Pine-sol come to an end. Do you think Pine-sol, the original can make a comeback for those who grew up with it? Or be offered in addition to the new longer lasting scent for those who like the new scent?

Review from pinesol.com
Helpful?1M8FKMUI3WZ815315553458
Oct 27, 2013
Noelle
1 out of 5 stars review

The new smell is awful!

I would give it zero stars if I could. Reminds me of a gas station restroom!!! My family has used original Pine Sol for generations but I will not use it anymore. The new smell is nauseating. Puine sol, take a page from Coca Cola and get rid of the New Coke!

Review from pinesol.com
Helpful?1M8FKMUI3WZ815315553458
Sep 17, 2013
dissapointedinseattle
1 out of 5 stars review

Horrible New Scent!

This new scent pine-sol is absolutely horrid. Don't buy it. It does not clean as well as original formula and it smells like some off brand chemical cleaners. If you wash your cleaning rags with other clothes, your clothes will smell like this horrible pine-sol scent until you wash them four or five times. DON'T BUY!!

Review from pinesol.com
Helpful?1M8FKMUI3WZ815315553458
Feb 1, 2014
lholmes
1 out of 5 stars review

New Scent is a Big Mistake

The new scent is nothing like the original even though the label says original. This is a terrible idea. It would have been better to have a pine-sol "shortage" than trying to pass off whatever this is. The new/original isn't even the same consistency. I poured some in the sink water and I thought, something isn't right with this. So I googled it. I knew something was up. I'm going to try to get my money back. The original reminded me of my first house. When I was 20 and broke, I bought it. Now I'm 30 and not so broke and I still would buy it-if it was the same. I'm actually depressed over this. I know the old stuff is going to be sold online. But I want to be able to run to the store and buy it and not pay shipping or wait a week to get it.

Review from pinesol.com
Helpful?1M8FKMUI3WZ815315553458
Sep 5, 2013
Mr Mom
1 out of 5 stars review

Took it back, smell is sickening

My mom used Pine-Sol and I grew up with that clean pine scent in our house. Just last week I happily used the last of a bottle. Yesterday I got a new bottle, not noticing the New Scent notice on it. While cleaning the kitchen floor I realized there was a strange smell. I took a closer look at the bottle and saw the notice at that time. Thinking I might get use to it I finished the floor. By the time my wife came home I was sick of it and she asked me what that awful smell was. By bedtime she had a head ache from the smell that seemed to Last Longer. I took it back and am looking for a store that might have some of the old Pine-Sol left in stock. This reminds me of the time NEW COKE came out. Awful.

Review from pinesol.com
Helpful?1M8FKMUI3WZ815315553458
Jun 1, 2014
Cajun
2 out of 5 stars review

I don't like the new scent of the "Original"

I have always used Pine-Sol and grew up in a home where my mother always used it. However, I don't like the new scent for the "Original". I don't know why the decision was made to change it, but I will have to find another product to use since this scent is too strong for me. I don't like heavily perfumed scents. I purchased 2 bottles at the same time, and will probably throw away the contents of the first bottle and hopefully be able to return the second one to the store if I can find the receipt for it.

Review from pinesol.com
Helpful?1M8FKMUI3WZ815315553458
Oct 13, 2013
5millsboys
2 out of 5 stars review

New scent, not good!

I'm very disappointed with the new scent of Pine-sol. I've used it for years because of it's fresh non-floral scent and great cleaning power. It didn't bother our allergies. I'm said to say the new scent has a floral scent to it and immediately upon opening it I couldn't use it.

Review from pinesol.com
Helpful?1M8FKMUI3WZ815315553458
Sep 24, 2014
Trish
1 out of 5 stars review

This isn't MY Pine-Sol

My mother cleaned exclusively with Pine-Sol. I have always cleaned exclusively with Pine-Sol. When my children are older, I will clean their homes exclusively with Pine-Sol - just to have an excuse to smell the pine scent. That is... the scent of Original Pine-Sol, NOT the new long lasting version. I just bought a very large bottle of the new Pine-Sol, and used it to clean my kitchen. Not only does the new 'original' scent smell like a bucket of chemicals, it causes an almost immediate headache. Now, where is my old friend? The bathroom still needs to be cleaned.

Review from pinesol.com
Helpful?1M8FKMUI3WZ815315553458
Nov 8, 2013
Bringbacktherealpinesoloriginal!!!
1 out of 5 stars review

Bring Pine-Sol Back!!!!

The new and longer lasting smell is sad and not going to work - Pine-sol original is a classic, and you can't just change a classic. I know a lot of people who are not going to buy Pine-sol anymore, though they probably won't even bother to take the time to speak up about it. Pine-sol owes it to their customers to give us the Pine-sol we all know and love. The new smell smells like laundry detergent or something that could be any product, but its not Pine-sol. Give us back the real Pine-sol Original. I, and many others I know, will not be buying these products until its back!!

Review from pinesol.com
Helpful?1M8FKMUI3WZ815315553458
Jan 29, 2014
mountain girl
1 out of 5 stars review

Terrible scent!

Growing up my Mom used pine-sol so naturally I use pine-sol or should I say Used pine-sol. I just finished my 175 fl oz container and that's it! I never thought I would say this but "I will no longer be buying your product." I only like the original scent but the New longer lasting scent is TERRIBLE. My family thinks it just plain stinks. It is overpowering and yes it last long but who want that smell to linger. I will find another multi-purpose cleaner that disinfects & kills germs without the smell.

Review from pinesol.com
Helpful?1M8FKMUI3WZ815315553458