Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Member ratings & reviews for
Coffee-mate Italian Sweet Creme Liquid Coffee Creamer (64 fl. oz.)

Member photos

  • +220 images
Sort by |
Showing 241-250 of 2,932 reviews
Sep 22, 2023
micveg82
1 out of 5 stars review

New Label is Gross

Purchased several bottles with the new label and they are disgusting. I've been using this creamer for a decade and even stuck with it after the sour-taste debacle of 2020. But this is not good and I would rather pay for Starbucks than use this creamer anymore.

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
Oct 4, 2023
Hall
1 out of 5 stars review

Italian Sweet Cream Flavor Change

I am greatly disappointed in the unannounced flavor change of the Italian Sweet Cream creamer. This was the only creamer, Coffeemate or other brand, that my husband and I use. I am at a loss as to what to use now. I reached out via chat, and they were very helpful. Unfortunately, the flavor profile has been permanently changed.

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
Apr 11, 2021
ShyannAngel
1 out of 5 stars review

Tastes sour??

I just bought this and it definitely tastes likes it sour? Is this supposed to be the flavor? I've never had it so thankfully I only bought the small one but will not be using because I don't want to get sick of this isn't supposed to taste like this.....

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
Apr 16, 2024
dmc5560
5 out of 5 stars review

Love this flavor and I will buy it again.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I received a coupon for a free bottle of Coffee Mate Italian Sweet Cream Liquid Coffee Creamer in exchange for my honest review. I love the taste of this creamer in my morning cup of coffee. I will continue to purchase this Italian Sweet Cream Liquid Coffee Creamer because it it is so good.

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
Oct 17, 2023
Italian Sweet Cremes Ex
1 out of 5 stars review

You've changed. SUCRALOSE? Won't buy again

If I could give zero stars I would. Like others, I used to LOVE this creamer. It's undrinkable to me now. For everyone saying it has a bad aftertaste, there is **SUCRALOSE** in it. I only found out because I wasn't expecting it in a non-sugar-free product, but I got a headache after drinking it and looked at the label.

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
Oct 22, 2023
RFJR3371
1 out of 5 stars review

HORRIBLE Reformulation. Bad taste and even worse

This reformulation is absolutely disgusting. I would rather drink the water out of a sink of dirty dishes before I ever drink this again. Stop trying to improve something that was perfect! Until you change is back, you will be selling 7 less units per week from my immediate family. If it would be possible to give this product negative stars, I definately would have!

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
Jan 8, 2021
Salie
1 out of 5 stars review

It is not the same--June 10, 2021 expiration date

I had bought 3 bottles of your Italian Sweet Cream since it's been my favorite. You can say nothing was changed, but all 3 bottles went down the drain! Bad flavor and even a wrong smell. Too bad-- I'm looking for a different brand now. Don't buy June 10, 2021 exp date Italian Sweet Cream. Thanks for your time

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
Oct 30, 2023
Meags0211
1 out of 5 stars review

No No No

My husband and I have been using this creamer for years....it is the only creamer that I like. I drink a ton of coffee and just bought 2 big jugs....that are now wasted. Why on earth did you have to change it? the "new formula" has a horrible taste. Please go back to the old way, this is ridiculous. All the negative comments on here.....something should be done. A ton of sales are going to be lost on your part. Super dissatisfied.

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
Nov 8, 2023
KatV
1 out of 5 stars review

Bad formula change

The formula of this product was changed without notice or obvious labelling on the bottle. I compared a new bottle to an old bottle and the ingredients listed are slightly different (vegetable oil changed to soybean oil, milk changed to milk derivative). The worst part is that the new formula tastes awful and completely different from the old one! It made my coffee taste like some sort of knockoff hard candy from another country. I've been using this creamer for many years but I will have to try and find a new one due to this change.

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
Mar 14, 2024
Kazykat7
1 out of 5 stars review

Will not be buying it again

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My whole family has been buying your creamer for years but this one did not make it twice does not pass the flavor test in our house so will not be buying it again we will be buying the original creamer

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
reply from goodnespwr

We'd like to make this up to you. Expect an email from us.