Bought the S2 Smart Scale about a month ago. It does what it's advertised to do. I like that multiple people can use it and that it can automatically differentiate between people. As well as taking that data and integrating it into the stats depending on your watch model. The only issue that I have is with connectivity during initial setup. I found that it won't connect to wireless for two reasons if you have your home network configured a certain way, which I didn't see mentioned in the manual: 1. The network CANNOT be hidden 2. You can't have the SSID broadcast with smart frequency negotiation, you have to broadcast each frequency (2.4Ghz and 5 Ghz) and that it can only connect to 2.4 So, it took a bit of troubleshooting to get it setup. Other than those 2 reasons, I love the scale.

I am disappointed in the scale accuracy for percent body fat. It is off over 10% for me compared with an In Body reading 4 months ago. I’ve lost 7 pounds since my In Body reading of 20% and Garmin scale reads 33% body fat. I am still the athletic post-menopausal woman with excellent muscle definition in legs and arms who exercises daily. I expected a drop in % body fat, not a 13% increase!

I bought this scale to go with my new Garmin smartwatch. The scale itself looks great. The readout is easy to read, and I like the different measurements it tracks. I do not like how the Gramin Connect app works with it. On the scale, it shows red for measurements I need to work on, but in the app, it only shows the measurements, and there is no comparison to what it should be. I would like more detailed information in the app to go along with the scale.

I agree with most posts that accuracy of the fat percentage or any of the others is questionable at best. However, it does trend nicely and is saved in Garmin Connect which is very nice so that I do not have to do any of that manually. It was easy to set up and is a nice looking scale. Not worth it unless you are into the Garmin subsystem but very nice if you are.

Like the scale; however, there seems to be no information from Garman on the information provided. For example, how do I compare my bone density or body mass to what? A score of XXX compared to what range? A body mass index score, by itself, tells me nothing or I don't know compared to what!

I had version one till I got this for Xmas. It's not quite the upgrade I thought it would be. Mainly because it is a bunch of redundant information I see on Garmin Connect, which I am on a lot and prefer to view there rather than on the scale screen. Also, on a wood floor, I have to "tap it" before stepping on it. For some reason, if I just step on it, it doesn't recognize that I am standing on it. not a big deal, but weird.

I have been seriously working out and improving my diet for the last year. And my weight has not dropped as much as I planned. My BMI has decreased a bit but my body fat has dropped significantly and my % water has increased significantly. That tells me that my efforts are working. The scale is a great tool and it keeps me motivated. If you are someone that tracks your effort then this is a must have. My gripe is that I have had to reset it a few times over the year because it stops calculating BF%. That can be a PITA but other than that, I highly recommend having this scale.

I've had this scale for several months now but have only just started using it over the last month or so. It was a bit of a challenge to set it up as it needs to be connected to the internet to work (i.e. - I could not figure out to use it as a stand-alone scale), but once connected, it works fine. Provides all kinds of information (water weight, bone weight, BMI, even weather...). But, overall, it does a good job for what it does...

I bought this scale a few weeks ago and I’ve been loving the information I’m gathering from it. It is such a game changer. Only downside that I wish wasn’t a thing is that it has to be connected to WiFi to sync data onto the app, and my whole apartment is too far from the WiFi router for the scale to connect so I haven’t been able to sync data or see how the app analyses my data yet.

Been a garmin devices fan this scale is an excellent way to track your weight and more, very accurate and reliable.