It was very good! The crust was fluffy. The syrup- not a great word for it- with the peaches was good. But I think more peace's would push it up to all 5 stars!

It was too lemony tasting . Not that good .

I have never had a peach pie that crunched. The peaches must have been green when picked and just not quite ripe. Flavor was good, crust was okay and I won't get another.

Very sweet, bland peach flavor, crust was soggy.

The crust was thick and very underbaked even though the edges were brown- the crust was nearly raw in the middle! The peaches were a little crunchy and heavily spiced. Wasn't worth eating or trekking back to Sam's to return it, so we threw it away. Wish I had read the reviews first!

The peach pie had a lard tasting crust, The filling was very thick, there was a lack of peaches and lacked peach flavor

I bought this peach pie to try out from Sam's because we love their apple pie. There is no way that I would even consider this "peach" The spices they used in the pie are so overwhelming that it actually made my mouth burn. Tastes like nutmeg. The peaches were hard and almost nonexistent. The only way that I would recommend this pie is if you like hard peaches that you can't even cut with your fork and you love nutmeg, and I mean you really, really love nutmeg.

Wish read reviews before purchasing in store. Pie had a horrible aftertaste and Peaches were extremally hard. Was extremally not edible for my family. We enjoy most deserts Sam's bring to the table. This one is a hard pass. With prices as they are feel bad about purchasing this one and having a not good review. None of us could bring ourselves to eat more then the slices we cut and this was a surprise for my husband who is Southern and loves peach pie since he was remodeling around the house and thought he'd enjoy a treat with how hard he's working. Even for him who can stomach most deserts that we aren't fans of he just couldn't even bare a few bites.

Maybe it's a "regional thing", but here in Texas, we expect Peach Pies to taste like peaches (especially when you live near Fredericksburg). The first thing you taste with this pie is lemon. Then more lemon. The last thing you taste is lemon. The peaches are in the pie but have absolutely NO peach flavor. And to make it worse, the peaches are hard like they haven't been cooked. Maybe I got a bad one, but I won't be buying another to find out.

I was excited to see peach pie. Had my taste buds all set with memories of my grandmother's pie. Big mistake! Couldn't taste peaches for all the strange spices. Crust was soggy. I didn't finish one slice. Three family members and a friend had 1 bite. In the trash it went.