Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
All Departments
All Services
Customer reviews for Beautyrest Silver Dearborn Mattress Available in Extra Firm, Medium Pillow Top, and Plush for
Beautyrest Silver Dearborn Mattress Available in Extra Firm, Medium Pillow Top, and Plush
4.5 out of 5 stars
stars
423 ratings402 reviews
  1. 5 stars72% (303)
  2. 4 stars19% (80)
  3. 3 stars4% (19)
  4. 2 stars1% (4)
  5. 1 star4% (17)

Member photos

Sort by |
Showing 11-20 of 402 reviews
Apr 19, 2024
Reviewer name: Paperplate
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

Saggy

We bought this mattress, King, medium, Aug 30, 2023, and debated returning it after about 3-4 weeks as it started to sag where we sleep! I am 6', about 220, and wife is 5'2" and about 130. We kept it until the sags got so bad we decided to get another different bed! High, very hard lump all down the middle of the bed! This bed has a 10 year warranty and a 100 night trial period! When you get beyond that 100 night you are pretty much on your own! After 3 'chat' sessions with Sam's return folks, we got them to agree to take the mattress back. They put us with Serta, who makes Simmons I guess, and that lady was adamant that we could not return it unless the matter was approved by higher ups! She kept going back to the 100 night trial being past! We bought a more expensive mattress from Sams, and at the moment we are assured by a supervisor that Sam's will refund our money! But, the one in this ad sagged significantly where we sleep[. After about 4 months it started to make a noise, 'scrunching sound' when I moved, like rubber rubbing against other rubber.

Helpful?5PH9BVBHL1TZ13884803968
reply from BeautyrestSleepExpert

Hi Paperplate. Thank you for your candor in sharing your experience with your Beautyrest Silver Dearborn Mattress, we're sorry to hear that it was not as comfortable as you'd hoped & broke down so quickly! Our mattresses are backed by a 10-year limited warranty and we expect our mattresses to provide quality sleep for years to come. It's worth ensuring your current frame or foundation is providing adequate support to the mattress as this can have a tremendous impact on how the mattress performs. That said, Sam's Club can typically walk you through the warranty claim and get you taken care of, but you can also reach out to us directly at warranty@beautyrest.com for further guidance. It sounds like you were able to come to a solution with Sam's Club, but we're sorry that the process was more difficult that anticipated. We hope that your sleep well for years to come, but let us know if we can assist moving forward!

Jun 18, 2021
Reviewer name: Ryan
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

Not "Ultra Firm"

This mattress is NOT ultra firm. Yes, they've branded it as ultra firm but there's a layer of "plush" soft material on top of the firm part. The problem is, this top layer is super low quality. I'm a 220 pound guy which isn't overly heavy and Im literally sinking 6 inches into the mattress a week after purchase. There's a valley where I sleep already! So if you need a firm mattress that you actually sleep on top of, and not sink into, look elsewhere. I'm surprised how low quality this mattress is. Ignore the reviews saying how great this thing is... It's not!

Helpful?5PH9BVBHL1TZ13884803968
reply from BeautyrestSleepExpert

Hello Ryan, thank you for taking time to leave a review. We are sorry to learn that our product did not meet your comfort needs. Please contact us at 1-888-800-9936 so we can learn more about your setup and explore some potential solutions.

Oct 31, 2021
Reviewer name: Duke
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

Low Quality - Horrible Customer Service

DO NOT buy Serta or BeautyRest! Mattress was noticeably sagging on both sides when received. After a couple of months concave on two sides. Contacted CS for a return, but it took numerous calls and e-mails to eventually schedule a pickup. Waited all day for pickup but no one showed or called. System says pickup was complete and no one home. Called CS several more times, but still no pickup scheduled and no resolution.

Helpful?5PH9BVBHL1TZ13884803968
reply from BeautyrestSleepExpert

Hi there! We would like to apologize for your recent experience. We're sorry to hear you were less than satisfied with your mattress. We would like to learn more about your specific situation and make this right. If you wouldn’t mind, please contact us at 1-888-240-1945. Thank you.

Mar 19, 2026
Reviewer name: Jack D
4 out of 5 stars
4 out of 5 stars review

Comfortable

Comfortable mattress, good value. Have in our guest bedroom Would have given it 5 stars but about a week after it was delivered when we went to make the bed, we noticed there is a 4” portion where it missed being sewn together on the underside of the mattress at the seam. Quality control should have caught that.

Review from Beautyrest
Helpful?5PH9BVBHL1TZ13884803968
Dec 29, 2024
Reviewer name: MaGum
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

Horrible Mattress Set, Poor Customer Service

Worst mattress set that I have ever purchased in my life! It felt a bit harder than I anticipated but my husband liked it for his back. We took delivery of the set in early July 2023 and by early December my husband said his side of the bed was causing him back pain. I too felt some discomfort by February. So we turned the mattress and believe me this was no small feat for to seniors in their 70’s. By March, we were awaking with serious backaches. We noticed that the mattress was sagging on the edges! I called Beautyrest customer service to explain our dilemma. We were told by the representative to take a picture of the mattress, which was reasonable. We were instructed to then remove the mattress and take a picture of the box spring, AND remove the box spring take a picture of our bed frame! I responded that this was near impossible for us septuagenarians to accomplish. The reps responded that this was the only way they would be able to address our problems with the mattress set. We have still not be able to find help removing each piece to take pictures. We have literally suffered for almost a year with this set. It has brought me to tears because my husband and I have daily backaches that go away only after we take pain pills. We are once again, currently trying to find two young men who will charge us an affordable amount to help us moving each piece to take pictures. So disappointed with this expensive purchase

Helpful?5PH9BVBHL1TZ13884803968
reply from BeautyrestSleepExpert

Hi there, we are sorry to hear about the difficulties you have had submitting photos for your warranty claim. We recommend seeing if there is a friendly neighbor nearby who will be able to help, or a family member who can also assist. This way you can get the help you need to proceed with your claim. If neither of these are options, using a service like Task Rabbit is another great way to get some additional help. We hope this helps!

Sep 14, 2026
Reviewer name: Irene P
4 out of 5 stars
4 out of 5 stars review

Very comfy and supportive bed

Got the mattress on sale, so far no problem with the quality. However I wish I order 14 inch thick. I fi d the 16 inches to hight for me.

Review from Beautyrest
Helpful?5PH9BVBHL1TZ13884803968
Feb 9, 2026
Reviewer name: Larry E
5 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 stars review

Haven't slept on it yet

Although we haven't slept on it yet, it has to be a vast improvement of sinking 6 inches and having to rock and roll just to get out of bed. Heeheehee

Review from Beautyrest
Helpful?5PH9BVBHL1TZ13884803968
May 14, 2023
Reviewer name: VivianHues
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

Extra Firm is awful

I did not see that the item was not available for return until this morning. It has been less than 24 hours of having the mattress and I hate it. If I can't have a return, can I please have some sort of an exchange?

Helpful?5PH9BVBHL1TZ13884803968
reply from BeautyrestSleepExpert

Hi Vivian- we're sorry this mattress isn't a good fit for you. We don't offer exchanges but all Beautyrest mattresses are part of our 120 Night In-Home trial which means you can return this for a full refund for any reason within the first 6 months. Please reach out to our Serta Simmons call center at (385) 256-9674 so they can assist you with the return- thanks!

Mar 2, 2026
Reviewer name: Chris C
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

Not the same quality BeautyRest as the old one

This is the second BeautyRest I purchased. The first one was fabulous and well used for 15 years. However this one leaves me tossing and turning and my body is stiff and sore in the morning.

Review from Beautyrest
Helpful?5PH9BVBHL1TZ13884803968
Sep 5, 2026
Reviewer name: Laura H
3 out of 5 stars
3 out of 5 stars review

Firm and satified

Nothing worst the laying on a solf bed. I want firm everyday

Review from Beautyrest
Helpful?5PH9BVBHL1TZ13884803968