Bought this because of the price and the bucket packaging. Performance is less than satisfactory. Does not clump or contain oder! When you try to scoop, the “clump” falls apart and makes it almost impossible to remove. I have a recommendation for this product. DO NOT BUY!

Member's Mark seems to have improved this litter over the previous scoopable litter. I noticed less dust, thank goodness, and improved clumping that holds together better when being scooped. The cost for the size cannot be beat. The only thing I cannot comment on is the scent of the litter due to my inability to smell at this time.

The litter has improved some, but the odor control needs more improvements. The litter was scooped daily and there still is an odor of a "litter box" hours later lingering in the air. Clumping isn't too bad and tracking doesn't travel to the 3rd floor like it used too. Dust isn't quite bad either.

I have three cats and tried this Litter in one of our litter boxes along side 2 boxes of our standard litter. They used this one just as much with no difference in preference. This one is considerably cheaper per pound than our regular litter. Price is good. But if the cats won't use it it is useless. Our cats did use it that makes it great.

Loved the prior version, but the dust was significant. But the cost and size were perfect and scoopable/clumping feature was wonderful. After not having available and using the Walmart Special Kitty while Members Mark was being revised, its nice to have this back. No dust - its' great!

We exclusively use Tidy Cats but decided to try this for the savings. Cheaper is not better! It hardly clumps, therefore you can't get the litter box cleaned well, and then you can smell urine. 2 weeks of using it and our cat started pooping next to his litter box

The litter itself is a little more "clay-y" than say the little grey balls of Tidy cat but it was sufficient for the job at a cheaper price. Clumped just fine. That being said I am comparing to Tidy Cat who I feel has changed their formulas within the last year and I'm no longer satisfied with.

I recently tried this brand for the first time. Compared to tidy cat that I usually buy it clumps so well! Easy to scoop out. There is about the same amount of litter that comes out with the cats as the others and covering the odor about the same. The $$ value is great, I just wished it was lighter. Kind of hard to carry up a flight of stairs.

Best litter for the best price, although it has gone up from $9 in the past, but so has everything else. I have joined Sams Club just to buy this litter and have used this for over 10 years until they discontinued it last year?, so glad to see that Sams is making it available again.

It’s not horrible but it doesn’t hold a flame to other brand name litter. I have 5 cats and 6 litter boxes, cleaned every other day. Within 7 days, these boxes are ready to be completely changed out because the smell just wafts, despite using baking soda based deodorizing powder, deodorizing air fresheners, and air purifiers. I will continue to purchase because we are trying to save money, but will use another reviewer’s advice and mix with quality litter.