This cat litter is horrible!. I couldn't get my usual brand, so I decided to try this one. It's moister than most brands, and it clumps into a sticky mess that clings to your scoop, especially if your cat pees close to the side of the litter box. It doesn't control the odor either. I'm glad I only bought one container. Never again!

This is my go to cat litter. It has proven to be far better than the national name brands for quality, odor control, superior clumping and low tracking. It also last longer and the price is terrific. My cats will actually seek out where this litter is in the pan if I run out and use another brand. You can’t go wrong with this litter.

Most Member's Mark stuff is very very good, so was excited to start using this litter once I found it. The clumps it forms from urine do NOT hold together when you go to scoop them out, all they do is break into a million pieces of pee soaked powder. This makes the litter smell horribly very quickly. 100% going back to Tidy cats which clumps as hard as stones.

It lists superior clumping on the front of the product but it does not clump. Urine just disintegrates when you try to scoop it and after a week or two it smelled very strongly of ammonia. I had to replace the litter when half of it was still left just because it was full of disintegrated, concentrated urine.

I purchased two containers of this litter because Sam's club is not that close to me. What a waste of money! This is the worst cat litter I have ever purchased. The clumps fell apart as soon as you try to scoop them. The odor control was non-existent. If It wasn't such a trip, I would have returned them.

I don't understand all the positive reviews on here. I purchased this because Sam's was out of the scoop away I usually buy. It forms very small clumps which means at least twice as long to sift through the box. And there is so much dust--I'm fairly certain I've taken a couple years of my life with as much dust I've inhaled from this stuff! So it takes longer to clean the box and the whole time you are sticking your face in a dust cloud.

I don’t know if the formula changed, but it’s absolutely terrible now. To the point where I went out of my way to come here to say this. It does not clump well anymore and it is probably the worst litter I’ve ever used. And I have used some cheap litters in the past. I used to love it, but until I get word that something changes, I will never purchase it again. My first members mark product that I am disappointed in

This used to be a great cat litter, it always clumped well, and stayed fresh. Lately, it has awful clumping and the litterbox smell gets out of hand after only a day. I'm not sure what happened. Seems like shrinkflation may be the issue, made the formula cheaper to make by lowering the clumping and odor agents it is cheaper to make and then charge more for it? Is it a victim of corporate/shareholder profits? Sadly, it's just not good any more.

This litter is ok. I used to get refills at Petco but their litter has changed and doesn’t clump as well. I really wish this didn’t come in plastic. The rim of the top hurts my hands and when I have to lift it. It’s super heavy. Cardboard would be lighter and much less wasteful and not as bad for the environment.

We usually like members mark products but I've not come across litter this bad in 30yrs. It turns into a wet, slimy, sticky, stinking mess in no time. I'd of been better off using a shovel full of garden soil in the litter box. At least I could get it off the sides. Yuck!!