Super Mario Half Sheet Cookie Cake

|10 ratings
Item # 984235532
Current price is $19.98
Prices may vary in club and online
How do you want your item?

Bakery, in club pickup

Next-day pickup if ordered by 2 PM. Cakes can be ordered up to 30 days in advance and picked up in the Bakery area within the club.
Columbus, Hilliard Sam's Club
Return or replace anytime.
SNAP EBT eligible
Sam's credit card
Get a $30 statement credit when you open an account and use it to make $30 in eligible Sam's Club purchases within 30 days¹.

Highlights

  • Made fresh in-club
  • Double-layered half sheet cookie cake
  • Great for birthdays, themed parties and celebrations
  • Serves ~36-48 people
Super Mario Half Sheet Cookie Cake
Super Mario Half Sheet Cookie Cake
Hero image 0 of Super Mario Half Sheet Cookie Cake, 0 of 1

About this item

Product details

Get ready to enjoy this delightful Super Mario themed Half Sheet Cookie Cake—a scrumptious sensation that perfectly combines the fun of cookies with the charm of a cake. Designed to serve ~36-48 guests, this cookie cake transforms ordinary moments into extraordinary adventures, making it an essential addition to any event. Order now and relish the fusion of cookie magic and cake charm at your next gathering!

Captivate Your Taste Buds

This Super Mario Half Sheet Cookie Cake is a harmonious blend of two cherished treats—cookies and cake. The result? A tantalizing treasure that merges the chewiness of cookies with the lushness of cake. Each slice promises an unforgettable experience that captivates taste buds and hearts alike, transporting you into an enchanting video game world.

Skillfully Designed

Enhance the appeal of this Cookie Cake with skillfully designed icing decorations inspired by this iconic video game character. Each detail is precisely shaped and decorated, creating a spectacular display that radiates playful charm.

Ultimate Crowd Pleaser

Whether it's a kid's birthday, playdate or any special event, the Super Mario Half Sheet Cookie Cake is the ultimate crowd-pleaser. With each slice, guests are treated to a symphony of textures and flavors that evoke a sense of nostalgia and amusement. Jump into the delicious world of Super Mario and make memories at your next event with our Cookie Cake.


Member’s Mark Made Without Commitment™

This item meets our Member’s Mark Made Without Commitment™: Our Member’s Mark Made Without Commitment makes it easier to know what is not in our products, so members can feel better about what is. We simplify the choice for our members by setting a high brand standard for the products they bring into their homes. This isn’t list a list of ingredients, it’s our commitment to simpler ingredients that reflect our members' values. And we deliver this without compromising taste, performance, or value. This means that this item doesn’t contain the 40+ ingredients on our Made Without Commitment list like High Fructose Corn Syrup, Phthalates, Talc, Certified Synthetic Colors/ FD&C Colors, and Formaldehyde. See the full list of ingredients here: https://www.samsclub.com/cp/members-mark-goals/30001929. 

info:
If the item details above aren't accurate or complete, we want to know about it. 

Specifications

Cake & cupcake orders can be picked up in the Bakery area within the club.

Warnings and disclaimers

Disclaimer

WARNING: CHOKING HAZARD – Small parts. Not for children under 3 years

CAUTION: Gum paste is not edible due to hard, brittle texture and/or wires in some products, but is safe for food contact. DO NOT EAT.

Member ratings & reviews

4.5 out of 5 stars
stars
10 ratings4 reviews
Write a review
  1. 5 stars80% (8)
  2. 4 stars10% (1)
  3. 3 stars0% (0)
  4. 2 stars0% (0)
  5. 1 star10% (1)
Filtered and sorted results would be available on the new 'Customer ratings & reviews' page.
Sort by |

Showing 1-3 of 4 reviews

Jul 16, 2025
Reviewer name: Lynn
5 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Mario cookie cake

Cute cookie cake, tasted pretty good, love the frosting filling. It was a hit for the party and good amount.

Helpful?4CPIMTBCKCDI15232154155
May 29, 2026
Reviewer name: anonymous
5 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 stars review

Great Cookie Cake

We got a Mario cookie cake for a birthday. It was super easy to order online and pick-up. The cake was 2 layers of cookies with icing in the middle, so a small piece was filling. It was decorated exactly as it was ordered and tasted good. This will be our go to for a cookie cake in the future.

Helpful?4CPIMTBCKCDI15232154155
Jul 28, 2025
Reviewer name: Shannon
5 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 stars review

AMAZING Cookie Cake (regardless of sassy employee)

5 Star review based on the cake itself. The Club Bakery experience would have been only 2 stars. This was my first experience with a Sam's Club Bakery Order. I had no idea I've been missing out on this cookie cake 'sandwich'. There's a thin layer of icing between two cookie layers and boy, its delicious and a game changer. I'm also not a huge fan of buttercream icing from stores but this one is light and not overly sugary--Overall delicious cake and would HIGHLY recommend anyone who is considering it. 5 Starts for the cake. As for the service--I would footnote that my particular store location could improve their customer service a bit. I had a pick-up window between 1-2 PM, arrived at the bakery at 1:01 PM and the employee at the counter acted rudely and was giving me a lot of attitude. She assumed I was trying to pick up my order earlier than my timeslot (which I wasnt), but this whole ordeal seemed excessive considering the cake was done, decorated, and sitting on shelf awaiting pick-up...so where the attitude was need??? not sure. So rating for bakery personnel, 2 stars.

Helpful?4CPIMTBCKCDI15232154155

Related pages