These are an absolute find for an ice cream novelty. The marshmallow flavored ice cream is subtle enough where it is harmonious with the chocolate and graham cracker flavor. I personally enjoy the soft texture of the grahams sandwiching the ice cream, very reminiscent of an ice box cake.

My oldest son and I bought a box of these and devised a plan to eat them surreptitiously, hiding them in an extra freezer from the wife, daughter and the 2 year old. Our code word to venture off and enjoy one of these baddies was, "let's go throw out the trash in the garage". Once the coast was clear and the freezer door opened, those FatBoy S'mores Ice Cream Sandwich Bars awaited us, and, with giddy excitement, my son and I quietly tore into the soft packaging, and exposed these little, texturous dessert bricks. You have to take a second to just appreciate its graham cracker covered surface, its weighty girth and its chocolate shell. The first bite obviously happens at its top corners. The creamy ice cream just melts in your mouth. It's then that you feel like you're at a campfire, roasting marshmallows, only to remember you're a 40 year old hiding in the garage, secretly eating a stash of ice cream with your son. Well, I guess this is how memories are made.

If you don’t plan on eating the whole box then don’t get these lol. These were too good and made it about a week in my house lol

Hope it’s not just seasonal. Tastes great but dark chocolate would be better. Milk chocolate isn’t keeping me from buying them, though.

I had my doubts about these as this brand does come with combos very different from all others - but these are great, and the current price - it makes them greater! All flavors come together well. I'll get them again.

Hey Fat Boy! You've come up with the ultimate summertime treat! We used these at our camp kickoff party, and everyone absolutely loved them! They were a big hit!

We fell in love with these the 1st time we bought them. Then they weren't available at our store. Later they came back in stock... but it seems the couple of boxes we've had since haven't been as good. The cracker layer is too thin and it really makes a big difference in the flavor.

It’s too sweet, tastes nothing like a smore. Better off being a sandwich, it’s always falling off the stick.

These are the most terrible tasting Ice Cream Sandwich suckers I ever tasted in my life. Never again will I buy them.

I love regular Fat Boys but these S'mores had a funky taste that was not pleasant so I through them away. The ice cream did not taste like real Ice cream. It tasted like whipped topping.