These have been the best muck boots. My daughter works on a horse farm. These boots are warm and roomy enough to wear a couple pairs of socks in the cold. They are not completely water proof but her feet do not get soaked, just slightly damp. She wears a size women's 8 1/2 shoe and the men's size 8 is a perfect fit. The tops tend to be a little snug so if you need a wide calf they might not be a good fit. The pair that she has been wearing has lasted 2 years working 2 days a week.

I bought these for my 13 year old who spends lots of time outside. My 17 year old liked them, so I ordered him a pair. They aren't insulated, but we've had mild winter weather so they're still wearing them regularly.

Great boots for the price. Knocked off two stars because they are so tight through the ankle (front top of foot through the back achilles heel part) I can hardly get them off without help and I don't have a big or wide foot. I use them less because they're so hard to get off.

Around Christmas 2018 my husband bought a pair of these boots for me because we live on a farm and I am always walking around the fields etc. I had them for a few weeks and they both leaked water around the toe area and got my socks wet. We bought some Flex Seal and it help a little. When Sam's Club had a special on them Nov. 2019 I decided to try it one more time. The first time I wore them the left foot leaked when I stepped in a puddle of water the right foot didn't. I would not buy them again.

The description stated that these boots are waterproof but they aren't, At best you can say water resistant. The soles opened up and fell apart within 3 days. I even tried to super glue it but still wont hold up.

I just got these and loved them. They are lightweight, comfortable, fit well but...I wore them three times, one time for only about 3 minutes and they already leak. So disappointing!

Had them for a month and the plastic is coming off my heel. Will be returning them. They we're comfortable. Just wish they were more durable.

Had them 1 month and the bottom began separating from the sides.

My husband wore this 1 time, only to get his feet wet with a hole in the bottom. Returning them.

Leak at the seams...not very waterproof..bummer