Sam's has a different brand that was awesome. These cost a dollar more and not as good. Disappointed.

Not as much flavor as the cretors brand. It's not bad but it's definitely lacking if you've tried the other. I see that it's available for shipping but I hope they bring back the cretors in store.

The Carmel Corn is the absolute best, I bought several bags last year. I was very disappointed to see that they are only carrying Garrett Mix this season. Not good news for those of us who don't like cheese!

Tasted terrible, threw it all out. Poor puck on Sam's part. I get they want to save money to be competitive but Sam's this isn't the way to do it. Bring back the other brand👍

way worse than cretors, more 'spicy', less flavorful, less airy, more hard pieces, less edible 'food' overall. i was buying cretors every week. bought this one time months ago, never did again

Horrible, Cretor’s is 100% better than this junk. It’s 90% cheddar and 10% caramel. The kernels are much smaller and the bag I bought at the Springdale, AR store on 7/11/25 was extremely stale. Speaking of that store, it was upside down. A train wreck of stuff scattered all over the place. The signs said they were remodeling so I’m sure that was the issue but it wasn’t even organized madness. Only 3 checkout in service as well.

The bad - only 1 thing; the bag is actually full (not like potato chips) and it says to mix well, and sadly you can't do that in the bag. I had to pour it out and mix it, then put it back in the bag. I'm not a huge popcorn fan, but this stuff is really good just enough cheese, salt and caramel corn to make it tasty. Bonus, I didn't see one unpopped kernal, I did get a few partially popped ones but no trash. Good stuff.

I've grown up with Garrett Popcorn, going to their shops in Chicago and having Garrett at family events. My family is so glad we can get Garrett in grocery stores and now Sam's. Garrett Mix is my favorite and this was so delicious! We've tried other brands, but nothing else compares.

I've been a fan of Garrett Popcorn Shops Garrett Mix for almost 25 years, and it's great that Sam's Club is bringing a little bit of Chicago to everyone. The salty and sweet combo of caramel and cheddar popcorn is absolutely delicious. The bag is huge and a fantastic deal. I highly recommend it!

My daughter-in-law recently was on a business/convention trip to Chicago and purchased a bag of Garrett's mix which I thoroughly enjoyed. When I was attending Moody Bible Institute during the late 1950s, I worked 20 hours each week at Garret's Popcorn shop. My favorite was the caramel corn. Often, I was allowed to take some of the day-old (free or at a great discount) which I took back to Moody and gave to my close friends. They all loved it. Both Mr. and Mrs. Garrett both worked at the shop. All the employees were Moody students (male) and we all had to wear a white shirt with a necktie. Mrs. Garrett often came close to each of us and made sure we always had deodorant on. Prior to owning the shop, Mr. Garrett was a WWII pilot, and Mrs. Garrett was a "model" for a clothing company.