I read all the glowing reviews for Member's Mark Solid Albacore tuna in water, however; I cannot give such a positive review. I bought this 8-pack tuna on a recent instore shopping trip and it was terrible. The tuna had quite a fishy odor, more than tuna generally does and it tasted terrible. I normally buy a brand name tuna but thought I'd give this a try. There's no comparison. This is one of those "stick with name brand" items and I will never purchase the Member's Mark substitute for solid albacore tuna. I actually got an upset stomach after several bites of a sandwich made from this tuna so there is no way I could give it better than a 1-star review. I'll pay more for less next time and get the name brand.

I once live near a Bumble bee cannery. Always bought Bumble Bee Tuna. Moved away but cont to buy Bumble Bee, always white, packed in water. Went to a Sam's Club, only had Members Mark that day, was busy, So I bought it any way. I have never bought Bum Bee since. Sam's albacore tuna is just the best. There are actual chunks of solid tuna in water. The water smells fresh %26 is clear, the tuna is packed tightly %26 white. I was so pleasantly surprised. Bum Bee is not solid, lots of flakes that drain away with the water, which means less tuna! I will never buy another brand, my family even noticed the fresh taste of the salad %26 seemed to like having some larger chunks of tuna in their sandwiches. Oh yeah, our tuna dip for game time has made a real comeback. Thanks Sam's, please keep this on your shelves. We love it!

I always weigh my food and keep track of that macros that I eat. In the past I bought other tuna brands from Sam's Club and noticed that when it says the can says I should have have 113 grams after draining and instead I only receive 85 grams of tuna after draining something is terribly wrong and cause me to doubt the macros listed on the label. However, I was pleasantly surprised with this Members Mark Premium Albacore Tuna. After draining this tuna I noticed my scale said 113 grams. So far, I've only eaten two of the eight cans but I am not only pleased with the taste and the quality but well as the quantity provided.

Great quality tuna that is firm, not mushy. I definitely recommend this tuna to my friends & family.

This tuna has been consistently high quality, unlike the varyng quality of the name brand tuna I used to buy.

My go-to canned tuna - good taste, good quality, good price, and conveniently packaged as a cube of 8 cans.

Love this tuna, makes great salad and great in a casserole; I especially like it when I do my 3 day military diet plan.

Worst tuna I've ever had. Stinks and tastes like bad fish. Tiny slivers of fish with a few chunks. Though I'd try Members Mark, put I'll stick with national brand next time.

I don’t eat tuna often, mostly sardines in olive oil these days. I grabbed a pack of MM tuna as a pantry back-up item. I tried one can and was very impressed with the quality of the fish and flavor. Makes great tuna salad!

Wow, maybe I just got a bad batch, but this tuna was gross. Smelled extra fishy and tasted like the bottom of the ocean.