This pimento cheese must have been mislabeled. It was supposed to be the original flavor but it definitely had jalapeños in the mixture. Just didn’t have a good flavor. I returned it. Would not purchase this brand again.

it was the worst pimento cheese i have ever had we had 15 people for thanksgiving as always we stuffed celery with pimento cheese there is usually nothing left this year it was thrown away i will never buy this brand again

Good product but not the best for grilled cheese or on veggies. Cheese needs to be grated finer and needs more mayonnaise. I prefer a milder cheddar cheese taste.

I had never had Pawleys Island Pimento Cheese before and I will definitely be going back for more! This is by far better than any of the other brands on the market. I love the sharp cheese and spices they use.

I have purchased this many times, have always been very pleased but the first of January 2026. i purchased one and it had so much sodium/salt or ? that it had to be trashed. Was the recipie changed? Will not purchase this item for a few months.

I love *pimento* cheese. THIS is *NOT* true "pimento cheese" but a product that uses mayonnaise (rather than "salad dressing") and adds cream cheese to the mixture. It's bland and has an almost rancid flavor due to the mayo and cream cheese. *REAL* "Pimento Cheese," and the "better" brands (Mrs. Weaver's, Price), is grated cheddar cheese, salad dressing (quite different than mayo), and pimentos - absolutely *no* cream cheese or mayo.

Absolutely delicious well bye again

I really like that it’s got a bit of a kick

Love this!!! We always keep this in the fridge as a snack staple.

Good snack with sesame sticks