This popcorn is the best! It is the perfect amount of crunchy. It’s sweet, it’s salty. I was not sure how I would feel about caramel and cheddar being in the same bag, but it’s amazing! Within the bag the two flavors stay separate pretty well, so it would be easy to place the different flavors on a serving tray while keeping the flavors separate. I am surprised at how much I like to eat these two flavors together!

I have to preface this review with the fact that I was thinking of white cheddar despite the image on the packaging. That being said I was surprised at the intensity of the yellow cheddar flavor. The caramel flavor is deep and rich. The cheese is bright and tangy. I can see this being a favorite among those who enjoy the contrast. It was a bit difficult to get it mixed in the bag (caramel popcorn is heavier than cheddar. But I solved for that by dumping into a large snack storage container.

Garrett Popcorn Garrett Mix is fantastic. While the bag isn't quite as good as fresh from a Garrett's store, it's definitely the next best thing! Great cheesy flavor combined with the sweetness of caramel is so satisfying. My entire family loves it! It's a good thing this comes in a nice big bag so there's enough for everyone.

This popcorn was fresh and the flavors themselves are good, but I am definitely not a fan of having the cheddar and caramel mixed together. I honestly didn’t even realize that was a thing, but I thought it might be something new and interesting to try. It turns out the combo just isn’t for me. I think it’s a solid product when the flavors are sold separately, but not in this particular mix.

When first opened the smell is delicious! Tasting each flavor separately shows a quality product and eating the blend was over the top bursting with flavor. Before opening and eating out of the bag definitely give the bag a good tossing to ensure the flavors are mixed or put in a big bowl and toss to mix. Great for a quick snack.

When in Chicago if you love popcorn you grab Garrett's! I was skeptical if it'd taste as good as what you get fresh in the store... to my surprise it was just as delicious! You have to be extra careful when opening the bag as the cut will travel quickly. We ended up having to transfer to a ziploc bag to maintain freshness but it was gone within less than 2 days either way. I would prefer smaller individual packaging to be able to send with my kiddos but the taste was great! Freshness superb! Will definitely buy in store.

I was very excited to try this. However, my family had mixed reviews. Some of us love the combined sweet-and-savory flavor and couldn't stop eating. While the rest of us prefer just one flavor—either the bold Cheese Corn or the rich Caramel Crisp and feel mixing dilutes their favorite.

I've always loved caramel popcorn, but this Garrett Mix far surpassed any other popcorn I'd tried. My kids, who don't like many things, loved these too. They simply took the whole bag to their room and almost finished it, haha. The cheese ones also have a very subtle but delicious flavor. I recommend them for a snack any time of day.

Not a big fan of this popcorn. There is going to be a personal preference aspect of this review...the caramel is TOO salty, it almost tastes burnt. The cheddar is okay, but not overwhelmingly good In the end, this is just a mid level popcorn for me. I would not buy it.

The authentic buttery flavor instantly transports you to a theater seat. The rich, artificial butter and sweet caramel flavors are the perfect combination, creating a savory aroma that's irresistible. Each piece offers a crispy crunch that holds up well, making for a satisfying texture. This popcorn is all about indulgence and nostalgia. While it might not be an everyday snack, it's the excellent choice for a special movie night at home when you crave that classic, buttery-rich popcorn with sweet caramel flavors.