Customer reviews for Member's Mark Hotel Premier 14" Hybrid Mattress (Available in Medium, Plush, and Firm) forComfortable and More Affordable
Choosing a mattress is a lot of work. We first decided what type of mattress we wanted. We tried out several options at furniture stores and Mattress Firm and realized that we wanted a Medium-Firm Hybrid with cooling layers on top. This Member's Mark mattress was the most affordable mattress that I could find that matched all of our requirements and it is a bonus that it is 14 inches. We bought the medium and we absolutely love it. It may be very similar to the Nectar Hybrid 14 inch. Great job Sam's Club! We hope that more Member's Mark products that are good quality like this one are available in the future. Thank you!
Hi Houston family - We are pleased to hear that you are loving your new mattress! Thank you for your purchase :)
defective
Don't waste your time on this mattress. We had two more delivered after the first one was faulty, the first replacement mattress being both the wrong size and the wrong model. Turns out both the first and the third were faulty. Neither expanded to the full 14" height after more than a week of inflate time, both were 70" instead of 75". The return/replacement process is a nightmare. A private shipping company, which was terrible to deal with, was dispatched to our house to collect the mattress. The first replacement mattress was a California King instead of a twin. Unfortunately, we did not figure this out until it had expanded partially on my child's bed and partially on the floor. When I spoke with someone about the issue, I was told that my child could sleep on the california king on the floor while we awaited the pickup and replacement of the extremely too large mattress. It was a true delight to try and get a fully expanded california king out of the room, down the stairs, and outside for the aforementioned terrible shipping company to come and pick it up. While awaiting the pickup and shipment of the appropriate size model my child was completely blocked out of her room by the mattress and forced to sleep elsewhere. After the third and final mattress arrived we set it up and let it sit for longer than the 3 recommended days. It is still just 12" high and 70" long. It does not come anywhere near filling the cover and no sheets will ever fit it. It will be going back. Both of my adult children have had great success with other Sams mattress models, but do not get this one.
Very soft, in fact too soft
If you buy the Ultra Plush, expect a SUPER SOFT mattress. In fact it is so soft, it feels like it is actually hurting rather than helping since there is virtually no support. We like a plush mattress but this is nuts. When you lie on it, and we are not big people, from the side you can only see 80% of us. Medium firm is probably the best. The other issue is sheets staying on. The cover is incredibly slick and the sheets slip off with ease. You will need a zip-on mattress cover that has some friction to keep the sheets from slipping off the corners. All it takes is getting in the bed and a corner will come off. We have the right sized, deep pocket sheets (from Sams). If your weight is in the 100 to 120 pound range, you may not sink like a rock. An average adult (I weigh 190), I am in a hole. This one is going to being returned.
Hi Greg, Thank you for taking the time to share your experience with the Plush mattress. We’re truly sorry to hear that it didn’t meet your expectations. Comfort is highly subjective, and while some customers love the deep contouring feel of the Plush, we understand it may not be suitable for everyone—especially if you're looking for more support. Your detailed feedback about the lack of support, sheet slippage, and the sinking feeling is incredibly helpful, and we’ve shared it with our product team. We always aim to match the right mattress to the right sleeper, and it sounds like a Medium Firm option may indeed be a better fit for your preferences and body type. We're also sorry to hear about the trouble with your sheets staying in place. We’ve seen success with friction-based mattress protectors, just like you suggested, and we’ll consider including that tip in future materials. We appreciate you giving it a try, and we’re glad you’re making use of our return policy—it’s there for exactly this reason. If you’d like help selecting a model that better suits your needs, our team would be happy to assist. Warm regards
overall worth the buy.
Bought roughly 6 months ago, full FIRM mattress. Allowed this to "inflate" for 72 hours before sleeping on it. I am 5'6" roughly 200 lbs and tend to sleep on my stomach and back. I rotate the mattress every 4-6 weeks. Measures at roughly 13-13.5 inches after the 72 hr period which I consider close enough to the description. Initially felt it was too soft for me, however I think it matches the "firm" description when compared to other hybrid/memory foam mattresses. So far I don't have an indention where I sleep, but I do think the regular rotation is making a difference there. I would certainly buy this again; I have recommended it to my friends since buying. Only gave 4 stars because it does get a bit warm as the night goes on which again may be par for the course when it comes to memory foam mattresses.
mattress was lopsided, the latex pad was not centered on the springs. the cover was too big for the bed. i tried 2 beds with same results. Getting sams to pick up the beds was nor a pleasant experience. i would not recommend this bed. i dont understand why this bed was given great test result on a leading reporting service.
GOAT mattress on a budget
We desperately needed a new mattress for two adults and two dogs. We are larger people and sleep with 60 lb and 12 lb dogs. This mattress is supportive for all the weight it carries from us. We got the medium so we could feel the support but also a touch of plush. Better sleep days are ahead for sure. We have been sleeping on it for about a week and my body is already feeling much better. I have arthritis and my stiffness is much improved so far. As for the unboxing, it was so simple. We opened the box and took the plastic off. The mattress looked and smelled clean. We allowed it to rise and had zero issues with it not being true to size. just buy it already!
Excellent and comfy mattress with a slight flaw
We got the medium for my son who's moving out. The mattress itself is super nice and comfy. The top is squishy which is great and what he wanted, but with some firmness. The only issue is that one side does not expand to the height of the other. We keep the smaller side at the foot of the bed. I measured and one part is at 13.5" while the other is at 13", so not quite the 14" advertised. This leaves the covering a little loose. I believe the unevenness is due to it being rolled and the inner part that is compressed the most has been comprimised.
Arrived with defects
Like other people reviewed, this mattress arrived with a defects. On one side it was 4 inches short, on the other side it was 2 inches short. The foam was also misaligned to the base so the coils stuck out 2 inches on one end and the foam stuck out 2 inches on the other end. The cover also fits loose and theres no foam protecting the bottom coils so they pushed through my bed slats. Sam's Club was great about taking care of the problem. They offered a return or replacement. I opted for a return and purchased another mattress. Sam's Club sent out somebody to pick it up for disposal. Some people had good experiences but I'd recommend going with something else.
Run and Hide
Avoid at all costs. Mattress started to break down within weeks. And now I am dealing with customer service and that is a useless and extremely exhausting experience. Return started on 2-9 and it is 2-20 and I am still waiting for a call from the carrier. Have called Sam's Club 5 times now and each time am told ATI will contact you in 24 to 72 hours. Do not buy a mattress from Sam's. Quality is garbage and customer service is even worse!!!!
Dreamy!
DREAMY! We purchased two more expensive mattress only to return for these. We are not fans of memory foam and this is a true hybrid. We choose a king split - (2) twin XL, one plush and one medium. Heavenly! The plush is very soft and the medium is on the softer side as well. Personally, I do not feel the “cooling” aspect, but they are not hot like most memory foam. Fluffed up in a couple hours and slept on them same day. Hopefully they will hold up overtime, but you cant beat the price! Highly recommend!