I’ve purchased the Members Mark version for a number of years, so I didn’t hesitate when I saw the label marked as an improved version. Not an improvement. The clumps are much heavier and don’t hold together, and I think the odor control is much worse too.

This is the worst cat litter I have ever bought!! It doesn't cover up the smell at all. It tracks everywhere!! The clumps fall apart when you scoop them and it's super dusty. Only tried this because the brand we normally use had been out of stock for weeks and this was a good deal......Save your money don't buy it

I bought this cat litter for the price. After all, it's $5 cheaper than the next cheaper cat litter, and the label says "new & improved." It has to be good for the price, right? Not at all. The clumping ability of this litter is the problem. For some reason, it doesn't dry cat pee effectively, so while it technically clumps, it breaks apart very easily when you try to scoop it up. It's like a non-clumping cat litter pretending to be scoopable. I do not recommend this cat litter at all.

It is an economical and effective product. I'm particularly pleased with the transition to 100% recyclable materials in the pails. Previously, the pails had a metal bail which had to be removed prior to my local transfer station accepting them for recycling.

I purchased this to try because I've been having difficulty getting my regular Fresh Step from Chewy lately due to supply issues. This was considerably cheaper so I was very hopeful it would work for my two babies. The first few days it seemed to work well but I did notice that the clumping properties worked well only if the cat went exclusively in the center of the box (would make an easy to scoop puck) but if they peed near the sides of the boxes it would spread out everywhere and make a chunk of concrete along the wall that was so difficult to scoop. Then it started to retain an ammonia smell even after scooping out everything I possibly could. It has zero long-term odor control unfortunately. Unfortunately this wasn't the bargain I was hoping it to be.

I normally get fresh step for my cats. But after the latest price increase decided to look elsewhere and try this one. First thing it smells off putting, before it's even used, and once it is used it smells like they went in the middle of the room not in the box. Within the first day my house smells like the typical I own cats and I don't properly clean the litter boxes house, and I scoop them twice a day!. Gross.

In sifting this with a wire mesh cat box scoop, it is approximately 25% small gravel and not clumping material. The clumping is SO sub par. Remains like wet mud forever. Terrible, terrible purchase even for the lesser price from other products. I've learned my lesson to NEVER buy this litter again.

We have been using the older Members Mark clumping cat litter for years. We are a multiple cat household and the old formula clumped the urine well into balls, rarely fell apart and controlled the odor. When they repackaged the litter and said it had superior clumping and odor control we were hoping it had improved. We noticed it was more clay like and a different consistency. When trying to scoop urine it DOES not clump AT ALL. Even if it's not fresh urine, it still falls apart and the uric acid from the urine is atrocious because it doesn't remove it or control the odor enough that it stings my eyes. It's not any change in my cats because it only has been since we have been buying the new litter. Please bring back the OLD formula!!!

This cat litter does not clump 70% of the time. It makes the litter box smell terrible after only a couple of days. Regular name brand clumping cat litter I could just scoop and only change once every week and a half. I have to change the whole box with this after less than a week so no savings at all! Total waste of money.

I use the Members Mark Scented Scoopable Cat Litter all the time for our two indoor cats. I find that it works as well as some of the higher priced name brands. If I could improve it I think that the scent could be a little stronger but all in all I'll continue to use it.