I bought this peach pie for Mothers Day and it is horrible!! Nobody liked it!! Had to throw it away!! Has a weird spice that overwhelms the taste of the peach.

My pie was full of chunks of Peaches and I love the crust. I usually buy the apple pie but I decided to give it a try. I had no ice cream so I use whip cream, but tomorrow I am going to get some ice cream.

Delicious

Excellent pie

I was so happy to find a peach pie at SamsClub, but was greatly disappointed when I went to eat a piece. The peaches were crunchy. The pie does not taste like peaches, but more of a lemon taste. I figured the pie might have canned peaches in it, but between the crunchy peaches and the non-peach taste, I was so disappointed almost went back to the store and asked for a refund.

I was born in Mobile, Al and lived in the New Orleans area 30 years. I cook and bake from scratch . I really know good food. I'm known for great cakes. I do not use canned goods This pie is as close to a real peach pie as I have ever purchased commercially. It has fresh peaches that are Al dente “ to the tooth” as they should be . Only canned peaches are soft. They used real sugar snd brown sugar. We have been so use to cutting corners and eating poorly that some people think that's how it should be. When we were young and picked peaches for pies, cobbler or turn overs they were firm. Firm foods are great for our teeth, gums and the fiber is also good for you. The spices are old fashion and on point. The ones we've used since I was a child and well before then. I was reluctant to buy a store made pie. I'm so happy I did and I will be telling everyone I know that knows quality about my experience. Some people think twinkies or cake mixes are baked goods. So if you like fake foods, this may not be for you. If you know what a homemade peach , apple, cherry, blackberry pie should taste like, feel like when it's baked from scratch, then enjoy. My family certainly did. My 84 year old cousin that I take care of loved it too. Reminded him of his childhood as well as mine. Not to sweet, balance of nutmeg and spices. The only thing that missing was homemade churned real vanilla bean ice cream . Too bad some people don't know the real deal . We loved it.

Sorry. This is not the best peach pie I've eaten. 😐 there is too much pumpkin pie spice, especially cinnamon. It overpowers the taste of the peaches. And the crust is nowhere as good as other Sam's club pies. Sam's club, please go back to making your own pies.

Rarely do I leave a review for food, but after this pie I had to. Wish I had read reviews before buying. Peaches are hard and flavorless, crust is gummy, some sort of gelatinous goo holding it together. I'm not picky, especially with desserts. This pie is not good. Do not waste your money.

Bought one today. Had a penny size piece of peach pit in the filling. The crust was very good. Lacked the ripe peach flavor I expected. It is peach season in the Texas Hill Country. Excellent ripe peaches are available. This pie does not have that flavor. For my taste there is too much nutmeg. With more peach flavor the spices might be right.

Worst pie ever! I totally agree with review of Horrible. I jumped for joy at seeing that pie. I love peach pie. My first bite said take a second bite of because no way could it taste as bad as you .think. But it did. I took it back and got my refund.This pie deserves no stars,