Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Customer reviews for Stearns & Foster Estate Tight Top Mattress Set (Available in Soft, Firm, and Ultra Firm) for
Stearns & Foster Estate Tight Top Mattress Set (Available in Soft, Firm, and Ultra Firm)
4.2 out of 5 stars
stars298 ratings298 reviews
  1. 5 stars73% (217)
  2. 4 stars7% (20)
  3. 3 stars2% (6)
  4. 2 stars6% (19)
  5. 1 star12% (36)
Sort by |
Showing 101-110 of 298 reviews
Jan 22, 2026
Nonnie & Poppy
5 out of 5 stars review

Second Stearns&Foster mattress.

We bought a firm mattress about three years ago and it was terribly firm. Too firm on our backs. We thought we would just get accustomed to it but it didn’t get any better so we decided to go to another store and see if we could just get another less firm mattress. Yes, we should have gone back to the original store (2 hours away) and see what could be done as far as an exchange or such but being busy retired people, we just didn’t do that. Having gone to a local store here, we were greeted by a very helpful salesman who guided us in purchasing a new mattress top. We received the mattress yesterday and slept on it last night. We noticed a great change in comfort for us. I would definitely select the Stearns and Foster brand and make sure to try them out.

Review from Stearns & Foster
Helpful?4NS4A7RO0O8M13935100125
Jan 23, 2026
Capt. Loren
5 out of 5 stars review

I bought two!

I’ve been extremely pleased with our Sterns & Foster’s mattresses and white glove delivery service. We purchased our second mattress from S & F and relocated our first to the guest bedroom after 13 years. Do to my up coming Lumbar Spine Surgery I wanted a new firm comfortable mattress to rely on during recovery. Luxe Estate firm works best for me. We figured we spend a third of our life’s in bed so better get the best.

Review from Stearns & Foster
Helpful?4NS4A7RO0O8M13935100125
Jan 30, 2026
Sleepy Head
5 out of 5 stars review

I love my mattress!!!

I certainly needed a new mattress as mine was about 25 years old! The sag in the middle wasn’t conducive to great sleep. It took only 2-3 nights to adjust to my new - Stearns & Foster. Am now enjoying a wonderful nights sleep. I wake up refreshed. I had hoped to make it a bit lower but the pillow top added to the height- a small price to pay - great quality- good decision on my part!

Review from Stearns & Foster
Helpful?4NS4A7RO0O8M13935100125
Feb 9, 2026
Back Pain Free Sleeper
5 out of 5 stars review

Plush Pillow-Top Luxury That Delivers Real Sleep

If you’re wanting a firm feel without sacrificing comfort, this California King Estate Collection Firm Pillow Top Mattress delivers exactly that. The pillow-top layer adds just enough plushness to soften the initial feel while the firm support core keeps my spine aligned night after night. I noticed less back stiffness and pain in the mornings and the roomy California King size is ideal if you just love extra space. You're buying top quality when you purchase a Stearns & Foster mattress. I don't like the fact that the mattress is really high. I need to use a little stool to get help me climb into bed at night.

Review from Stearns & Foster
Helpful?4NS4A7RO0O8M13935100125
Feb 22, 2026
William S
5 out of 5 stars review

What your body needs!

This Mattress replaced our first STEARNS and FOSTER MATTRESS which we enjoyed for 16 years. To be honest I never really thought of looking at any other brand after experiencing the difference with the last one. The quality is exceptional and the comfort is worth every penny spent. My back and muscles remind me of that every day.

Review from Stearns & Foster
Helpful?4NS4A7RO0O8M13935100125
Jan 16, 2026
Annoyed Sleeper
1 out of 5 stars review

Overpriced junk.

Our mattress is only 2-3 years old and it has utterly failed. I am 160 lbs at 6’ and I sink halfway below the edge of the mattress, my SO is short and petite. We keep our mattress clean, protected and constantly rotate. This is not a firm mattress. By ANY measure. But I am stuck with it because it is not collapsed, S&F has so cleverly hid behind the “Comfort Preference” of their sham of a warranty. Almost 3k down the drain for nothing. I am so beyond frustrated and annoyed that this is the situation I have been put in that I am seriously considering civil options.

Review from Stearns & Foster
Helpful?4NS4A7RO0O8M13935100125
Jan 26, 2026
Unhappy Sleeper
5 out of 5 stars review

Stearns & Foster Estate Collection mattress

We purchased a King-size Stearns & Foster Estate Collection mattress (medium firmness) last year, and unfortunately, it has been a major disappointment. We sink in much more than expected and can actually feel the steel coils through the mattress, which makes it very uncomfortable to sleep on. This is the worst mattress we have ever owned, and we would not recommend it.

Review from Stearns & Foster
Helpful?4NS4A7RO0O8M13935100125
Jan 12, 2026
Jim M
5 out of 5 stars review

I should have known better

I used to own Sterns and Foster mattresses years ago, and we moved down south. Bought some Sealy's for our bedrooms. Big mistake. I literally threw out our Sealy's and ordered the Sterns and foster. What a difference a great mattress makes. (and by the way, my Sealy's cost me a bundle anyway). Bravo S&F!

Review from Stearns & Foster
Helpful?4NS4A7RO0O8M13935100125
Feb 2, 2026
not pleased
3 out of 5 stars review

Solid, extremely heavy.

I wish I knew how heavy this mattress was going to be, we have a difficult time tucking in the sheets and blanket. Our old mattress did not sag in the middle, I have to work myself to the side with this one. I also wake up in the middle of the night now since we bought this mattress with pain in my hands, I've tried changing pillows but it doesn't make a difference. Turning the mattress is a real chore. I did not read reviews before buying.

Review from Stearns & Foster
Helpful?4NS4A7RO0O8M13935100125
Jan 30, 2026
JT
5 out of 5 stars review

Review of the Stearns & Foster Estate Firm Mattress

From the perspective of someone with chronic lumbar back issues After years of wrestling with lower‑back pain and waking up feeling like I’d slept on a crooked park bench, I finally decided to invest in the Stearns & Foster Estate Firm mattress. I went into it cautiously—firm mattresses can be hit or miss when you have lumbar problems—but after several weeks of sleeping on it, I’m genuinely impressed. Comfort & Support The standout feature is the lumbar support. The mattress has a firm, stable surface that doesn’t sag or let your hips sink too deeply, which is crucial for keeping the spine aligned. I noticed within the first few nights that I wasn’t waking up with that familiar tightness in my lower back. The support feels intentional rather than just “hard,” which is a big difference. Pressure Relief Even though it’s firm, it isn’t rigid. The top layers have enough cushioning to relieve pressure around the hips and shoulders without compromising the support underneath. For someone who alternates between back and side sleeping, this balance matters more than I realized. Build Quality Stearns & Foster is known for craftsmanship, and it shows. The mattress feels substantial and well‑constructed, with no edge collapse when sitting or lying near the sides. It has that luxury‑hotel sturdiness that makes you feel like it’s going to last. Temperature I tend to sleep warm, and this mattress has stayed comfortably neutral. No overheating, no waking up sweaty—just a consistent, cool sleep surface. Overall Experience For the first time in a long time, I’m waking up without that dull lumbar ache. The Estate Firm strikes a sweet spot: supportive enough to keep my spine aligned, but cushioned enough to feel comfortable rather than punishing. If you have lower‑back issues and prefer a firm, stable sleep surface, this mattress is absolutely worth considering.

Review from Stearns & Foster
Helpful?4NS4A7RO0O8M13935100125