Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
All Departments
All Services
Customer reviews for Beautyrest Silver Dearborn Mattress Available in Extra Firm, Medium Pillow Top, and Plush for
Beautyrest Silver Dearborn Mattress Available in Extra Firm, Medium Pillow Top, and Plush
4.5 out of 5 stars
stars
417 ratings396 reviews
  1. 5 stars72% (300)
  2. 4 stars19% (78)
  3. 3 stars4% (18)
  4. 2 stars1% (4)
  5. 1 star4% (17)

Member photos

Sort by |
Showing 11-20 of 396 reviews
Jun 26, 2025
LS
1 out of 5 stars review

Horrible Customer Service

I will never order from Sam's online again. We received a defective mattress and have spent hours over several days trying to connect with Sam's Online Customer Service to get the issue resolved. We are asked for our phone number and promised to be called back if we get disconnected. We NEVER get called back and always just sit on hold forever and never get reconnected Each new person we talk to has a different story of what is happening with our case. We were told at one time that a new mattress was being shipped - not true. Another time we were told that the old mattress was going to be picked up - not true. We finally had to contact Beautyrest and they are sending us an email with information on how to send pictures and request a replacement (something the first 3 people we talked to at Customer Service promised to do but never did). Update: It has been over a month and we still have not received a replacement mattress. We have scheduled a delivery twice and both times we got a notice of cancellation a few days prior because the product had not been delivered from the warehouse. It has been a nightmare experience.

Helpful?5PH9BVBHL1TZ13879813737
reply from BeautyrestSleepExpert

Hi there, thank you for taking the time to review your mattress. We are sorry to hear about your experience when trying to communicate with the Sam's Club team. We are happy you have been pointed in the right direction so that your warranty claim can be evaluated. Rest assured, Sam’s Club offers a 100% member satisfaction guarantee, so if you need additional assistance, please reach out to Sam’s Club member phone number 888-802-2948. We hope this helps!

Sep 3, 2024
cc27
5 out of 5 stars review

Great mattress, love the extra firm

I have this mattress for about 2 months now. It's very good quality and I love the extra firm. I don't feel it's too hard at all, it's more like a firm mattress. The delivery can be improved though. The delivery guys were just going to leave it at the garage. Luckily I saw it and asked them to bring it in.

Helpful?5PH9BVBHL1TZ13879813737
Jun 18, 2021
Ryan
1 out of 5 stars review

Not "Ultra Firm"

This mattress is NOT ultra firm. Yes, they've branded it as ultra firm but there's a layer of "plush" soft material on top of the firm part. The problem is, this top layer is super low quality. I'm a 220 pound guy which isn't overly heavy and Im literally sinking 6 inches into the mattress a week after purchase. There's a valley where I sleep already! So if you need a firm mattress that you actually sleep on top of, and not sink into, look elsewhere. I'm surprised how low quality this mattress is. Ignore the reviews saying how great this thing is... It's not!

Helpful?5PH9BVBHL1TZ13879813737
reply from BeautyrestSleepExpert

Hello Ryan, thank you for taking time to leave a review. We are sorry to learn that our product did not meet your comfort needs. Please contact us at 1-888-800-9936 so we can learn more about your setup and explore some potential solutions.

May 3, 2026
JESSICA
3 out of 5 stars review

Lasts 3-4 years

This mattress was great—until it wasn't. About 3 years in, it started to noticeably have sagging on both sides. By year 4, it was completely done. The back pain is excruciating. Disappointing for a mattress that was sold as lasting 10 years.

Helpful?5PH9BVBHL1TZ13879813737
reply from BeautyrestSleepExpert

Hi there, thank you for taking the time to review your Beautyrest Silver Dearborn Mattress. Your feedback is valuable to us. We are sorry to hear about your experience. If your mattress has begun to sag, it may have a manufacturing defect. If that is the case, we encourage you to reach out to your retailer to begin the warranty claim process. If approved, you may qualify for a replacement mattress, which should help you get the wonderful nights of sleep that you deserve. If you would like to share more with us, feel free to reach out to our team directly through the Contact Us page on our website with any questions, comments, or concerns.

Mar 2, 2026
Chris C
1 out of 5 stars review

Not the same quality BeautyRest as the old one

This is the second BeautyRest I purchased. The first one was fabulous and well used for 15 years. However this one leaves me tossing and turning and my body is stiff and sore in the morning.

Review from Beautyrest
Helpful?5PH9BVBHL1TZ13879813737
Feb 9, 2026
Larry E
5 out of 5 stars review

Haven't slept on it yet

Although we haven't slept on it yet, it has to be a vast improvement of sinking 6 inches and having to rock and roll just to get out of bed. Heeheehee

Review from Beautyrest
Helpful?5PH9BVBHL1TZ13879813737
May 14, 2023
VivianHues
1 out of 5 stars review

Extra Firm is awful

I did not see that the item was not available for return until this morning. It has been less than 24 hours of having the mattress and I hate it. If I can't have a return, can I please have some sort of an exchange?

Helpful?5PH9BVBHL1TZ13879813737
reply from BeautyrestSleepExpert

Hi Vivian- we're sorry this mattress isn't a good fit for you. We don't offer exchanges but all Beautyrest mattresses are part of our 120 Night In-Home trial which means you can return this for a full refund for any reason within the first 6 months. Please reach out to our Serta Simmons call center at (385) 256-9674 so they can assist you with the return- thanks!

Nov 21, 2025
Aimee
1 out of 5 stars review

Mattress is as hard as a rock. Trying to get a hold of someone to return it has been an absolute nightmare. Sam's customer service is awful. Serta's customer service is worse. Call and get a message that they are in a team meeting and then call disconnects. Absolutely horrible. I don't think I will continue my Sam's membership after this terrible experience.

Helpful?5PH9BVBHL1TZ13879813737
reply from BeautyrestSleepExpert

Hi there, thank you so much for taking the time to review your mattress, your feedback is very important to us. We are sorry to hear that the mattress is not providing you with the experience you are looking for. If you are still within your Sam's Club return or exchange period we recommend reaching out to them to see if you still can do so. Sam’s Club offers a 100% member satisfaction guarantee for additional assistance please reach out to Sam’s Club member phone number 888-802-2948. We hope this helps!

Sep 7, 2025
Marla K
5 out of 5 stars review

Great mattress for extra firm

My husband needed a very firm mattress and this mattress is definitely extra firm. I like to have a little softer so we ended up putting a Tempur-pedic pad on top of it and he seems happy with that and I’m happy with it. Mattress seems very well built

Review from Beautyrest
Helpful?5PH9BVBHL1TZ13879813737
Nov 24, 2025
farmerinthedell
1 out of 5 stars review

Was comfortable the first 6 months

Looks good and comfortable but after 6 months, we began to feel a depression in the mattress where we each slept. After 9 months a depression where we slept was noticeable and we could feel a ridge in the middle of the mattress that is now even more pronounced after 1 year. It was comfortable the first 6 months, but after the depressions were we slept and the ridge formed, it became less comfortable. The ridge in the middle makes it difficult to sleep near the center of the bed. We are not heavy in weight, or overweight, and that makes us wonder if the material used in the mattress is very good material. We would not purchase again nor can we recommend this mattress or the material used to make it. The original coil mattress we had originally lasted over 30 years and was very comfortable until a spring broke. This mattress did not last one year.

Helpful?5PH9BVBHL1TZ13879813737
reply from BeautyrestSleepExpert

Hi there, thank you for taking the time to review your mattress. We are sorry to hear about the issues you are facing. The issue you are describing does not sound normal. We highly recommend reaching out to your original purchasing store and filing a warranty claim so this can be looked at and evaluated. If your mattress is found to be affected by a manufacturing defect, you should be able to get a replacement. Sam’s Club offers a 100% member satisfaction guarantee for additional assistance please reach out to Sam’s Club member phone number 888-802-2948. We hope this helps!