Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
All Departments
All Services
Customer reviews for Goodnites Nighttime Bedwetting Underwear for Girls, Sizes Extra Small - Extra Extra Large for
Goodnites Nighttime Bedwetting Underwear for Girls, Sizes Extra Small - Extra Extra Large
4.7 out of 5 stars
stars
1,815 ratings1,182 reviews
  1. 5 stars83% (1,498)
  2. 4 stars11% (195)
  3. 3 stars3% (54)
  4. 2 stars1% (23)
  5. 1 star2% (45)

Member photos

  • +362 images
Sort by |
Showing 161-170 of 1,182 reviews
Oct 6, 2019
Reviewer name: NoLongerAFan
2 out of 5 stars
2 out of 5 stars review

What happened to the sides?!?!?!

Just bought a new pack of GoodNites and was horrified to find that the stretchy sides are now...not stretchy at all. Child had a terrible time trying to put them on, after many tears and tantrums, three discarded pants later we were able to (very carefully) pull them on. Why the change? It is very difficult to encourage Independence when putting the things on becomes a team job. Very disappointed in this product that used to be the favorite. I suppose it's time to try other brands.

Review from goodnites.com
Helpful?5WMNFVX6RF9L14990968798
reply from Huggies® Brand

We truly value your opinion and are sad to see your disappointment with the new updates. Please know that in response to the increasing demand for this product, we are temporarily manufacturing the pants and some materials at different manufacturing facilities, which can lead to slight product variations. We are sorry if your experience with the product was unsatisfactory and apologize for any inconvenience. Please be assured that we will share your comments with those involved in order to make your experience better in the future. Please contact us at 1-800-810-8075 (weekdays, 8AM-5PM CT) or online at http://bit.ly/2cVqZxt so that we can understand more about your situation and how we can help. Thank you.

Sep 8, 2013
Reviewer name: marshal74
5 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 stars review

Great For Boys

Well my son does likes the girls goodnites because he says its more comfortable and they do not leak unlike the boys they leak and they are uncomfortable and he does not like to wear them. But please change the desings because he says the Tinkerbell desing makes him feel like a princess.

Review from goodnites.com
Helpful?5WMNFVX6RF9L14990968798
Jan 14, 2015
Reviewer name: momofincontinentteen
4 out of 5 stars
4 out of 5 stars review

Make a bigger size!!! Please! BIGGER THAN XL.

I am a constant buyer of the girls Goodnite diapers. I was very happy to see that the sides were advertised as being stretchier- and that they were! I was able to compare because I still had the old style at home. HOWEVER!! They are still very tight. There really needs to be a bigger size. If you didn't realize, girls have much wider hips! Even in the diapers target age, a 12 year old girls hips and thighs are larger, and it makes the diaper VERY uncomfortable, and appear un fitting. they also do not RISE as high as they should. there has to be midnight changes. So I do not use Goodnites for night time at all! Which is what this product is supposed to be for! They are used for day time only, and cloth diapers at night. Part of why goodnites and similar products are so popular is because kids and teens can retain their dignity. You often refer parents of larger/older children to depends. THIS ISNT HELPFUL!!! Here is why: Depends diapers, even the "pullup underwear" style, is very ugly and unappealing to tweens and teens. They do not want to wear them! They are often TOO BIG, or TOO CLUNKY and do NOT fit under their clothes. Transitioning a tween to Depends diapers IS NOT HELPFUL for their self esteem! This is why parents like to buy Goodnites, I understand your goal for Goodnites is to look and feel like underwear. You have accomplished that. I have no doubt you would be able to make a larger size that still retain these same qualities. WHAT YOU NEED TO REALIZE ABOUT GOODNITES: They are indeed DIAPERS. They are for absorbing urine and holding feces. Please make sure that when you make a larger size, that they hold a larger amount of bodily waste as well. NOTHING is more embarrassing than waking up to a wet diaper, and then a wet bed, sheet, or disposable pad. for years, parents have asked for larger sizes. you've made the sizes stretch, now PLEASE MAKE A BIGGER SIZE!! With a greater area of absorbent material, that rise higher, and that can stretch around wider hips and thighs! you could even CHARGE more, at this point, im sure other parents would pay an extra 3-5 dollars a pack if it meant OUR LARGER TWEENS AND TEENS can feel SECURITY OF THE MIND AND BODY. Your clientele of special needs parents need you! Your clientele of typical children and teens who bed wet need you! Your clientele of parents who want to make bedwetting easier on our children, tweens, teens need you! Just because a child, tween or teen is bigger, doesnt mean they need to be cheated out of a product that can help them fell SAFE AND SECURE while retaining their DIGNITY. Goodnites! Lead the way in larger sizes! PLEASE REPLY!!! TAKE ACTION!!

Review from goodnites.com
Helpful?5WMNFVX6RF9L14990968798
reply from GoodNites Brand Team

We greatly appreciate your feedback and have shared it with the rest of our team. If you have further suggestions or need assistance, please contact our Consumer Care team directly at http://bit.ly/RjQ2YH. Thank you for being a GoodNites family!

May 14, 2014
Reviewer name: Anon
3 out of 5 stars
3 out of 5 stars review

Good but recently bad.

I've been impressed with this product thus far for my daughter. Recently however I've noticed a dip in quality. The large size seems to have gotten smaller and when my daughter wakes in the morning they are always ripped along the same area, the right side where the absorbent middle part meets the side. On top of this problem recently she has had a hard time getting them on due to the sides ripping easier. I did some testing by buying an older pack at the store and they were perfectly fine. While I recommend this product for people with smaller kids, this product does not seem to be suited for the higher end of it's claimed age range.

Review from goodnites.com
Helpful?5WMNFVX6RF9L14990968798
Oct 17, 2013
Reviewer name: sb630
5 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 stars review

Life savers...

My 10 year old is Autistic, and unfortunately, is still not potty trained at all. We use Goodnights as her protection day AND night, and they really are life savers. They aren't bulky, so she can wear them under her clothes to school without being able to see them, and at night, we never have a problem with leaking or soaking through. They are certainly the best value for the performance, and we never buy anything else.

Review from goodnites.com
Helpful?5WMNFVX6RF9L14990968798
Jun 20, 2014
Reviewer name: Mom42
5 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 stars review

LARGER SIZES PLEASE

My daughter is only 10 and the L/XL size is getting so tight on her we've had to get some extra bedding because she's leaking out of the largest size pull-up. Sadly, this recently happened at an overnight at a friend's house and my daughter came home crying asking me to get a larger size. It was heartbreaking telling her she's in the largest size. PLEASE MAKE A LARGER SIZE! We've got a few more years of bedwetting ahead of us and we want to stay with this product!

Review from goodnites.com
Helpful?5WMNFVX6RF9L14990968798
Nov 1, 2012
Reviewer name: grandma49
5 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 stars review

girls underwear

We do a lot of traveling and take our 3 year old grandchild with us. These were great for night time in a Hotel at night.I also love them for the car.And she loved them the color,and hoe easy they were to pull up And to pull down.We are now done with potty training but these sure made it a lot easier to do .

Review from goodnites.com
Helpful?5WMNFVX6RF9L14990968798
Feb 24, 2015
Reviewer name: TurbosRfun
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

More requests for larger sizes

First I would like to say that my family has given up on goodnites but i think your company should heed the advice in the review by"momofincontinentteen" as there are a great many people who could benefit from larger sizes! Personally there are 8 children in my family who could benefit from larger sizes. Also recommending depends Real-Fit or "Silhouette" doesnt help because they are far too large and quite frankly the goodnites are more absorbent. Recommending the bed mats is also unhelpful because with them you still wind up with wet sheets and pajamas thus negating their purpose and recommending the tru-fit is unhelpful as well because even though they are a great idea, they are even smaller than the goodnites. If anyone intends to respond answer me this one Question, what was wrong with the goodnites from 1994 to 2002-2003 they were quite large and what I wore as a teenage bedwetter so why dont todays children deserve the same quality and size? Also to those of you others who request larger sizes dont give a 5 star review and expect anyone who can fix this to notice... just FYI! Sorry

Review from goodnites.com
Helpful?5WMNFVX6RF9L14990968798
reply from Goodnites Brand Team

Hello TurbosRFun - We are disappointed to hear that you have given up on GoodNites. It is great to hear that they have worked well for you in the past, but sorry to hear about your more recent experiences. We are always looking for ways to improve our products and do appreciate your feedback. We will be sure to share this with the rest of the team, but always want the parents that purchase our products to be happy they did. Our Consumer Care Team would be happy to discuss your concerns further and see how we can help make this right. Please take a moment to contact them at http://bit.ly/1nJPHLZ. Thank you.

Jul 24, 2019
Reviewer name: Dad29
2 out of 5 stars
2 out of 5 stars review

Side panels have changed for the worse

Got two new packs with the new designs of the girls l/xl and boys l/xl... there is something wrong with the side panels both the girl and boy ones split on the right side going up they feel significantly smaller than before and we've never had a problem with past purchases...please fix we love the new desgins though

Review from goodnites.com
Helpful?5WMNFVX6RF9L14990968798
reply from Goodnites Brand

Thanks for your review, and for bringing this to our attention. We understand the importance of bedtime pants that hold up for your children's needs, and this is certainly unexpected. Could you please hang onto the product and packaging and reach out to us directly? You can contact us online at https://www.goodnites.com/en-us/contact-us or by phone at 877-601-6483 (weekdays, 8am-5pm CST). Thank you!

Jun 3, 2014
Reviewer name: PullUpDaughter
4 out of 5 stars
4 out of 5 stars review

Looking for larger size and different designs

Our family is quite happy with this product, but as our daughter is an early teen with an occasional wetting issue still we could use a slightly larger version. Maybe there should be three sizes? Maybe the new stretch sides that are coming out will help. Also, she loves the Tinkerbell design of the S/M. Please don't write off tweens and early teens with those designs and run some of those as well in XL.

Review from goodnites.com
Helpful?5WMNFVX6RF9L14990968798