We got a Mario cookie cake for a birthday. It was super easy to order online and pick-up. The cake was 2 layers of cookies with icing in the middle, so a small piece was filling. It was decorated exactly as it was ordered and tasted good. This will be our go to for a cookie cake in the future.

Cute cookie cake, tasted pretty good, love the frosting filling. It was a hit for the party and good amount.

5 Star review based on the cake itself. The Club Bakery experience would have been only 2 stars. This was my first experience with a Sam's Club Bakery Order. I had no idea I've been missing out on this cookie cake 'sandwich'. There's a thin layer of icing between two cookie layers and boy, its delicious and a game changer. I'm also not a huge fan of buttercream icing from stores but this one is light and not overly sugary--Overall delicious cake and would HIGHLY recommend anyone who is considering it. 5 Starts for the cake. As for the service--I would footnote that my particular store location could improve their customer service a bit. I had a pick-up window between 1-2 PM, arrived at the bakery at 1:01 PM and the employee at the counter acted rudely and was giving me a lot of attitude. She assumed I was trying to pick up my order earlier than my timeslot (which I wasnt), but this whole ordeal seemed excessive considering the cake was done, decorated, and sitting on shelf awaiting pick-up...so where the attitude was need??? not sure. So rating for bakery personnel, 2 stars.

The cookie cake I received looks nothing like this image. Mine, which was for my son's birthday, appears as if the screen printer ran out of ink. Instead of fixing it, the weird, discolored image was placed on the cake and sold to me. His birthday cake is ruined with no time for a new one. Thanks, Sam's.