Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Customer reviews for Bay Valley Nacho Cheese Sauce, 106 oz. for
Bay Valley Nacho Cheese Sauce, 106 oz.
4.2 out of 5 stars
stars1,574 ratings448 reviews
  1. 5 stars71% (1,114)
  2. 4 stars9% (140)
  3. 3 stars5% (76)
  4. 2 stars2% (36)
  5. 1 star13% (208)

Member photos

  • +8 images
Sort by |
Showing 341-350 of 448 reviews
Apr 18, 2023
Tami
1 out of 5 stars review

Disappointing

I was hesitant about buying this brand because I was unfamiliar with it. However, it was all they had. I didn't care for the taste and I didn't detect any 'nacho' flavor. I also thought it was rather thick and the color was too orange. We used it for our nacho station at a birthday party and no one came back for seconds, which never happens because nachos are typically a crowd pleaser. I was in a time crunch and didn't taste it first. I wish I had because it needed some help, like milk and spices. I usually don't have to add anything to the other cheese sauce brands we normally purchase for events. Needless to say, over half of it was leftover.

Helpful?4ND17NNHMAE815007454528
Jul 27, 2020
Anonymous
1 out of 5 stars review

They change the recipe/manufacture It tastes awful

They have changed the recipe/manufacture and it tastes awful. Bring back the original version. For years I have been buying this nacho cheese and it was amazing! They recently have changed the recipe or manufacturer and it is disgusting. At first I thought I bought a bad batch so i went back to the store that same night and bought another one because we were having nachos that evening, opened it up and it was the same disgusting color and taste. So I looked further into it and found out they changed it to a new recipe/manufacture. Those of you that think this new version is good clearly have not had the pleasure of tasting the older version. It was wonderful. I am very disappointed! It was my party go to item and i always had one on hand. Please bring back the old version.

Review from walmart.com
Helpful?4ND17NNHMAE815007454528
Apr 16, 2018
Yennie83
5 out of 5 stars review

This has not changed!

Reading the reviews we were very scared as to we have used the Daily Chef Nacho Cheese for the last two years in our concession at a annual Truck Show that has brought us many rave reviews! We started looking elsewhere and were very disappointed in what we found. So on 4-21-2018 we talked with a lady in the store and she said "she hasn't noticed a difference and used it all basketball season" with no complaints. Well we purchased a can to do a test menu and, IT IS THE SAME AS LAST TWO YEARS! Such a load off our backs! So we will be purchasing this for our event in the next two weeks!!! So glad we tried it for ourselves!!!!!!!

Helpful?4ND17NNHMAE815007454528
Jun 30, 2020
MrD
1 out of 5 stars review

Don’t buy

I have always brought my nacho cheese from Sams club then it change name or label don’t know but it tasted different. Which it was ok, but just then I just brought a can that is horrible is like you are eating chemicals it has a nasty taste I didn’t give it to my family I don’t think this is save to eat don’t buy! I didn’t see the reviews until now and I do understand where people are coming from. Really don’t buy !! Too bad i can not give them no stars !!

Helpful?4ND17NNHMAE815007454528
Jul 18, 2020
review
1 out of 5 stars review

tastes like perfume

I have bought this before and it was good. I purchased it for the 4th of July for our small gathering and was so embarrassed! It tasted like someone put perfume or chemicals in it!! I read other reviews and now am concerned for people’s safety! DISGUSTING!!!!!!!!!! Members mark should be ashamed.

Helpful?4ND17NNHMAE815007454528
Apr 17, 2019
HIGINIA
1 out of 5 stars review

Metallic taste

This cheese used to be great and our customers loved it. We began our season 4 weeks ago and it is now tasting like metal therefore is gross. It seems like the protection between can and cheese is no longer protecting the cheese. Please fix this a.s.a.p.

Helpful?4ND17NNHMAE815007454528
Aug 9, 2021
Hillbilly Shack Delights
1 out of 5 stars review

NASTY!!! NASTY!! NASTY!!!

The previous Member's Mark cheese was way better than this nasty stuff. It has absolutely no flavor and has a weird Sheen to it. Looks like plastic! Thought I'd try one can to see what it was like after Sam's discontinued the Member's Mark brand. Don't waste your money!! Not to mention it's a dollar more a can than the previous better cheese. Bad move by Sam's. Just order the Gold Medal nacho cheese sauce online, the cans will be beat up but it tastes much better!! Just put some jalapeno juice in it and chop up some jalapenos. Makes it super tasty!!

Helpful?4ND17NNHMAE815007454528
Aug 2, 2021
lelu221
1 out of 5 stars review

Yuck.

Compared to the Members Mark brand nacho cheese.. this is disgusting. Do NOT buy at any cost. It does not hold well (in heat) and will separate as soon as it is hot. It needs constant stirring because the solid and liquid parts of the "cheese" separate. It is NOT good tasting. Ugh. Such a disappointment. Will NEVER buy again.

Helpful?4ND17NNHMAE815007454528
Mar 14, 2023
That LA Girl
1 out of 5 stars review

Terrible flavor, consistency, & color!

We always have nacho cheese sauce at parties and gatherings and always end up with an empty crock pot. Purchased this as my two preferred big box stores did not have their usual brands in stock. The color is an artificial almost neon orange. It was also so thick I had to add milk to get my usual velvety consistency. The flavor was lacking, tasted artificial and although a large party, had most of it left over. Do yourself a favor a purchase another brand. Yuck! What a waste of money and presentation at a party!

Helpful?4ND17NNHMAE815007454528
Dec 31, 2018
Enn1232
5 out of 5 stars review

Ignore the bad reviews!

I was almost discouraged from buying this nacho cheese because of the reviews, but I decided to test the product for myself. It was delicious! My family loved the cheese, and we quickly ran out. I am planning to now stock my pantry for future parties.

Helpful?4ND17NNHMAE815007454528