The negative reviews are spot on. I should have paid more attention to them but, thought the many 4&5 stars outweighed the negatives. I purchased it knowing it was rum, not the bourbon based like Evan Williams brand. I thought it would be good to have on hand for the holidays. It has no taste - no rum, no vanilla, no nutmeg, nothing. Just a disgusting cream gunk. I tried adding water, then tried adding rum. Neither helped. I don’t think it would even work in a bread pudding mixture in an attempt to redeem the waste of money. I would pass on this even if they were giving it away for free. I’ve tried to provide a photo but, it keeps saying an error has occurred. :-( I just wish I could return it and get a refund.

I’m generally very happy with Sam’s Club but for this product it’s supposed to be refrigerated at all times I’m sure because the bottle says he refrigerated and not refrigerate after opening. It’s kept on the shelf and it had lumps in it. I returned it.

Off the shelf when you first open it and pour a glass, it is SUPER thick. Then once you refrigerate it it glugs out like thick pudding. Horrible texture!! Would not buy ever again! I thought I just had a bad bottle, but it appears others have had the exact same experience.

Whoever wrote the blurb about this egg not that said there was a "subtle rum flavor" either never tried it or uses a heavy pour when making themselves a cocktail. It's good, but everyone in the house agreed it's very strong. We bought two bottles, so I might add some plain old eggnog to it to make it easier to enjoy. Just don't blow out any candles after having some or you might end up with a small fire.

A delicious full bodied nog with authentic flavors, medium alcohol strength, keeps well through the holidays when refrigerated. We add touch more cinnamon and nutmeg as we like, but serve as is with confidence of guest satisfaction. Never disappointed.

Disappointed in the taste. Won't purchase again.

Tastes great by itself or with a little brandy or Irish whiskey added.

Killer taste! Strong taste, thick! I added milk

Taste lack eggnog flavor, and had harsh finish

Not very good. I usually love Members Mark products, but not this time.