Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Member ratings & reviews for
HLM HEAVY MAYO GAL 1 GALLON
4.4 out of 5 stars
stars4,533 ratings4,531 reviews
  1. 5 stars78% (3,515)
  2. 4 stars8% (365)
  3. 3 stars3% (118)
  4. 2 stars3% (125)
  5. 1 star9% (410)

Member photos

  • +239 images
Sort by |
Showing 151-160 of 4,531 reviews
Sep 6, 2016
pwp2
1 out of 5 stars review

What happened???

I've used Hellman's, then Hellman's Light (when it came out) for my whole life!! What happened?? The last jar I bought had this smeary consistency and a horrible taste!! Almost as if it's half full of Canola oil. I've ruined 2 recipies with it already. I don't even have a second favorite brand because all I use is Hellman's. Can anyone suggest a new brand?

Review from hellmanns.com
Helpful?3MHT1URFP1OO15303509170
Mar 17, 2024
Ginger24
1 out of 5 stars review

Very sad customer

I am very disappointed in Hellman's. I always used your Mayo. Adding soybeans oil totally ruined my favorite Mayo. I will have to look for a new condiment to replace it.. you should think about going back to your original recipe.. one very sad customer

Review from hellmanns.com
Helpful?3MHT1URFP1OO15303509170
reply from Consumer Support

We truly appreciate you taking the time to share your feedback about our Real Mayonnaise. Our formulation hasn't changed, just the packaging. The intent of these changes is to continually improve our products as well as providing the best quality products possible. We'll make sure to share your comments with our team.

Mar 10, 2016
purpanda
1 out of 5 stars review

Acetic!

Why change something that was good and worked well for over 40 years? The change in recipe makes vinegar more noticeable makes it taste pungent and quite honestly just plain awful. It is creamier as advertised, so much so that it's runny and the texture feels a lot worse and is more suceptible to changes in temperature.

Review from hellmanns.com
Helpful?3MHT1URFP1OO15303509170
reply from Consumer Services

Thanks for contacting us here at Hellmann's. We have responded via email. Please check your inbox or spam folder for our correspondence.

Jan 6, 2015
thts
1 out of 5 stars review

tastes like plastic/oil

I grew up on Helmans (i am 50). whatever you did to the recpie is terrible. tastes like oil or plastic! was wondering why i was having such an aversion to it in recent months, then found out you changed the ingred. yuck! please go back to orig. ingred.

Review from hellmanns.com
Helpful?3MHT1URFP1OO15303509170
Feb 3, 2015
schy
2 out of 5 stars review

What's Up?

Help! Something is wrong with my Hellmann's Mayo! My last few jars were not nearly as thick and lush and the taste was just not quite right. I hope this is just a fluke and not a change in the ingredients or manufacturing. This is the only mayo I've used since a little girl ( a very long time ago) so I'm hoping it's just a temporary issue. Please....please don't change my Hellmann's!!!!!

Review from hellmanns.com
Helpful?3MHT1URFP1OO15303509170
reply from Consumer Services

Please contact Hellman's at Consumer.Services@Unilever.com or call 800 671-6025 so we may learn more about your experience. Thank you.

Jan 31, 2015
Gagi
1 out of 5 stars review

CHANGE IT BACK! Why, grinchy clause, why?

Where to begin? Had an old small jar I hadn't opened yet. Did a taste test versus current hellman's. WOW. The old real version is the Helman's we have loved for decades. The new version should be called HELLman's - it is a different color, has a paste like consistency, and the wonderful flavor is gone. GROSS. Helman's please please please listen to the customers and change it back.

Review from hellmanns.com
Helpful?3MHT1URFP1OO15303509170
reply from Consumer Services

We'd love to learn more about your taste and texture experience. Please contact Hellmann's at Consumer.Services@Unilever.com or call 800 671-6025 so we may further assist.

Dec 21, 2023
MayolessinGA
2 out of 5 stars review

I think it's time you come clean.

I am a 3rd generation "We only use Hellmans" family member, from a huge family of cooks. Our exlusive mayo does NOT taste the same. Nothing we make with it tastes the same, and we can all tell. What happened? This change-you're clearly not admitting-is NOT for the better. Please bring back your original recipe. We're already testing other brands. This new and not improved version will never do.

Review from hellmanns.com
Helpful?3MHT1URFP1OO15303509170
Nov 19, 2023
Mayo Purist
1 out of 5 stars review

Disappointed Former Fan

Please return to the old recipe!!! I used to love this stuff and could almost eat it out of the jar. This past spring I threw away many partial jars hoping for my tasty Hellmanns. Not to be! I am in South Carolina and my tomato sandwiches, tomato pie, 8 layer salad are all suffering. I am now a former Fan....willing to return with old recipe!!!

Review from hellmanns.com
Helpful?3MHT1URFP1OO15303509170
Oct 14, 2024
Tribble
1 out of 5 stars review

What happened to Hellman's

The recipe has changed and definitely not for the better. Creamy is not good, seems as if more water or something added. This mayonnaise now breaks down much faster and the taste is is more like a vinegar additive of some sort. Do not recommend and will not purchase any more in the future.

Review from hellmanns.com
Helpful?3MHT1URFP1OO15303509170
May 26, 2024
Rero8450
1 out of 5 stars review

DONT BUY THIS CRAP!!!!

Why did you change your product? Its DISCUSTING! Change it back. Have been a loyal customer all my life. Good luck selling this crap. Im not the only one that feels this way. CHANGE IS BACK TO THE ORIGINAL RECIPE!!!! You have lost my business along with others. Bocot this until they change it back!

Review from hellmanns.com
Helpful?3MHT1URFP1OO15303509170