I bought this because I thought it was Sam's version of Blue Mountain. My dogs love it, however, I noticed my dogs eyes started tearing again. I have a Bichon and they are known for tears but with Blue Mountain, she doesn't get tear stains. I truly believe it's all in what she eats. Quality food is the key

Pretty sure both dogs had a reaction. Neither of them wanted to eat it. Never was able to fully phase it in. A bull and pug mix female... and a 3-4 breed mutt male... neither liked it. Male ended up with hots spots within 3-4 days of eating it. Female ended up sick and refusing to eat within second day. Just was not well received by my 2 dogs.

My 2 Dogs stayed sick with diarrhea after starting this brand. We gave it time for their tummies to adjust to new food and had even purchased another bag but the diarrhea never ended and they were acting lethargic so we trashed it and went back to Blue Buffalo brand.

So pleased with this product. Bought when $5 off and wish I'd bought 3 instead of 1. My golden retriever mix and pointer/hound mix love this and seem to each have more energy (and smaller poops, too). I've been told the smaller the "end" product, the better absorption to the system. If that is the case, then this is the product for your fur baby. Will definitely be buying more of this. (Do wish it was a bit larger size kibble for my boys.)

My dogs like Exceed salmon & pea better, but it's not available. This was my second choice. They are doing well with it. They didn't have time to adjust to a new food, but fared well. It's small enough for my chihuahua's. I will get this again if I can't get my first choice.

My parents had a chow mix and after they died she became my dog. She was constantly having rashes and ear infections so I thought she may have allergies to her food. I switched her to this dog food and just recently brought her to the vet and they said she is the healthiest they have ever seen her. She is 8 years old and hasn't had a rash or ear infection since being on this food. So happy I changed her food to the Member's Mark dog food.

I bought this dog food about a month ago and my rescue dog loves it. I checked the ingredients before purchasing it and I think it is a good product overall. There are 2 things that would make it even better. 1) Remove the pea products from it and replace with a more nutritious carbohydrate, and 2) Add probiotics for digestive and intestinal health.

Have been buying this food for almost two years! I buy a bag every month I purchased a bag and one dog started vomiting and the other dog had diarrhea!! I noticed a lot of cat food mixed with it I switched to the salmon version had no problems bought another bag of chicken and vegetables everything was good then needed another bag same thing made them sick again!!! I am done feeding them bland diet and slowly introducing a new food.

This is the first time I purchased this dog food and am very pleased with it. The shipping was not perfect. There was a slit across the entire bag and much of it was in the outer packaging. This made the zip lock useless. However, I would purchase this again - the dogs like it

We use this product for both our Weimaraner and golden doodle. We have struggled endlessly with finding a dog food for our Weimaraners extremely sensitive stomach. This has been the trick for over a year now. So glad we can finally stop spending a huge chunk of money on expensive and ineffective dog foods.