Sam's Club bakery nailed it! It was big enough to generously serve 26 people, with room to spare. Looked amazing, and tasted super fresh. I only used Mario on the cake. I had a little "Mario Kart" moment in the car on the way home and smudged it slightly (100% my fault!), but it still held up great and the kids absolutely loved it. Unbeatable value and quality!

Delicious cake! We ordered cake two times from Sam’s Club, and both times the cakes were amazing. They were fresh, soft, and delicious, with beautiful designs. Everyone loved them. We will definitely order again. Highly recommended!

Message will fit. It is screen printed, which was fine. I was worried it would not fit. Cars & flag arrive separate from the cake so you can put them on when you are ready to present. Looks just as pictured and was delicious!

The cake was so flavorful!

The cake was delicious and very attractive. The only negative was, I ordered chocolate and got vanilla. It was still a hit at the birthday party.

Everyone liked the taste and complemented it, it was good texture not mushy yet moist. However it didn’t have the sprinkles and didn’t have the image with the text I requested. Looked cute and with the candles and the decor it looked good enough but was expecting that little detail as advertised. Anything that the store doesn’t have or will remove from the original design should be informed to the customer beforehand. I had a cake delivery from Baskin Robbin’s the same week and they called me to confirm the order details, so not asking for much. Overall takeaway: have better service and communication for custom orders, but at least it was good tasting cake.

Very pleased with the size of the cake. Rated 3 stars because the vanilla cake we ordered had notes of lemon flavor. This isn’t the first time the vanilla flavor here has tasted this way.

This cake was delicious. The Club however…I’m less than happy with! They called me the morning of my pick up to tell me they didn’t have the decorations for the cake! So the cake that my granddaughter picked out herself and was so looking forward to, was not going to be. :( I had to search for some toys to put on top…that were similar…thankfully I found some but it cost me $15 and stress like you can’t imagine…then running out the day of the birthday to go get them and decorating the cake with them best I could! I was in disbelief! All bcuz someone didn’t bother to check their supplies ahead of time ! I’ve never been so upset with a club! (Madison Hgts)

Normally this is the best cake ever. However it was disappointingly dry. Please do better.

We ordered this cake which has our grandsons favorite characters, Super Mario. But when we picked it up it had totally different characters that he wasn’t familiar with. I was told they ran out of Super Mario and the baker should have called us to see what we wanted to substitute on the cake. No one called us. My grandson was disappointed. But the cake was large and delicious and a good buy for the cost.