Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Member ratings & reviews for
HLM HEAVY MAYO GAL 1 GALLON
4.4 out of 5 stars
stars4,533 ratings4,531 reviews
  1. 5 stars78% (3,515)
  2. 4 stars8% (365)
  3. 3 stars3% (118)
  4. 2 stars3% (125)
  5. 1 star9% (410)

Member photos

  • +239 images
Sort by |
Showing 121-130 of 4,531 reviews
Jan 22, 2024
Missmad
2 out of 5 stars review

Hellman's Mayo disappointed

Something has changed with the mayonaise recipe, it is oily and laeaves a weird sensation in the mouth. Is this consistnet with the change inte jar, it is supposed to me bore ecofriendly. But bring back the fluffy, origninla Hellman's Mayo! This new stuff is gross!

Review from hellmanns.com
Helpful?3MHT1URFP1OO15303509170
reply from Hellmann's Consumer Services

Thank you for taking the time to leave your feedback! We're very sorry to hear about this - it's not the experience we want anyone to have with our Real Mayonnaise. Please reach out to us at consumer.services@unilever.com and share ref ID: 46253172, so we can ask you some questions. We look forward to hearing back from you!

Nov 19, 2023
Mayo Purist
1 out of 5 stars review

Disappointed Former Fan

Please return to the old recipe!!! I used to love this stuff and could almost eat it out of the jar. This past spring I threw away many partial jars hoping for my tasty Hellmanns. Not to be! I am in South Carolina and my tomato sandwiches, tomato pie, 8 layer salad are all suffering. I am now a former Fan....willing to return with old recipe!!!

Review from hellmanns.com
Helpful?3MHT1URFP1OO15303509170
Oct 14, 2014
GrandmaO
1 out of 5 stars review

What happened /changed ? that great flavor is gone

Something has changed in and it was for the worst. Been using only Hellman's for over 40 years and so had my Mom and my Grandma' s . Even though it would cost a little more no matter what we would go without something else to pay the extra and buy Hellman's, We used nothing else especially for Tuna , egg and potato salad. The flavor that once was , is not there anymore and it's runny once mixed. The flavor seems almost spoiled after a month or so after opening . Not sure what has changed , but please go back no matter the cost and make it and sell it the same way Hellman's used to be or you will be losing many , many customers .

Review from hellmanns.com
Helpful?3MHT1URFP1OO15303509170
Apr 24, 2023
Shirley Ann
1 out of 5 stars review

YOUR REAL MAYONNAISE IS NOW AWFUL!

I have ONLY bought your Real Mayonnaise since I married in 1970. It was my family's favorite! Everyone raved about my food made with your Real Mayonnaise. However, I bought some the other day and it was terrible! It had an aftertaste that was all wrong. It ruined the ham sandwiches I made and today it ruined the egg salad I made. What have you done? I see now that many people have complained about this and you haven't done anything about it. Why? I want my tried and true Real Mayonnaise back! (I live west of the Rockies so it is labelled Best Foods here.) I am going to throw it in the garbage today! Now, do I try another jar of your Real Mayonnaise or a different brand? I see America's Test Kitchen / Cook's Country / Cook's Illustrated recommend Blue Plate Real Mayonnaise as the best mayonnaise over your Real Mayonnaise. I never thought I would have to look for another mayonnaise for my family!

Review from hellmanns.com
Helpful?3MHT1URFP1OO15303509170
Jan 25, 2024
HF73
1 out of 5 stars review

Horrible product

Bioengineered crap! I have used Hellmans for everything for my entire life...not anymore! You have permanently lost my business! The flavor will never be the same again...really sad! No one can trust the crap you put in your products now. I hope more and more people will wake up and realize what bioengineered products really are and stop buying your product.

Review from hellmanns.com
Helpful?3MHT1URFP1OO15303509170
Nov 26, 2023
chuck07860
1 out of 5 stars review

I just can't eat this anymore

Over the last year I noticed that I can no longer eat your mayo. I have opened a number of jars and I just don't like the taste anymore. I used to love mayo and only ever bought hellmanns. Now I am fine with the packets I get at the burger places, but when I use it out of the jar the taste I used to like isn't there anymore. Did something change or did my taste change? Is my body telling me not to eat it anymore? I have not tried another brand yet because I can't afford to throw out food.

Review from hellmanns.com
Helpful?3MHT1URFP1OO15303509170
reply from Hellmann's Consumer Services

Thanks for reaching out. From time to time we may change the formulations of our products. The intent of these changes is to continually improve our products as well as providing the best quality products possible. We are sorry you were disappointed, and we will certainly report your comments to our team.

Oct 14, 2024
Tribble
1 out of 5 stars review

What happened to Hellman's

The recipe has changed and definitely not for the better. Creamy is not good, seems as if more water or something added. This mayonnaise now breaks down much faster and the taste is is more like a vinegar additive of some sort. Do not recommend and will not purchase any more in the future.

Review from hellmanns.com
Helpful?3MHT1URFP1OO15303509170
Apr 29, 2025
izabelao1_3893
5 out of 5 stars review

Numer one 1️⃣

This is my favorite mayonnaise when I don't have time to make my own. It has a perfect creamy consistency. It goes well on its own on sandwiches, toasts, wraps, with meats and salads. It works perfectly as a mix for various sauces. has a very good and tasty composition.

Review from influenster.com
Helpful?3MHT1URFP1OO15303509170
Mar 17, 2024
Ginger24
1 out of 5 stars review

Very sad customer

I am very disappointed in Hellman's. I always used your Mayo. Adding soybeans oil totally ruined my favorite Mayo. I will have to look for a new condiment to replace it.. you should think about going back to your original recipe.. one very sad customer

Review from hellmanns.com
Helpful?3MHT1URFP1OO15303509170
reply from Consumer Support

We truly appreciate you taking the time to share your feedback about our Real Mayonnaise. Our formulation hasn't changed, just the packaging. The intent of these changes is to continually improve our products as well as providing the best quality products possible. We'll make sure to share your comments with our team.

Feb 4, 2015
Miken40
2 out of 5 stars review

Boo

Guys, my family has been using Hellman's Real for generations but lately it seems like you did something different. The mayo lacks that classic flavor that makes everything from sandwiches to my wife's tartar sauce just right. It's thinner, less flavorful. I get it. Every once in a while some food engineer comes along promising "better mouth feel" or more profits by cutting a corner but seriously, you guys were a national treasure and now as your mayo slides unceremoniously off my knife, I wonder if I should start looking for a better alternative. Please stop whatever you're doing and go back to the way you were.

Review from hellmanns.com
Helpful?3MHT1URFP1OO15303509170
reply from Consumer Services

Please feel free to contact Hellmann's at Consumer.Services@Unilever.com or call 800 671-6025 so we may learn more about your experience. Thank you.