The cookie was and delicious but the icong was too sweet and had too much amaretto.

My 17 yr old said these cookies were soooo good! Will definitely purchase whenever I'm shopping at Sams!

These cookies are amazing! Wish they had a little bit more frosting, but the flavor is excellent. For sure a repeat buy.

found these today while shopping at Sam's I was a little skeptical a first until I got home and tried and was like Sam's is onto something let me tell you went back later that day and bought 3 more boxes S's please don't discontinue these cookies

Wonderful huge cookies. The icing is so flavorful, maybe almond extract? I typically find the icing on Sam's baked goods to be too sweet but these were perfect.

This a good cookie, but not great. The almond flavoring in the frosting can be a bit much on the first bite. The cookie is light yet very crumbly, so I found it messy. It's sweet enough to know your eating a cookie, but not overly sweet.

I loved these. Super sweet and yummy. These are really large cookies, the price is right for these large yummy cookies. I just wish they had red or white to match our Christmas theme.

These sugar cookies are the BOMB! Now that's a sugar cookie! I was suprised how thick they were and how heavy they are! They are huge!! Definitely worth $1.50 per cookie!! If you want to treat yourself or your kids for the holidays or whenever, I highly recommend!!! I will definitely buy them again!

These cookies are amazing. They melt in your mouth and are just sooooo good, I don't have words to explain it. I chatted with Sam's club- they are currently discontinued. "The more request we have, the more probabilities there are for this item to be restocked." Message in ya'll!!!!!

I was anxious to try these but at the first bite I almost threw them out, I think the cookie itself is great but the icing ruins the whole thing, I don't know what flavor that is but they should never use it again. If they chose a different flavor of icing these would be AMAZING. Try again, you ALMOST got it right.